Reader question

Our customer paid an employee's personal account and says the invoice is settled. Who should bear the loss?

Answered by Advocate Sharan Jain··Money Recovery & MSME Dues

Legal Shorts · 76 words

A personal-account transfer does not alone decide who bears the loss. Check the employee's actual authority, the company's representations and any informed later acceptance. Contract Act Section 226 addresses authorised receipt through an agent, Section 237 concerns company-induced belief in authority, and Sections 196-198 concern ratification. Preserve the invoice, complete instruction, bank confirmation and ledger history. Request a reasoned reconciliation before demanding or making a second payment. Any suspected fraud needs prompt bank and legal attention.

Short sources checked:

WhatsApp

The loss does not automatically fall on the customer or the company simply because the account was personal. Find out whether the employee was authorised to receive payment, whether the company created that appearance of authority, and whether the company later accepted the payment. Preserve the instruction and transfer trail before accusing either side of non-payment or fraud.

Section 226 of the Contract Act addresses the consequences of an agent's contracts and acts. Its payment illustration recognises discharge where an agent authorised to receive money receives it. Section 237 concerns a principal whose words or conduct induced a third party to believe an unauthorised act was authorised. Those are factual questions, not a rule that every employee can collect company money.

What did the invoice tell the customer to do?

Start with the issued invoice and the agreement. Identify the named payee, bank account, payment-change procedure and any warning about staff accounts. Obtain the version actually sent to the customer. An internal invoice copy does not settle what arrived in their inbox if the attachment or covering email was altered.

Ask for the complete instruction that led to the transfer. Was it sent through an established company account, a new address, a personal number or an intercepted thread? Keep headers, attachments and surrounding messages where available. A cropped screenshot of an account number may hide who gave the instruction and what assurance accompanied it.

Was the employee authorised to collect money?

Check actual authority first. Sections 186 and 187 of the Contract Act recognise express and implied authority. Look for a role description, written mandate, collection instructions and established dealings approved by the company. Authority to negotiate a price or manage a project does not necessarily include authority to receive the price personally.

Then examine what the company communicated to the customer. Did management previously confirm the account, acknowledge similar payments or permit this collection practice? A private internal prohibition and an outward company assurance may point in different directions. Section 237 makes the principal's own words or conduct material. The employee's bare claim of authority should not be treated as the whole analysis.

EvidenceIssueRelevant provision
Collection mandate and approved prior transactionsActual express or implied authorityContract Act Sections 186-187
Company assurances to the customerCompany-induced belief in authorityContract Act Section 237
Company receipt or acceptance after learning the factsPossible ratificationContract Act Sections 196-198

What happened after the transfer?

Obtain the transaction reference and reliable bank confirmation, then check the company ledger. Did the employee remit the money, issue a company receipt, apply a credit or conceal the transfer? A paid stamp made by the employee should be checked against authority and the actual accounting record.

Sections 196 and 197 of the Contract Act address ratification of acts done without authority, including ratification by conduct. Section 198 requires adequate knowledge of material facts. Do not treat an uninformed automated receipt as conclusive ratification. Equally, do not overlook a manager who knowingly accepted the arrangement after reviewing the transfer.

How should the company communicate with the customer?

Request the payment evidence and state that the account and authority are being investigated. Identify the invoice and amount without demanding an immediate second payment as though liability were already decided. A customer who relied on a company-approved collector presents a different case from someone who ignored clear, verified contrary instructions.

Keep a single authorised contact and an accurate written chronology. Avoid telling all customers that the employee stole money unless that allegation is properly supported and the communication is necessary. Your immediate task is to stop further mistaken payments, preserve evidence and establish which invoice balances remain outstanding.

Immediate internal action
Preserve the invoice, payment instruction, collection authority, transfer proof and ledger history. Restrict changes through authorised systems so that the investigation does not overwrite the records needed to establish what happened.

What should the customer do?

Supply the full instruction and transfer evidence, ask the company to state whether the employee was authorised, and request a reasoned reconciliation of the invoice. If the instruction may have been fraudulent, notify the bank through its official channel promptly and obtain advice about reporting and recovery. Do not assume a bank recall is assured.

Avoid paying twice merely to close an argument without documenting what the second payment means. If an urgent commercial settlement is necessary, record whether payment is made under a reserved claim and who will pursue the recipient. Counsel should draft that arrangement around the actual dispute. The service-agreement guide provides context for specifying payment channels and changes clearly.

How can the business prevent a repeat?

