Reader question

A fraudster used my business account to receive money without my knowledge. What evidence should I preserve?

Answered by Advocate Sharan Jain··Cyber Crime & Online Fraud

Legal Shorts · 81 words

Notify the bank through its verified channel and preserve complete statements, transaction references, account mandates, access logs and any genuine business records explaining the credit. Record who could operate the account and every onward movement. Do not spend or privately refund disputed money on a stranger's instructions. Verify police notices and respond on supported facts with legal advice where needed. Account ownership alone does not decide involvement, and your own complaint does not automatically remove a restriction or resolve another claim.

Short sources checked:

WhatsApp

Notify the bank through its verified fraud or grievance channel, preserve the complete transaction and access records and obtain legal advice on the police response. Do not move, spend or privately refund a disputed credit just because someone claiming to be the victim asks you to. Establish what money arrived, who could operate the account and what happened next.

Your assertion that you did not know about the credit is important, but it needs a supporting chronology. The account can be investigated even if you say you were deceived. Keep the evidence of unauthorised access or misuse separate from any ordinary business payment that may have been wrongly identified.

What should I ask the bank immediately?

Identify the disputed transaction by date, amount, reference and account. Ask the bank to secure compromised access, preserve relevant logs and explain any restriction already placed on the account. Request a complaint reference and written confirmation of the instructions you receive. Use the bank's genuine channel rather than a number supplied by a stranger.

If the bank says the account is frozen or a lien has been marked, ask for the amount, scope and available identifying details of the authority or complaint. Do not assume that a debit restriction and attachment of the entire account are the same event. A bank may be unable to disclose every investigation detail, but your request and its response still belong in the file.

  • Complete statements covering the relevant period, not only one cropped credit entry.
  • Transaction identifiers, bank alerts and beneficiary or remitter details available to you.
  • Account mandates, authorised-user records and access permissions.
  • Device, email and payment-system logs lawfully available to the business.
  • Invoices, contracts and messages explaining any claimed business purpose.
  • Bank and police notices, complaints, acknowledgements and responses.

Which access evidence matters?

Record who held credentials, tokens, payment devices or delegated access and who could approve transfers. Preserve changes to registered numbers, email addresses, devices and mandates. If an employee or service provider had access, keep the engagement terms and instructions. Do not accuse that person merely because they had permission to operate the account.

Preserve evidence of compromise before resetting or replacing equipment where practicable. Coordinate urgent security action with preservation so that further loss is contained without casually wiping logs. Keep the original messages that induced any access or sharing, including a purported verification, refund or payment-processing arrangement.

What should the money trail show?

Trace the disputed credit and any onward movement using actual transaction references. Distinguish money you transferred, an automated debit and a transfer you say was unauthorised. Record who instructed each movement and what information was available at that time. A chronology that stops at the incoming credit leaves the central question unanswered.

If the money relates to an apparent sale, retain the order, invoice, delivery and customer communications. Compare the customer identity with the remitter and any person who requested a refund. Do not create an invoice after the dispute merely to explain the credit. Identify ordinary-course records and later reconstructions separately.

Do not privately redirect disputed money.
A person asking for repayment may be the victim, the fraudster or someone else. Verify the claim and use bank or lawful authority instructions. An improvised transfer can remove the traceable balance and create another dispute.

What if the police contact me?

Verify the officer and notice independently, obtain the case reference and understand whether you are being asked for documents, witness information or attendance as a person under investigation. The BNSS contains different powers for production, examination and attendance. A request concerning your account does not automatically establish guilt, and it should not be ignored.

Provide a factual response supported by the preserved records, after advice where personal exposure is possible. State what you know, what you do not know and where the supporting record is. Do not guess the identity of the sender or adopt a police summary that you cannot verify. Keep acknowledgements for documents supplied and an inventory if originals or devices are taken.

Does account ownership make me automatically liable?

No single rule turns every account holder into the author of every fraud involving the account. The relevant offence and alleged role must be examined. Cheating, personation, knowing assistance and unauthorised computer access involve different elements. Evidence of instructions, knowledge, control and onward transfers may matter. An innocent explanation should therefore be documented rather than treated as self-proving.

For current BNS and IT Act allegations, check the applicable provisions and event dates. Older conduct and pending proceedings may engage the former law and savings rules. Do not assume a new section number decides whether your conduct is criminal, and do not rely on an online label such as "mule account" as a substitute for the allegation and evidence.

Should I file my own complaint?

If you believe the account or credentials were misused, report the facts through the bank and appropriate police or cybercrime channel promptly. Identify the suspicious credit, access events and any subsequent unauthorised transactions. A complaint does not automatically release a freeze or resolve another person's claim, but it records your account of the incident at the time.

If there is ongoing financial cyber fraud, use the official national reporting process, including 1930 where applicable, and keep its acknowledgement. A corporate incident may also require a separate CERT-In assessment. Covered entities must consider the directions for reportable incidents rather than assume a police complaint discharges every reporting duty.

