Yes, it can, and in January 2026 it did. On 12 January 2026 the Karnataka Real Estate Regulatory Authority (K-RERA), sitting as Bench-4 under its Chairman, held in Complaint No. 00547/2025 that Sankalpa Welfare Society (R.), a Mysuru society registered under the Karnataka Societies Registration Act, 1960, was a "promoter" under the Real Estate (Regulation and Development) Act, 2016, and directed it to refund the Rs 22,45,000 a buyer had paid for a plot in its unregistered layout, with interest at the SBI MCLR plus 2 percent from each payment date, within 60 days. An order is still not money in hand, and a two-line K-RERA dismissal of 20 January 2026 shows why the complaint has to be framed with care.
Part of the RERA and homebuyer disputes practice at S Jain & Attorneys, Bangalore.
This guide is for a buyer who paid a registered welfare society for a site in a layout it was forming, holds receipts and a booking or membership form but no agreement for sale and no plot, and is now told to wait because of a land dispute. It does not deal with house-building co-operative societies registered under the co-operative law. If you have not yet paid, start with our guide on checking a project's RERA registration before you pay, and for a BDA site see our guide for BDA layout allottees.
What the society argued before K-RERA, and what the Authority held on each point:
| What the society argued (paras 8, 9 and 23) | What K-RERA held (paras 20 to 24) |
|---|---|
| It is a welfare society, not a "promoter" under Section 2(zk). | Registration as a welfare society "does not immunize" an entity that undertakes real estate development and sale. Section 2(zg) makes it a "person" capable of being a promoter. |
| The money came under an internal membership or booking arrangement. | The membership claim was "untenable". The buyer was "an external party" and the transaction "commercial, not internal". Booking without registration and without an agreement broke Sections 3, 4 and 13. |
| O.S. No. 392/2025 over the same land is pending before the Senior Civil Judge, Mysuru. | The suit "is not sufficient to deny relief under RERA". The Authority has independent jurisdiction under Section 31. |
| Disputes about a society's affairs go under Section 25 of the Karnataka Societies Registration Act, 1960. | Not discussed by name. The Authority treated the claim as an outsider's statutory claim, not an internal dispute. |
| A 2018 memorandum of understanding with a developer shifts responsibility. | The unregistered, unstamped MOU did not identify the plot and "cannot absolve" the society. |
On those findings the operative order did four things.
Refund with interest
Rs 22,45,000 to be refunded with interest at SBI MCLR plus 2 percent per annum from each payment date till actual refund, within 60 days of the order.
Registration in sixty days
The society was directed to register its Varakodu Project under Section 3 of the RERA Act within 60 days from the date of the order.
Penalty proceedings ordered
K-RERA's Secretary was directed to start proceedings for the Section 3(1) violation, with penalties possible under Section 59 for non-registration and unauthorised collection of funds.
Liberty to recover
If the society did not comply, the buyer was left at liberty to start recovery in accordance with law. No order was made as to costs.
Key takeaway. K-RERA tested conduct, not the name on the registration certificate. A society that took money from outsiders for numbered plots and promised to register them was, on this order, doing a promoter's business.
What did K-RERA decide against a welfare society in January 2026?
It allowed the complaint and ordered the full refund. As the order records the buyer's case, the society represented that it was developing a residential layout at Varakodu village, Varuna hobli, Mysuru, and was authorised to collect funds for the sale of plots after complying with all statutory requirements, including RERA registration. The buyer booked Plot No. 193 and paid Rs 22,45,000 between 19 October 2023 and 13 July 2024 against the society's receipts, on an assurance that the plot would be registered in the buyer's favour once the planning authority approved, "as reflected in the Membership/Booking Form". The society never registered the project, never signed an agreement for sale, never registered the plot and never refunded the money. The complaint was filed under Section 31 on 1 April 2025.
The society answered with preliminary objections to maintainability, and the matter was heard on twelve dates. The same bench decided two other buyers' complaints against the same society and layout on the same day, in the same terms, for refunds of Rs 28,96,000 and Rs 28,05,000. Keep the order's limits in view: it is an order of one bench, an appeal lies to the Karnataka Real Estate Appellate Tribunal, and it turned on this society's own papers and promises.
Is a welfare society or housing society a "promoter" under RERA?
