Not for going to look after your parents. What can cost you the claim is refusing to live with your husband without a sufficient reason. Section 144(4) of the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023 (BNSS), which carries forward section 125(4) of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 (CrPC), denies a wife maintenance "if, without any sufficient reason, she refuses to live with her husband". In August 2026 the Karnataka High Court upheld the refusal of maintenance to a wife who went home in 2021 to care for her parents and did not return, because she could not establish a reasonable cause. In January 2025 the Supreme Court restored maintenance to a wife who proved why she stayed away.
Part of the maintenance and alimony practice at S Jain & Attorneys, Bangalore.
This guide is for a wife who went home to care for her parents, stayed on, and now meets the reply "she left without reason" in her maintenance case, and for the husband making it. It deals with the second of the three bars in section 144(4). All three are listed in our guides to maintenance under section 125, maintenance for a working wife and adultery as a ground for divorce.
| What the court looked at | Claim refused: Karnataka High Court, 25 August 2026 | Claim upheld: Supreme Court, 10 January 2025 |
|---|---|---|
| Why she was living apart | She went in 2021, during COVID, to look after her parents and sister. She later said harassment had driven her out | He ignored her after a miscarriage and bore none of its cost, and she was not allowed to use the toilet or cook with proper facilities |
| What the husband did | He came to her parents' house to ask her back, as her own statement to the police recorded | He obtained a decree for restitution of conjugal rights, then neither executed it nor sought divorce, and made no attempt at reconciliation after 2017 |
| The evidence of her reason | No substantive proof of harassment or cruelty, and a complaint in evidence said she had gone to care for her family | Her witnesses were not cross-examined, documents proved the miscarriage, and the toilet and cooking facts were accepted in the restitution case |
| Result | Refusal of her claim upheld. The younger daughter's Rs 8,000 a month was not in issue | Rs 10,000 a month restored from the date of her application |
Three points from the statute and these judgments run through everything below.
Refusal, not absence
The bar reaches a wife who refuses to live with her husband without sufficient reason. The Supreme Court has said that mere failure to live with him is not enough.
His offer is tested
If he offers to maintain you only if you live with him, the court may consider your grounds for refusing and still order maintenance where there is just ground.
Your reason, proved
In August 2026 the Karnataka High Court upheld a refusal because the wife failed to establish a reasonable cause and produced no substantive proof of harassment.
Will the court refuse my maintenance because I went to look after my parents?
Not for the going, but it may if you have since refused to live with your husband without a sufficient reason. Under section 144(1) BNSS, a Magistrate may order maintenance where a person "having sufficient means neglects or refuses to maintain" his wife, "unable to maintain herself". Section 144(4) disentitles a wife who refuses to live with her husband "without any sufficient reason", and section 144(5) requires an existing order to be cancelled on proof of the same fact. Sub-section (5) is word for word the old section 125(5) CrPC, and sub-section (4) matches section 125(4) except that the phrase "as the case may be" is gone.
The Karnataka High Court applied both requirements to a petition under section 125 CrPC, which it described as "corresponding to 144 BNSS". It held that a wife must show that her husband neglected or refused to maintain her, that she is unable to maintain herself, and that he has sufficient means (paragraph 7), and that "Leaving matrimonial home without justification and reasonable cause is certainly a disqualification to seek maintenance from husband" (paragraph 8). The court spoke of leaving, the statute of refusing to live with the husband without "sufficient reason". On our reading both ask why the wife is living apart, and on the Mysuru facts the weak point was not the going but the staying away after he asked her back.
A husband who says "she left" usually argues both, that he never neglected you and that you have no sufficient reason to stay away.
Key takeaway. Looking after your parents explains why you went. It does not by itself explain why you have not gone back. That second question, and whether you can prove your answer, is what the bar turns on.
What did the Karnataka High Court decide in August 2026?
It dismissed the wife's revision petition and left the Family Court's refusal of her maintenance in place (RPFC No. 133 of 2024, 2026:KHC:45979, 25 August 2026). The couple married in 1995 and lived together for about 25 years. In 2021, during COVID, she went to her parents' home to look after her parents and sister, who had COVID, and her father suffered a heart attack. The husband said she did not return despite repeated requests and complained to the police when he went to ask her back. She said harassment had driven her out.
The Family Court at Mysuru, deciding her 2022 petition on 29 November 2023, refused her claim and the elder daughter's, and ordered Rs 8,000 a month for the younger daughter until her marriage or until she found suitable work, with her full education costs. It relied on a complaint marked as Exhibit R1, which recorded that she had gone to care for her family, and on her own statement to the police, Exhibit R3, which recorded that her husband had come to her parents' house asking her to return. On harassment and cruelty, "no substantive proof was produced" (paragraph 6). He had also bought a house site in her name with a loan, and it was not denied that he had provided for the elder daughter's education.
