Reader question

A marketplace removed my listing after a trademark complaint, but I sell genuine goods. What should my response include?

Answered by Advocate Sharan Jain··Intellectual Property Law

Legal Shorts · 79 words

Respond with the exact listing, complaint reference, purchase invoices and evidence tracing the goods to a lawful source. Sections 30(3) and 30(4) of the Trade Marks Act distinguish lawful resale from situations where legitimate reasons justify opposition, including changed or impaired condition. Genuine goods do not justify a misleading claim of brand authorisation. Address the actual allegation and the marketplace policy separately. Preserve the removed page and request review through the official appeal channel, with an itemised evidence bundle.

Short sources checked:

WhatsApp

Challenge the removal through the marketplace's official process with evidence of the particular goods, their lawful source and the exact listing language. Saying "the goods are genuine" is a starting point. It does not answer every trademark allegation or a separate claim about photographs, authorisation or product condition.

What exactly did the rights holder complain about?

Save the notice, complaint reference, affected listing identifiers, stated mark and available details of the complainant. Ask whether the allegation is counterfeiting, unauthorised resale, changed packaging, misuse of a logo or a misleading claim of affiliation. Those allegations require different evidence. Do not draft a generic response before identifying which one the marketplace is considering.

Preserve the removed listing as it stood, including title, photographs, seller name, product description, warranty statement and packaging claims. Keep the notification timestamp and appeal deadline displayed by the platform. Do not recreate the removed listing through a new account while the issue remains unresolved. That can add a platform-policy dispute without addressing the original complaint.

What does the Trade Marks Act say about genuine resale?

Section 30(3) of the Trade Marks Act, 1999 addresses goods bearing a registered trademark that have been lawfully acquired. It limits an infringement objection arising only from the circumstances stated there, including the goods having been put on the market by the proprietor or with consent. The source and acquisition trail therefore matter as much as the physical appearance of the product.

Section 30(4) preserves opposition for legitimate reasons, particularly where the condition of the goods has changed or been impaired after they were put on the market. Do not present section 30(3) as an unconditional right to list anything carrying the brand. Product condition, alterations and the listing's representations must be considered on their facts.

Authenticity and lawful listing are related questions. Authentic stock supports a resale response. It does not authorise you to describe yourself as the brand's official seller, copy unrelated protected content or conceal a material change in the goods.

Which purchase documents should my response include?

Provide invoices identifying the supplier, purchaser, dates, products and quantities, with enough information to match the stock to the listing. Where useful, include serial or batch numbers, payment evidence, delivery records and the supplier's confirmation. Explain gaps in the chain rather than submitting a large file that never identifies the units removed.

If the goods were imported or obtained through a distributor, identify that route accurately and obtain advice on the actual legal and contractual issues. A receipt from an unknown intermediary may prove payment without proving provenance. Do not alter invoices, conceal a material source discrepancy or claim brand authorisation because the supplier said the goods were original.

  • Marketplace complaint and listing identifiers.
  • Purchase invoices and payment records matched to the goods.
  • Serial, batch and packaging photographs preserving condition.
  • Evidence of the source chain and any actual distribution authority.
  • The listing text and images as displayed before removal.
  • A response addressing each allegation and the policy cited.

What if I changed the packaging or condition?

Disclose refurbishment, repacking, repaired parts, removed seals and any missing accessories. Compare the physical product with the description used at sale. A genuine product sold as factory-new when it is refurbished raises a different concern from an untouched item accurately described. Section 30(4)'s condition qualification should be considered before relying on lawful acquisition alone.

Preserve photographs of the units actually in stock. Catalogue photographs cannot establish their current condition. If the complaint relates to warranty, state precisely whether any manufacturer's warranty applies, whether you offer only your own warranty or whether no warranty is represented. Do not promise a manufacturer's service arrangement you cannot document.

May I use the brand name and logo in the listing?

Section 30(1) addresses use to identify goods or services as those of the proprietor, subject to honest practices and avoiding unfair advantage or detriment to the mark's character or reputation. A factual product title can be a different use from a seller banner implying that your shop is run or approved by the brand.

Review words such as "official", "authorised" and "exclusive", the placement of logos and the seller profile. Remove or correct an unsupported affiliation claim through the platform's permitted process while preserving what was originally displayed. If the complaint concerns photographs or catalogue copy, address the rights in those materials separately. Authentic stock does not itself establish permission to reuse another person's creative content.

How should the appeal be organised?

Open with the requested outcome: review and restoration of the identified listing, or permission to submit a corrected version. State the source of the goods and identify the attached evidence. Then answer the complaint point by point. Refer to the relevant statutory provision as a reason for review without asserting that the marketplace has already adjudicated the legal question.

Separate the trademark response from contractual marketplace requirements. A platform may seek defined provenance evidence or impose seller conditions, and the effect of those terms requires its own assessment. Ask which requirement remains unsatisfied if a response is rejected. A bare demand to "restore immediately under section 30" may leave the platform's actual reason unanswered.