On the Act's words and the Mysuru order, it is when it develops land into plots and sells them, whatever its registration says. Section 2(zk)(ii) of the RERA Act includes in "promoter" "a person who develops land into a project, whether or not the person also constructs structures on any of the plots, for the purpose of selling to other persons all or some of the plots in the said project", and clause (v) adds "any other person who acts himself as a builder, coloniser, contractor, developer, estate developer or by any other name". A "person" under Section 2(zg)(vi) includes "an association of persons or a body of individuals whether incorporated or not". K-RERA read Section 2(zg) as including "associations and societies", so that the society "qualifies as a 'person' capable of being a 'promoter' under the Act" (para 24).
The finding rested on conduct. The Authority held that "mere registration as a welfare society does not immunize an entity from compliance with statutory obligations under other laws, including RERA, if it undertakes activities that amount to real estate development and sale", and that receipts specifying plot details, with an assurance of registration once approvals came, "amount to conducting a real estate transaction in the ordinary course of business" (para 20).
That cuts both ways. The order does not treat registration as a society as suspect, or hold that every society holding land for its members is a promoter, and many welfare societies are genuine non-profits with nothing to do with plots. The question is what this society did with your money: whether it offered plots to people who joined only to buy, fixed plot numbers, took instalments and promised a sale deed. Your complaint must prove those facts from paper.
The society calls me a "member", not a buyer: does that matter?
Not if the papers show a sale. The Mysuru society argued that the transaction arose "out of an internal membership/booking arrangement of the society". K-RERA called that "untenable": "The complainant is an external party who made payments in reliance on representations made by the Respondent, and the transaction is commercial, not internal." Section 2(d) points the same way. An allottee is "the person to whom a plot, apartment or building, as the case may be, has been allotted, sold (whether as freehold or leasehold) or otherwise transferred by the promoter", whatever the promoter calls him.
So gather what shows the sale behind the label: the form and the plot number on it, every receipt, any allotment letter, the layout sketch and the bank statements. The Mysuru buyer produced payment receipts, an allotment letter, an "outstanding letter" and photographs of the project (para 13). A receipt for a "membership fee" with no plot on it proves less than one that names the plot, so put the plot-specific papers first.
Did this layout have to be registered with K-RERA at all?
If it is a plotted layout in a planning area on more than five hundred square metres, yes. Section 3(1) bars a promoter from advertising, booking, selling or inviting persons to purchase "any plot, apartment or building, as the case may be, in any real estate project or part of it, in any planning area" without first registering it, Section 2(zn) makes "the development of land into plots" a real estate project, and Section 3(2)(a) exempts land not exceeding five hundred square metres.
A society may say its village land lies outside a planning area. The second proviso to Section 3(1) answers part of that: for projects developed beyond the planning area "but with the requisite permission of the local authority", the Authority may, in the interest of allottees, direct registration. The Mysuru order did not discuss the planning area. It recorded that the project "is not registered under RERA" and treated booking and sale without registration as the violation. Regulation 11(1) of the K-RERA (General) Regulations, 2022 lets the Authority ask a complainant for an unregistered promoter's details, and regulation 11(2) says that if it finds after enquiry that the project has to be registered, it "shall initiate appropriate proceedings to register the project".
Didn't K-RERA dismiss a complaint about an unregistered project in January 2026?
It did, eight days later, and the two orders can be reconciled. On 20 January 2026 the Fifth Additional Bench dismissed Complaint CMP/697/2025 in a one-page order sheet: "Complainant is not an allottee as per RERA and the project is not registered under RERA." The order then reads: "Complaint is dismissed as not maintainable."
The Authority's own order search shows what that complaint was. It records the relief sought as "Request to not to grand RERA approval on 61/6", a request that the Authority not grant registration. Nothing in the listing or the order suggests that complainant had paid for a unit. The Mysuru buyer had paid Rs 22,45,000 against receipts for a numbered plot. On our reading, the first ground of the January dismissal, that the complainant was not an allottee, is what separates the two cases, and the second ground would be an odd bar to a buyer's complaint when booking without registration is itself the contravention Section 3 creates. No ruling we found reconciles the two, and the January order gives no reasons beyond its two lines. Treat it as a warning about framing: plead the facts that make you an allottee, attach the receipts that name your plot, and say in terms that the society booked and sold without registration in breach of Section 3(1).
I never signed an agreement for sale: can I still claim a refund with interest?
Yes, on the Mysuru order, which directed a full refund with interest although no agreement for sale was ever signed. Section 13(1) bars a promoter from accepting "a sum more than ten per cent. of the cost of the apartment, plot, or building as the case may be, as an advance payment or an application fee" unless a written agreement for sale has first been signed and registered. The Authority held that the society "neither registered the project nor executed any agreement with the complainant" and that "Collection of funds without registration and statutory compliance is a direct violation of the Act, constituting misrepresentation and unauthorized real estate activity" (para 21).