What should I prepare for legal review?

I would put the complete bank statement beside the access chronology and the alleged business explanation. Those three records often expose gaps that a long declaration of innocence misses. Identify the actual relief needed, such as clarification of a restriction, permission for ordinary payments or return of a seized item, rather than asking generally for the case to disappear.

The first-hour fraud answer concerns urgent reporting after a loss. The cyber-fraud guide explains reporting, and the police-notice answer addresses attendance. Preserve those separate tracks while the facts are verified.

Sources

The law this answer relies on, so you can read it yourself.

  1. 1.Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023, NCRB official text Read the source
  2. 2.Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023, NCRB official text Read the source
  3. 3.Information Technology Act, 2000, updated text Read the source
  4. 4.Bharatiya Sakshya Adhiniyam, 2023, NCRB official text Read the source
  5. 5.CERT-In directions under IT Act section 70B, 28 April 2022 Read the source
  6. 6.Ministry of Home Affairs: CFCFRMS 2.0 and 1930, 28 July 2026 Read the source

The short answer's sources were checked on 17 November 2026. Statutes and judgments can change, so check the current position before you act on anything here.

Nothing there yet? Send the question in and it gets answered here.

Related legal service

Dealing with this yourself rather than reading about it? Our Bangalore advocates work in this area.

Go deeper on this

This answer is the short version. These guides cover the same ground in full, with the procedure, the timelines and the leading cases.

SJ

Answered by

Advocate Sharan Jain

Advocate based in Bangalore, practising before the Karnataka High Court and District, Sessions, Consumer and Family courts. Answers public legal questions to make Indian law more accessible.

This answer is general information on Indian law as at November 17, 2026, published for public education. It is not legal advice, it does not take account of your facts, and reading it does not create an advocate-client relationship. Law changes and every case turns on its own circumstances. Please consult a qualified advocate about your own matter.

People also asked

Criminal Law & Bail

The police have issued me a notice to appear instead of arresting me. What does that mean?

A Section 35 BNSS notice requires you to attend and cooperate where arrest is not considered necessary. Keep the notice and evidence of your attendance. If you comply and continue to comply, the officer should not arrest you for that offence unless reasons for arrest are recorded. The notice is therefore useful protection, but it is not permanent immunity. If the date is impossible, seek a documented change rather than simply failing to turn up.

Cyber & Online Fraud

I lost money to an online scam. What do I do in the first hour?

Call 1930 and notify your bank immediately, then complete the complaint on cybercrime.gov.in. Give the transaction number, amount, time and receiving account or UPI ID. Prompt reporting can help the authorities try to stop further movement of the money, but it does not guarantee recovery. Save the messages and payment records, and secure any account the scammer accessed. Ask the bank for a complaint number and written response about your disputed transaction.

Cyber & Online Fraud

We emailed a customer spreadsheet to the wrong person. What should we do immediately?

Revoke any shared link, try an administrative recall and contact the unintended recipient through a verified channel. Preserve the original email, workbook and access logs before removing working copies. Establish which customers and data fields were affected. As at 17 November 2026, core DPDP breach duties are scheduled for May 2027, while current CERT-In, sectoral and contractual reporting obligations need prompt assessment. A recall or deletion assurance reduces uncertainty but does not prove that every copy has disappeared.

Cyber & Online Fraud

My UPI was used without my knowledge. I never shared anything. Who bears the loss?

Report the unauthorised UPI debit to your bank immediately and keep proof of the time. Under RBI rules, bank fault can mean zero customer liability. A third-party breach, with neither bank nor customer at fault, also attracts zero liability if reported within three working days of receiving the bank's communication. Customer negligence follows a different rule. Ask for the transaction and alert records. The bank bears the burden of proving customer liability under this framework.

Cyber & Online Fraud

The bank says I shared my OTP so the loss is mine. Is that actually the law?

Sharing an OTP can count as customer negligence, but the RBI rule is more specific than a blanket refusal. For an unauthorised transaction caused by that negligence, the customer bears the loss until it is reported. Losses after reporting fall on the bank. Other rules apply where the bank was at fault or a third-party breach caused the loss. Report immediately and ask the bank to identify the evidence and rule supporting its decision.

Cyber & Online Fraud

My money went into a mule account. Can the bank that holds that account be made to refund it?

A receiving account being used by scammers does not, by itself, establish that its bank must reimburse you. Report the transfer immediately through 1930 and your own bank, and provide the receiving account details to investigators. Ask for preservation of the transaction trail and action on any funds still available. Your own bank's liability for an unauthorised debit is a separate question under RBI rules. Recovery from a recipient or bank needs a basis supported by the evidence.

S Jain & Attorneys · Ask Me

Still not the question you had in mind?

Search the column, or send your question in. Questions of general interest are answered here, anonymously, so the next person does not have to ask.