The company may still be bound, depending on the employee's authority, what the company led the customer to believe and what it did after learning of the contract. An internal rule saying that only directors can sign does not decide every external dispute. Preserve the complete record before denying the agreement or continuing to perform it.
The Contract Act recognises express and implied authority, ratification of unauthorised acts and liability where the principal induced belief in authority. The employee's signature is therefore the beginning of the enquiry. It is not conclusive proof either that the company accepted every term or that the agreement can be ignored.
What authority did the employee actually have?
Collect the delegation, board or management authorisation relevant to the transaction, role description and contractual approval policy. Identify the limit in force when the employee signed. A later policy cannot establish an earlier limit. Check whether the authority covered the transaction type, amount and any unusual term.
Sections 186 and 187 of the Contract Act recognise express and implied authority, including circumstances and ordinary dealings. Section 188 addresses the extent of authority for an authorised act or business. A sales manager's authority to negotiate routine orders may differ from authority to give an exceptional guarantee. The precise act and established course of business matter.
What did the company tell the customer?
Review emails introducing the employee, prior contracts signed by them, company approvals copied to the customer and website descriptions of their role. Ask whether the customer was told of the relevant limit. Do not assume every internal restriction was communicated merely because it appeared in an employee handbook.
Section 237 concerns a principal whose own words or conduct induced a third party to believe that an unauthorised act fell within the agent's authority. The customer's belief must therefore be examined against the company's conduct. An employee's unsupported claim that they can sign anything should not be treated as equivalent to a company representation.
| Question | Evidence | Contract Act provision |
|---|---|---|
| Was signing authorised? | Delegation, role and established dealings | Sections 186-188 |
| Did the company induce reliance? | Customer-facing assurances and prior approved signatures | Section 237 |
| Was the act later adopted? | Informed approval and performance after discovery | Sections 196-198 |
Can accepting the benefit ratify the contract?
It may be relevant to ratification. Section 196 permits a person to ratify or disown acts done on their behalf without authority. Section 197 recognises express or implied ratification. Section 198 requires knowledge of material facts. Examine who learned what and when before treating ordinary processing as an informed approval.
Preserve delivery, invoicing, payment and project records after discovery. A company that knowingly supplies under the signed contract may face a different argument from one that promptly objects and does not adopt it. Section 199 also makes ratification of an unauthorised act forming part of a transaction relate to the whole transaction. Do not assume the company can adopt only the profitable clause.
What if the employee exceeded only part of their authority?
Sections 227 and 228 distinguish excess authority that can be separated from the authorised act from excess that cannot. Counsel should examine the transaction as a whole before saying that one unauthorised clause invalidates everything. The provisions are fact-sensitive and do not supply an automatic rule for severing any unwanted term.
For example, review the ordinary supply obligation separately from an additional undertaking the employee purported to give. The legal question is whether the authorised and excess acts can actually be separated under the statute and documents. Do not rewrite a signed agreement internally and send the edited version as if the customer accepted it.
Keep the signed version, all attachments, signature audit trail, delegation in force, communications with the customer and later performance records. Preserve originals and version history through authorised access. Do not delete or backdate an approval to improve the company's position.
How should the company respond now?
Appoint one authorised decision-maker to review the facts and communicate with the customer. A preliminary response can identify the disputed authority and request the customer's record without making unsupported accusations. Obtain advice promptly where delivery, payment or a contractual notice date is close.
Continuing performance, suspension and repudiation each can have consequences. Do not let separate departments make inconsistent choices while the legal position is being examined. If the company decides to adopt or replace the arrangement, document that decision through the proper authority and obtain the customer's agreement to any actual change. Section 62 governs agreed alteration or substitution, not a unilateral rewrite.
Is the employee's internal responsibility a separate issue?
Yes. The company's rights against the employee and its obligations to the customer need separate analysis. A disciplinary breach does not by itself establish that the customer has no enforceable agreement. Preserve the employee's explanation and follow the applicable employment process rather than treating a commercial dispute as proof of deliberate misconduct.
My review would map actual authority, outward representations and informed later conduct on a single chronology. That usually exposes the decisive gap more clearly than debating job titles. The service-agreement drafting guide and answer on indemnity clauses show why authority limits should be matched to the risk of the particular bargain.
- Delegation or approval policy effective on the signing date.
- Executed contract and signature audit trail.
- Earlier approved contracts signed by the same employee.
- Post-discovery invoices, deliveries and management communications.
Record any corrective agreement transparently, with its real date and authorised signatures. If the customer agrees to replace a disputed term, preserve the earlier version and the amendment together. The file should show what was disputed and what was later agreed, without manufacturing an earlier authorisation.