Not if the booking amount you paid on the builder's sales manager's instructions can be tied to the builder. On 12 November 2026 the Karnataka Real Estate Appellate Tribunal (K-REAT) held, under the agency provisions of the Indian Contract Act, 1872, that a promoter "cannot disown the acts of its representative insofar as such acts fall within the scope of his actual or apparent authority", and that the employee's alleged misconduct did not, by itself, entitle the builder to make the buyer pay again. The finding was "subject to the genuineness of the invoice and the circumstances surrounding its issuance being established", so your papers decide your answer.
Part of the RERA and homebuyer disputes practice at S Jain & Attorneys, Bangalore.
This guide is for a buyer who paid part of the booking amount into an account the builder's sales or relationship manager named and is now told to pay that part again before the agreement for sale is signed.
| What the tribunal relied on | What you should hold today |
|---|---|
| The person giving the instruction was the builder's Customer Relationship Manager when the buyer paid, which the builder never disputed | His emails from the builder's domain, his visiting card, and the booking form or allotment letter that names him |
| He told the buyer to pay a third person's account | The dated message or email giving you that account |
| The payment was made towards this unit | The bank record of the transfer, showing date, amount and payee |
| An invoice on the builder's printed format, with its seal and its authorised signatory's signature, recorded the payment | The original receipt, with a note of when, where and from whom you got it |
| The builder's own police complaint alleged that he had collected more than Rs 1 crore from several customers | Any email, notice or complaint in which the builder names him |
Three points from the two Karnataka orders.
Employee, not stranger
The builder admitted that the person who gave the payment instruction was its Customer Relationship Manager when the buyer paid, and that he gave that instruction.
No second payment
The builder may pursue its employee and the others involved, the tribunal said, but the alleged misconduct alone does not let it make the buyer pay again.
Genuineness is the condition
The tribunal counted the Rs 7 lakh towards the price subject to the genuineness of the invoice and the circumstances of its issue being established.
Is the builder bound by the booking amount I paid on its sales manager's instructions?
Yes, if he acted within the authority the builder gave him or appeared to give him. Under Section 182 of the Indian Contract Act, 1872, an agent is a person employed to do any act for another or to represent another in dealings with third persons, which describes a sales manager who books units and takes payments. Authority may be express or implied under Sections 186 and 187, and an agent authorised to carry on a business may do every lawful thing "usually done in the course" of it under Section 188. Section 226 makes obligations arising from an agent's acts enforceable as if the principal had acted, and its illustration (b) is close to your position: a payer who pays a sum due to the principal to an agent authorised to receive it "is discharged of his obligation to pay the sum in question".
Section 237 covers the harder case, where the employee had no real authority to collect money or to name another account. The builder is still bound "if he has by his words or conduct induced such third persons to believe that such acts and obligations were within the scope of the agent's authority". That is apparent authority, and it turns on what the builder did, such as giving him the title, the booking forms and the buyers to deal with, or issuing a receipt on its own format.
Timing matters too, on our reading. If the employee had already left when you paid, Section 208 says the end of an agent's authority does not take effect against third persons "before it becomes known to them", so whether and when the builder told you matters.
What did the Karnataka tribunal decide in November 2026?
It confirmed a K-RERA order making the builder credit the disputed payment. A buyer booked unit No. 68 in a project in Hoskote taluk promoted by M/s Space Properties, a partnership firm (a plot in the K-RERA order, a flat in the tribunal's judgment). She paid Rs 13 lakh straight to the builder, and a further Rs 7 lakh, on its Customer Relationship Manager's instructions, to a third person whom the builder called a stranger to it and to the project. The builder said the Rs 7 lakh never reached it, wanted it again before the agreement for sale, and filed a police complaint against the employee and others on 19 November 2024.
On 9 December 2025, in Complaint No. 01365/2024, K-RERA held that the builder had not established its plea that the invoice dated 30 May 2024 was forged, noting that it produced neither the original invoice nor its counterpart, and that the employee's act "under the colour of office" made the builder liable for the acknowledgment of Rs 7 lakh. It directed the builder to acknowledge Rs 20 lakh, take the balance and execute the registered sale deed within sixty days, and restrained it from selling the unit to anyone else.
The builder appealed, arguing that a booking form gave the buyer no enforceable right and that she had not executed the agreement for sale. In Appeal No. (K-REAT) 29/2026 the tribunal relied on the builder's admission of the employee's role and instruction, the invoice issued "in a printed format bearing the seal and signature of the authorised signatory of the promoter", the builder's own police complaint alleging that the employee had collected over Rs 1 crore from several customers, and the builder's conduct in letting him deal with buyers on booking and collection. Citing Sections 182, 186, 187, 188, 226 and 237 of the Contract Act, it dismissed the appeal without costs, holding that even if the employee misappropriated or diverted the money, that by itself "would not absolve the promoter of its liability towards the allottee", provided the payment was made "bona fide under the legitimate belief" that he was authorised to receive it.
Key takeaway. The tribunal did not say that every payment to an employee binds the builder. Its finding rested on an invoice on the builder's own format and on the builder's admissions, and was expressly subject to the invoice being shown to be genuine.
Which papers tie my payment to the builder?
The papers that show who the employee was, why you paid where you did, and that the builder recorded the money against your unit. In the Karnataka case the buyer produced, among other papers, the payment receipt, the allotment letter and email correspondence, and the builder's objections admitted the employee's role and his instruction. Collect these now.
- His role: emails from the builder's domain, his visiting card, and any booking form, cost sheet or allotment letter that names him.