The refund was what the buyer paid, with interest "from the respective dates of each payment till the date of actual refund". Your claim, likewise, is the money that left your account, payment by payment, not the price of the plot or a rate quoted for the next round. Section 18(1) measures a promoter's failure against "the terms of the agreement for sale", or a discontinuance of his business "for any other reason", and the order does not say which limb it applied where there was no agreement. It cited Section 18 as the power "to direct refund with interest" (para 24) and allowed the complaint under Section 31. Where a builder sold a booked unit to someone else, see our guide on a booked flat sold without an agreement, and for a demand above ten percent before any agreement, our guide on a builder asking for twenty percent first.
The society says only the Registrar of Societies or a civil court can hear this: is that right?
K-RERA did not accept it. The society argued that "disputes relating to the affairs of a society are required to be adjudicated under Section 25 of the Karnataka Societies Registration Act, 1960" (para 9). The order does not discuss Section 25 by name. What it held instead was that the buyer was an outsider in a commercial transaction (para 20) and that the Authority "has independent jurisdiction under Section 31" (para 22), which on our reading disposes of the objection.
The Act's words support that forum. Section 31(1) lets "Any aggrieved person" complain against any promoter for a contravention of the Act. Section 79 bars civil courts from "any suit or proceeding in respect of any matter which the Authority or the adjudicating officer or the Appellate Tribunal is empowered by or under this Act to determine". On our reading a refund of money taken for a plot booked in breach of Section 3 is such a matter, so the route for the refund is K-RERA, not a civil suit.
There is a civil suit pending over the land: does that stop K-RERA?
It did not in the Mysuru case. The society pointed to O.S. No. 392/2025, pending before the Court of the Senior Civil Judge, Mysuru, "in respect of the same land". The Authority held that the suit "is not sufficient to deny relief under RERA", that it could order refund, interest and penalties "irrespective of parallel civil proceedings", and that "The pending civil case relates to disputes over ownership or internal arrangements of the society, which is distinct from the complainant's claim for statutory relief" (para 22).
On our reading a land dispute is a reason the plot may be delayed, not a reason the money must stay with the society. Ask in writing for the suit number, the parties and the last order. If an injunction stops work on the layout, that bears on whether a plot can be delivered at all, and it is a reason to weigh a refund rather than keep waiting.
Common mistake. Accepting "there is a land case, please wait" for a year or two without asking for the case number. The suit did not stop K-RERA in the Mysuru case, and the society may spend the money while you wait.
The society says the developer it signed an MOU with is responsible: whom do I proceed against?
The society first, because it took your money, and the developer too if the papers show it developed the land. The Explanation to Section 2(zk) provides that where "the person who constructs or converts a building into apartments or develops a plot for sale and the person who sells apartments or plots are different person, both of them shall be deemed to be the promoters and shall be jointly liable as such". The Mysuru society relied on "an unregistered, unstamped Memorandum of Understanding with a developer dated 09.04.2018", which the Authority held "does not specify the schedule property, does not identify the complainant's plot, and cannot absolve the Respondent of statutory obligations under RERA" (para 23). The developer was not a party, and the order says nothing about its liability.
If a letter, site board, payment or the MOU itself shows the developer's role, consider naming it as a second promoter under the Explanation. On our reading a private arrangement between a society and its developer cannot reduce what the Act makes either owe a buyer, but no order read for this guide decides joint liability between a society and a developer.
What interest and penalty can K-RERA order, and can it make the society register?
Interest on every rupee refunded, a direction to register, and penalty proceedings, all of which the Mysuru order contains. Rule 16 of the Karnataka Real Estate (Regulation and Development) Rules, 2017 sets the rate as "the State Bank of India highest marginal cost of lending rate plus two percent". Rule 17 requires a refund with interest "within sixty days from the date on which such refund along with applicable interest and compensation, if any, becomes due". The period-by-period working is in our guide on calculating interest under the Karnataka Rules.
The penalty is a separate track the Authority runs itself. The order directed its Secretary "to initiate proceedings against the respondent for violation of Section 3(1) of the RERA Act and ensure compliance with statutory provisions". Under Section 59(1) the Authority may impose a penalty of as much as ten per cent of the project's estimated cost, as it determines, and under Section 59(2) a promoter who does not comply or keeps violating Section 3 faces imprisonment for up to three years, a fine of up to a further ten per cent, or both. On our reading nothing in Section 59 directs the penalty to the buyer, so it adds pressure, not money in your hands.