Use verified company payment details, a controlled account-change process and written customer confirmation through an established route. Separate collection authority from the ability to issue invoices or edit the ledger. Reconcile customer acknowledgements against bank receipts rather than treating an employee's statement as proof of credit.

My first legal review would trace the company's conduct as carefully as the employee's. An internal breach may give the company a claim against the employee while the customer's payment question still requires a separate authority analysis. Do not collapse those questions into one accusation. The answer on arbitration clauses is relevant if the contract directs how the resulting commercial dispute must be resolved.

If an earlier payment to the same account was accepted, preserve that complete transaction as well. Identify who at the company knew of it and what the customer was told. One approved collection does not automatically prove unlimited future authority, but omitting the prior dealing can distort the analysis.

Sources

The law this answer relies on, so you can read it yourself.

  1. 1.Indian Contract Act 1872 Read the source

The short answer's sources were checked on 17 November 2026. Statutes and judgments can change, so check the current position before you act on anything here.

Nothing there yet? Send the question in and it gets answered here.

Related legal service

Dealing with this yourself rather than reading about it? Our Bangalore advocates work in this area.

Go deeper on this

This answer is the short version. These guides cover the same ground in full, with the procedure, the timelines and the leading cases.

SJ

Answered by

Advocate Sharan Jain

Advocate based in Bangalore, practising before the Karnataka High Court and District, Sessions, Consumer and Family courts. Answers public legal questions to make Indian law more accessible.

This answer is general information on Indian law as at November 17, 2026, published for public education. It is not legal advice, it does not take account of your facts, and reading it does not create an advocate-client relationship. Law changes and every case turns on its own circumstances. Please consult a qualified advocate about your own matter.

People also asked

Arbitration & ADR

Our contract has an arbitration clause. Is it actually valid, and what does it mean for us?

An arbitration clause needs a written agreement to submit identified disputes to arbitration. That writing can include a recorded exchange of communications, rather than only a signed contract. Read the scope carefully: which disputes does it cover, and what appointment procedure does it set out? A valid clause does not make every subject arbitrable or eliminate the court's statutory role. Keep the complete contract and related communications together before deciding whether the particular dispute must go to arbitration.

Corporate & Commercial

Our vendor contract has an unlimited indemnity clause. Should we worry?

An unlimited indemnity deserves a close reading because the promised protection may extend well beyond the contract price. Section 124 of the Contract Act describes a promise to protect another party against specified loss caused by conduct. The clause still needs careful definition: what triggers it, which losses it covers, who controls a claim and when payment is due. Consider a negotiated cap and appropriate exceptions. The word 'indemnity' alone does not answer how much exposure this particular contract creates.

Corporate & Commercial

Our employee signed a customer contract without authority. Can the company still be bound?

An unauthorised signature does not automatically leave the company unbound. Check express or implied authority under Contract Act Sections 186-188, company-induced belief in authority under Section 237, and informed ratification under Sections 196-198. Preserve the signed contract, delegation, customer communications and later performance. An internal signature policy and the customer's external position are separate evidence questions. Avoid inconsistent performance or denial while reviewing the facts. Any employee disciplinary issue requires a separate assessment.

Corporate & Commercial

A capital reduction notice lists my invoice as zero. How do I object?

Respond to the capital-reduction notice with the invoices and a reconciled balance. Section 66 has its own creditor safeguards and should not be confused with the five-percent formal objection threshold for a section 230 merger. Ask that your claim be correctly recorded and protected before confirmation. Section 66 requires the Tribunal to be satisfied that creditor claims are discharged, determined, secured or consented to.

Corporate & Commercial

My lawyer recorded consent to an NCLT order that I say I never authorised. Can I appeal it?

A genuine consent order is subject to the section 421(2) appeal bar. If you say the consent was never authorised, preserve the settlement drafts, instructions and order and seek immediate advice on the correct challenge. Disputing authority is different from regretting agreed terms, and the order should not be treated as automatically suspended.

Corporate & Commercial

Private limited, LLP or proprietorship? Which should I register?

Choose a business structure around ownership, personal exposure and the way you expect to fund the business. A company limited by shares generally limits a member's liability to unpaid share capital. An LLP also has statutory protection against personal liability merely from being a partner, while responsibility for a partner's own wrongdoing remains. Compare those rules with the compliance work and investment plans for your business. The cheapest incorporation quote does not tell you which structure will work best over time.

S Jain & Attorneys · Ask Me

Still not the question you had in mind?

Search the column, or send your question in. Questions of general interest are answered here, anonymously, so the next person does not have to ask.