The High Court held that "neither refusal nor neglect are found" and that she "failed to establish that there exists reasonable cause due to which she withdrew from the society of the respondent" (paragraph 9). It found no ground to interfere with the findings. This is a single judge's oral order in a revision, and we had found no report of an appeal against it at the time of writing.
What counts as a sufficient reason to stay away, and what does not?
There is no fixed list. The Supreme Court said in January 2025 that even where the husband holds a decree for restitution of conjugal rights, whether the wife has "valid and sufficient reason" must be decided "on the strength of the material and evidence available", and there "can be no hard and fast rule" (2025 INSC 55, paragraph 29). The statute names one reason itself. By the Explanation to section 144(3), a husband's marriage to another woman, or his keeping a mistress, "shall be considered to be just ground for his wife's refusal to live with him", which our guide to second wife maintenance rights discusses.
The judgments show what courts have accepted. In the 2025 case the husband ignored his wife after a miscarriage and bore none of its cost, and she had not been allowed to use the toilet in the house or cook with proper facilities. The Court held that she "had just cause to not return" and "more than sufficient reason to stay away" (paragraphs 35 to 38). It also recorded a 2018 ruling in which cruelty and persistent dowry demands that ousted the wife gave her reasonable grounds not to rejoin her husband (paragraph 28).
Three weeks before the Mysuru case, the same judge dismissed a husband's revision against maintenance of Rs 5,000 a month for his wife and Rs 4,000 for their daughter, ordered by the Family Court at Tumakuru (RPFC No. 9 of 2026, 2026:KHC:40326, 3 August 2026). His own objections complained that she did not do the housework or look after his parents, and visited her parents without permission. The court held that she "has got sufficient cause to leave the company of the petitioner/husband", adding that where parents need looking after, "the primary duty vests upon the son or daughter as the case may be, but not the son-in-law or daughter-in-law" (paragraphs 8 to 10). The wife did not appear in the High Court, so it heard no argument from her side.
In the Mysuru case the reason the record supported was her family's illness, and nothing was proved against the husband. None of the three judgments holds that caring for a sick parent can never be a sufficient reason. On our reading, a parent who still cannot be left alone, shown by medical records, is a different case, and no judgment we read decides it.
My husband keeps asking me to come back. Does refusing end my claim?
Not automatically. The second proviso to section 144(3) covers this exact situation: if the husband "offers to maintain his wife on condition of her living with him, and she refuses to live with him", the Magistrate "may consider any grounds of refusal stated by her" and may still make an order "if he is satisfied that there is just ground for so doing". His offer moves the question to your grounds. It does not end it.
The offer also has to be real. The 2025 judgment records a 1996 ruling that the "mere 'failure'" of a wife to live with her husband is not enough, "especially as the crucial word carefully chosen in the relevant provision is 'refusal'" (paragraph 27), and a Kerala High Court view that refusal means declining "something which is offered" (paragraph 19). In the 2025 case the husband obtained a decree for restitution of conjugal rights and then "did nothing", neither executing it nor seeking divorce on it, which the Court read as "his lack of bonafides" (paragraphs 37 and 38). On our reading, a genuine offer, repeated and ignored, is the husband's strongest evidence, and an offer never made is hard to call refused.
A decree for restitution of conjugal rights does not settle the maintenance case either. The Supreme Court held that the decree and the wife's non-compliance "would not, by itself, be sufficient to attract the disqualification", and rejected the argument that the findings in that suit bind the maintenance court (2025 INSC 55, paragraphs 29 and 30). It repeated the rule in July 2026: if the wife refuses to comply, "it has to be seen on the facts whether such refusal is justified" (2026 INSC 778, paragraph 6.7).
Who has to prove my reason, and what evidence will the court look at?
In practice, you should expect to prove it. The Mysuru case turned on the wife's failure "to establish that there exists reasonable cause" (paragraph 9). The standard is not the criminal one: maintenance proceedings are "essentially civil in nature", and the standard of proof "is not beyond reasonable doubt" (2026 INSC 778, paragraph 6.2).
Each case was decided on ordinary evidence, often a party's own document. In 2025 the husband did not cross-examine the wife's witnesses, so her full dependence on her brother stood admitted, and documents proved the miscarriage (paragraph 35). In Mysuru a complaint in evidence and her own statement to the police explained why she had gone and showed that he had asked her back. In Tumakuru the husband's written objections did the work.