Compensation is different. The order's reasons say the Authority is empowered "under Section 71 to award compensation for financial loss", but the operative directions award none. Section 71(1) gives the adjudging of compensation to an adjudicating officer, and Rule 30(1) requires a separate complaint in Form O with a fee of one thousand rupees.
Can I ask for the plot instead of my money?
You can ask, but in a layout with no registration and, on the society's own case, no sanctioned plan, the plot is the harder remedy. The proviso to Section 18(1) lets an allottee who "does not intend to withdraw from the project" claim "interest for every month of delay, till the handing over of the possession". The Mysuru complaint asked for a refund, and the society had told the Authority that "There is no sanctioned layout plan, development approval, or agreement for sale as required under Section 13 of the Act" (para 8). On our reading, a plot there depends on approvals the society says it does not have, and a direction to register does not supply them. Choosing the plot is a bet that the society will obtain them and deliver. Choosing the refund ends the bet. Decide before you file, because the prayer fixes the relief you ask for.
Is this cheating, and should I also go to the police?
K-RERA does not decide that, and a refund order is not a finding of a crime. The Mysuru order calls the society's conduct "inducement and misrepresentation" in breach of Sections 3, 4 and 13 (para 23), but those are findings under the RERA Act. Cheating under Section 318(1) of the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023 turns on deception that fraudulently or dishonestly induces a person to deliver property, and illustration (g) says that if A, "at the time of obtaining the money, intends to deliver" and "afterwards breaks his contract and does not deliver it, he does not cheat, but is liable only to a civil action for breach of contract".
Whether there was deception when the society took your money is a question of evidence, such as what it said about approvals and whether it kept collecting after it knew of the land dispute. The police route is set out in our guide on a booked flat sold to someone else. Section 88 makes the RERA Act "in addition to, and not in derogation of" the general law, so the two routes can run side by side, but a police complaint should not name any individual without advice on what the papers show about that person.
The society has not paid after the order: how do I get the money?
Through execution before the Authority and recovery as arrears of land revenue, which is the route the Mysuru case has taken. Section 40(1) makes interest, penalty or compensation a promoter fails to pay "recoverable from such promoter ... in such manner as may be prescribed as an arrears of land revenue", and Rule 25 runs that recovery under the Karnataka Land Revenue Act, 1964. The Mysuru order left the buyer "at liberty to initiate action for recovery in accordance with law if the respondent fails to comply with this order".
The Authority's records show the refund was not paid. Its execution order of 1 June 2026 records that the society was absent, that notice had been served and "no response has been given", and directs the jurisdictional Deputy Commissioner to recover Rs 22,45,000 "towards refund of entire amount with interest" as arrears of land revenue. On 3 July 2026 the Authority wrote to the Deputy Commissioner of Mysuru District for recovery, and its revenue recovery list still described the project as not registered when checked for this guide. The procedure is in our guide on RERA recovery through the Deputy Commissioner.
A society may also appeal under Section 44(2), within sixty days of getting the order or later if it shows sufficient cause, and the proviso to Section 43(5) bars a promoter's appeal until it deposits thirty per cent or more of the penalty, or the allottee's whole dues with interest and compensation, or both. See our guide on a builder's appeal against a RERA order.
Deadline warning. In the Mysuru order the 60 days to refund ran "from the date of this order", not from the date you receive it. Diary day 61 from the order's date, not its upload, and keep an up-to-date memo of calculation ready.
Step by step: from the first letter to the order
- Put every payment in one table: date, amount, mode, receipt number and the plot the receipt names, with the bank statement entry for each.
- Collect the booking or membership form, any allotment letter, the price list, the layout sketch, messages about approvals and the land dispute, and site photographs.
- Search the K-RERA portal for the project and the society, and save a dated screenshot.
- Write to the society, by a mode you can prove, asking for a refund with interest at the Rule 16 rate, the project's registration number and the number of any suit over the land.
- Find the other buyers of the layout and compare papers. In the Mysuru case three buyers filed separate complaints on the same day.
- File in Form N on the K-RERA portal under Section 31, paying the Rule 29(1) fee of one thousand rupees, against the society and, if the papers show its role, the developer. Pray for the refund with interest from each payment date, registration and penalty, or for the plot with monthly interest.
- Answer the preliminary objections with the Mysuru reasoning: conduct makes a promoter, an outsider's payment is not an internal matter, and a land suit does not oust Section 31.