What if the complaint appears inaccurate or abusive?

Ask the platform for the allegation and evidence it can disclose, preserve its response and seek a review by the designated team. If the complainant is willing to clarify or withdraw a mistaken report, verify the person and authority through reliable channels. Do not send private customer or supplier information to an unverified email address claiming to represent the brand.

Where removal threatens substantial trading loss or the rights holder maintains a disputed legal position, obtain advice on a formal response and available remedies. Our guide to trademark infringement in India explains the underlying rights. Our comparison of infringement and passing off helps distinguish statutory rights from misleading presentation.

I would check the invoices and the live wording of the listing together. A clear provenance file can answer a counterfeit accusation, while one unsupported claim of official affiliation can create an avoidable separate problem. The appeal should establish lawful sourcing, accurate condition and honest presentation of these particular goods. That gives the reviewer something concrete to decide.

Sources

The law this answer relies on, so you can read it yourself.

  1. 1.Trade Marks Act 1999 official IP India text Read the source
  2. 2.Copyright Act 1957 IP India June 2026 publication Read the source

The short answer's sources were checked on 17 November 2026. Statutes and judgments can change, so check the current position before you act on anything here.

Nothing there yet? Send the question in and it gets answered here.

Related legal service

Dealing with this yourself rather than reading about it? Our Bangalore advocates work in this area.

Go deeper on this

This answer is the short version. These guides cover the same ground in full, with the procedure, the timelines and the leading cases.

SJ

Answered by

Advocate Sharan Jain

Advocate based in Bangalore, practising before the Karnataka High Court and District, Sessions, Consumer and Family courts. Answers public legal questions to make Indian law more accessible.

This answer is general information on Indian law as at November 17, 2026, published for public education. It is not legal advice, it does not take account of your facts, and reading it does not create an advocate-client relationship. Law changes and every case turns on its own circumstances. Please consult a qualified advocate about your own matter.

People also asked

Intellectual Property

Someone is using my brand name. What can I do about it?

Keep dated evidence of the other business's use of the name before it changes. A valid registration can support an infringement claim, but the use must satisfy the Trade Marks Act's conditions. An unregistered mark may still support a passing-off action. Compare the marks, goods or services and surrounding facts before deciding on a notice or court application. Registration does not mean you control every use of the same word in every industry, and an injunction still needs a properly supported case.

Intellectual Property

My trademark application has been objected to. Is it finished?

An examination objection is a chance to answer the Registrar's concerns, rather than an automatic final refusal. Rule 33 gives one month from receipt of the examination report to respond, and the Registrar may treat an unanswered application as abandoned. Read each objection and support your reply with the relevant explanation and evidence. If the response does not resolve the issue, or you request it, the rules provide for a hearing. Check the receipt date immediately and keep proof of the reply you file.

Intellectual Property

How do I register a trademark, and how long does it take?

Choose the mark and the goods or services you want to protect, then check for earlier marks before applying. The Trade Marks Act allows an application for a mark already used or proposed to be used, including applications covering multiple classes with a fee for each class. Filing is only the beginning: examination, advertisement and any opposition still matter. Keep the application details and evidence of use consistent. An application number is useful to track progress, but it is not a registration certificate.

Consumer Protection

The dealer sold me a used car as new. What can I do?

Selling second-hand or reconditioned goods as new is expressly treated as an unfair trade practice under consumer law. Preserve the advertisement, invoice, delivery record and evidence of the car's earlier use. A service history, prior registration or inspection report may help establish what was concealed. You do not need to treat this only as a repair dispute. Ask for the appropriate refund, replacement or compensation, and identify the dealer's particular representation rather than assuming every pre-delivery movement proves prior ownership.

Intellectual Property

Do I need to register copyright for it to be protected?

Copyright registration is optional in India. The Copyright Act protects qualifying works and allows the author or another interested person to apply for an entry in the register. That entry is prima facie evidence of the recorded particulars, rather than a final answer to every ownership dispute. Keep dated drafts, source files and the agreements showing how rights reached you. Registration can help with proof, but it cannot create originality or repair a missing assignment from the person who owned the work.

Intellectual Property

We paid a freelancer to build our app. Who owns the code?

Paying a freelance developer does not by itself settle copyright ownership in the code. Section 17 starts with the author as owner, with specific exceptions, including qualifying work created in employment. An independent contractor arrangement needs separate attention. If rights are being assigned, section 19 requires a written, signed assignment identifying the work and rights, with the duration and territory addressed. Check the agreement alongside the code being delivered. Access to a repository and ownership of the copyright are different questions.

S Jain & Attorneys · Ask Me

Still not the question you had in mind?

Search the column, or send your question in. Questions of general interest are answered here, anonymously, so the next person does not have to ask.