What we see go wrong is usually the record, not the law. A wife goes home for a family illness, the weeks become months, and nothing is written down: no message saying why she is still there, no reply to his request to return, and later a petition alleging harassment that no earlier document mentions. Husbands make the mirror-image mistake, a letter asking her back sent only after the maintenance notice arrives. The cases that go well are those where the reason for living apart is the same in every document, from the first message to the evidence.
Common mistake. Giving one reason in a police complaint, a letter or a message, and another in the maintenance petition. In the Mysuru case the Family Court read a complaint saying she had gone to care for her family, and her own police statement, against her later case that harassment had driven her out.
Will our children still get maintenance?
On the words of the section, their claims stand on their own. The bar in section 144(4) speaks only of a wife, and the children's clauses are section 144(1)(b), for a child unable to maintain itself, and (c), for an adult child, not being a married daughter, who cannot do so because of a physical or mental abnormality or injury. In the Mysuru case the Family Court refused the wife but ordered Rs 8,000 a month for the younger daughter until her marriage or until she found suitable work, with her full education costs. The elder daughter's claim was refused, and the High Court noted that she was working in Bengaluru after completing her education. How a child's claim is framed is covered in our answer on claiming maintenance for a child separately.
What should I do now?
Make your reason for staying at your parents' home the centre of your case.
- Write down the timeline: when you went and why, how long the need lasted, and every request to return with your answer.
- Reply in writing to any request to come back, giving your actual reasons with dates and incidents, because the court may compare that reply with your petition.
- Keep every document consistent: police complaints, statements, messages and affidavits in any other case.
- Collect proof of the reason you stay apart: medical records for a parent, messages, earlier complaints, and witnesses willing to give evidence and face cross-examination.
- File where you now live: section 145(1)(b) BNSS allows proceedings where the wife resides, and our answer on who can claim maintenance under section 144 sets out the filing details.
- Include the children's claims, which rest on their own clauses of section 144(1).
- If your husband files for restitution of conjugal rights, defend it and give evidence. In the 2025 case the wife filed a written statement and then stopped appearing, so findings there went against her partly uncontested.
What tipped each of the three cases.
Documents in evidence
In the Mysuru case, a complaint in evidence said she went to care for her family, and her police statement recorded his visit to ask her back.
His own pleading
In the Tumakuru case, the husband's objections showed he expected his wife to do the housework, look after his parents and seek permission to visit hers.
A decree left idle
Having obtained a restitution decree, the husband in the 2025 case neither executed it nor sought divorce, which the Supreme Court read as a lack of bona fides.
Frequently Asked Questions
My mother still needs care. Is that a sufficient reason to stay?
It may be part of one. None of the three judgments treats a parent's illness as decisive either way. On our reading, the illness in the Mysuru case explained why the wife went, not why she stayed away after her husband asked her back. Keep the medical records and tell your husband in writing why you are still there.
My husband never asked me to come back. Can he say I refused to live with him?
The bar uses the word "refuses", and the Supreme Court has said that mere failure to live with a husband is not enough. On our reading, where no offer to take you back was made there was little to refuse, though you must still show that he neglected or refused to maintain you.
Can my husband stop interim maintenance by saying I left without reason?
Only in a clear case. In July 2026 the Supreme Court said interim maintenance stops at once where one of the three situations in section 125(4), now section 144(4), is admitted or shown on the face of it, and otherwise continues while the court decides (2026 INSC 778, paragraph 13.1). The case concerned adultery, so applying it to a claim that you left without reason is our reading.
My parents are supporting me. Does that mean I can maintain myself?
Not necessarily. In the 2025 case the wife was fully dependent on her brother, a fact her husband did not contest, and the Supreme Court listed it among the facts the High Court had overlooked. A working wife's position is covered in our guide to maintenance for a working wife.
If I get an order and still do not go back, can it be cancelled later?
Yes, if your husband proves that without sufficient reason you refuse to live with him. Section 144(5) then requires the Magistrate to cancel the order. Until it is cancelled, the order stands.
Does a long marriage help my claim?
Not by itself. The couple in the Mysuru case had lived together for about 25 years, and the claim still failed because the court found no neglect by the husband and no proved reason for her staying away.
My husband has married again. Do I still need a reason?
His marriage to another woman is itself treated as just ground for your refusal to live with him, under the Explanation to section 144(3). You will still need to prove the marriage, and our guide to second wife maintenance rights covers the position.
Can I challenge the Family Court if it refuses me?
The wife in the Mysuru case went to the High Court in revision, which found no ground to interfere with the Family Court's findings. Our guide to appealing a family court order explains the routes. On our reading, the evidence is best put before the Family Court the first time.
This article is for general informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Consult a qualified advocate for advice on your specific situation.