- When the order comes, diary the 60 days, watch for an appeal and its pre-deposit, and file for execution if the money does not come.
- For a provable loss beyond interest, file separately before the adjudicating officer in Form O.
What we see go wrong
We see a pattern in these enquiries. The buyer trusted the society because it was a society, paid in small instalments, and kept receipts that say "membership" or "contribution" without a plot number. When the plot did not come, a land case was mentioned, and the waiting began. The papers that decide these cases are often the ones buyers throw away: the message announcing the layout, the price list, the sketch with the plot ringed in pen. And time is lost writing to office-bearers personally and waiting for the next general meeting, when the complaint lies against the society that took the money and issued the receipts.
What will it cost, and how long will it take?
The fee for a complaint in Form N is one thousand rupees under Rule 29(1). Time is the larger cost. The Mysuru complaint was filed on 1 April 2025 and decided on 12 January 2026, a little over nine months, and the order records that it could not be passed within the stipulated period "due to multiple adjournments sought by advocates / parties and other procedural reasons". The execution order followed on 1 June 2026 and the letter to the Deputy Commissioner on 3 July 2026. Professional fees turn on whether the society contests, the number of hearings and whether execution is needed, so treat any quote as indicative.
What to keep, and why each paper matters:
Receipts naming the plot
Receipts that acknowledged the payments and specified plot details were what K-RERA relied on to treat the Mysuru society as a promoter, not the society's label for the buyer.
Every bank entry
The refund is what you paid, payment by payment, with interest from each payment date, so every transfer needs its bank statement entry beside its receipt.
The booking form
On the buyer's case the Mysuru form recorded the promise of registration once approvals came, and calling the buyer a member did not change the transaction.
A dated portal search
A dated screenshot showing no registration supports the Section 3(1) breach and the enquiry the Authority can begin under regulation 11 of its 2022 regulations.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can a welfare society registered under the Societies Registration Act be a promoter under RERA?
Yes, on K-RERA's order of 12 January 2026 in Complaint 00547/2025, where it develops land into plots and sells them. The Authority held that registration as a welfare society does not immunise an entity that undertakes real estate development and sale, and that receipts for plots and a promise to register them made the society a promoter.
The society says I am only a member. Can I still complain to K-RERA?
Yes, if your papers show a plot sold to you. In the Mysuru case K-RERA called the membership defence untenable, holding that the buyer was an external party and the transaction commercial, not internal. Lead with receipts and forms that name your plot.
Our layout is not registered with K-RERA. Can I still file a complaint?
Yes. Section 31 allows any aggrieved person to complain of a contravention of the Act, and booking plots before registration is a contravention of Section 3(1) in its own right. Plead the facts that make you an allottee, because a different bench dismissed a complaint about an unregistered project by someone who was not an allottee on 20 January 2026.
How much interest will K-RERA order on my refund?
Rule 16 of the Karnataka Rules sets it at the State Bank of India's highest marginal cost of lending rate plus two percent. In the Mysuru order it ran from the date of each payment until the date of actual refund, on the sum actually paid.
Will the pending land suit stop my K-RERA complaint?
It did not in the Mysuru case. K-RERA held that the pending suit was not sufficient to deny relief, that it had independent jurisdiction under Section 31, and that the suit concerned ownership or the society's internal arrangements, not the buyer's statutory claim.
Can K-RERA order compensation as well as a refund?
The Mysuru order's reasons mention compensation under Section 71, but its operative directions award none. Section 71(1) gives compensation to an adjudicating officer, and Rule 30(1) requires a separate complaint in Form O with a fee of one thousand rupees.
What if the society still does not pay after the order?
File for execution before the Authority. In the Mysuru case the Authority passed an execution order on 1 June 2026 treating the refund as arrears of land revenue and wrote to the Deputy Commissioner of Mysuru District for recovery on 3 July 2026.
Can other buyers of the same layout and I file together?
Section 31 counts an association of allottees as a person who may complain. In the Mysuru case three buyers filed separate complaints on the same day and won the same orders on the same day, each for the sum that buyer had paid.
This article is for general informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Consult a qualified advocate for advice on your specific situation.
Related Guides
- The Sales Office Says 'RERA Approved': How to Check RERA Registration Before Buying a Flat or Plot in Karnataka
- I Paid the Booking Amount, the Builder Never Signed the Agreement and Has Sold My Flat to Someone Else: What Can I Claim?
- The Builder Has Not Paid My RERA Order: Execution, the Revenue Recovery Certificate and the Deputy Commissioner in Karnataka