- The instruction: the dated message, email or call record giving you the other account.
- The payment: the bank record showing the date, the amount and the payee.
- The builder's documents: the receipt for that payment, any demand letter or statement of account, and the receipts for your other payments, for comparison.
- The builder's admissions: any email, notice or reply naming the employee, and any police complaint it has filed against him.
What weakens a claim, on our reading of the two orders: cash with no receipt, a payment made after the builder warned customers in writing, a discount offered for paying a personal account, and a receipt unlike the builder's other receipts in format, numbering or signatory. The builder in the Karnataka case told K-RERA that it had emailed all its customers not to deal with the employee and to pay into the company account.
Common mistake. Handing the original receipt to the builder's office for verification and keeping no copy. Keep your original, give copies, and ask for the builder's own counterpart, which the builder in the Karnataka case did not produce before K-RERA.
The builder has gone to the police against the employee: does that change my position?
Not by itself. The tribunal would not accept, merely on the strength of the builder's criminal complaint alleging criminal breach of trust, that the employee had acted in his individual capacity and the money could not be treated as paid to the builder. The builder is "at liberty to pursue appropriate remedies against the errant employee and other persons involved", but it "cannot, on that ground alone, shift the burden of such alleged misconduct onto the allottee and compel her to pay the same amount once again".
You can complain yourself as well, against the employee and anyone involved in taking the money. Cheating under Section 318(1) of the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023 covers fraudulently or dishonestly inducing a person, by deceiving him, to deliver property to any person, and Section 318(4) (the old Section 420 IPC) punishes cheating that induces delivery of property with imprisonment of up to seven years and fine. Criminal breach of trust by a clerk or servant entrusted with property carries the same maximum under Section 316(4) (the old Section 408 IPC). The First Schedule to the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023 lists both as cognizable and non-bailable.
The information goes to the police station under Section 173 of that Sanhita (the old Section 154 CrPC), in writing, orally or by electronic communication, and an electronic complaint must be signed within three days. You are entitled to a free copy of what is recorded. If the station will not register it, Section 173(4) lets you send the substance by post to the Superintendent of Police and, failing that, apply to the Magistrate, a ladder covered in the guide on registering an FIR. A criminal case does not decide whether your payment counts towards the price. K-RERA can.
Can the builder cancel my booking or sell the flat while this is argued?
Not at will. Section 11(5) of the RERA Act, 2016 lets a promoter cancel an allotment "only in terms of the agreement for sale", and its proviso lets you approach the Authority if a cancellation is not in accordance with the agreement, unilateral and without sufficient cause. In the Karnataka case the builder asked the tribunal for leave to cancel the allotment, refund what it had received and sell the unit, and the appeal was dismissed with the order to execute the sale deed confirmed. While a complaint is pending, Section 36 lets K-RERA restrain a promoter from an act in contravention of the Act that is about to be committed, until the inquiry ends or further orders, and without notice where necessary.
Watch the ten percent rule too. Section 13(1) bars a promoter from accepting more than ten percent of the cost of the apartment, plot or building as an advance or application fee without first entering into a written agreement for sale and registering it. On our reading, if the builder already holds more than ten percent without a registered agreement, a demand for still more before registration runs into Section 13(1), and the guide on a builder asking for twenty percent before registration covers the reply.
What should I send the builder, and what do I ask K-RERA for?
Send a written demand first, and file if the builder does not credit the payment in writing within a stated time.
- List every payment with its date, mode, amount and receiving account, and total what you actually paid.
- Write to the builder's registered office and accounts team, by email and post, enclosing copies of the receipt and the transfer proof.
- Ask it to confirm within fifteen days that the full amount stands credited to your unit, to send a statement of account, and to produce its office copy of your receipt if it disputes it.
- Ask it to confirm that it will not cancel the allotment or deal with the unit meanwhile, and say that you remain ready to pay the balance as agreed.
- If it refuses or stays silent, file a complaint under Section 31 online through the complaint section of the K-RERA website, in Form N under Rule 29(1) of the Karnataka Real Estate (Regulation and Development) Rules, 2017, with the fee of Rs 1,000.
- Pray for directions to acknowledge the full amount and to execute the agreement for sale or the sale deed on payment of the balance, and for an interim order under Section 36 restraining any sale or cancellation.
- Ask the Authority to call for the builder's receipt records and its counterpart of your receipt. Rule 29(2) lets it order documents to be produced and summon any person acquainted with the facts.
- File your police complaint against the employee and the payee separately, and place a copy on the K-RERA record.
Section 29(4) asks the Authority to decide within sixty days and to record its reasons when it cannot. The Karnataka complaint was filed on 30 December 2024 and decided on 9 December 2025, and the tribunal's judgment came eleven months later.
Deadline warning. An appeal against a K-RERA order lies to the tribunal within sixty days of receiving a copy under Section 44(2), and from the tribunal to the High Court within sixty days of communication under Section 58, on the grounds in Section 100 of the Code of Civil Procedure. At the time of writing the Karnataka judgment was still within that High Court window, and we found no report of an appeal against it.
How do I pay the rest safely, and where do buyers go wrong?
Pay only into the account named in the builder's own demand letter or agreement, by bank transfer, and confirm each transfer by email to the accounts team, asking for a receipt on the builder's letterhead. Check any change of account by calling the office number on the builder's website, never a number the sales person gives you.
In our practice the damage is usually done in the weeks before the dispute. Buyers pay a sales person's nominee to hold a price or a preferred unit, accept a receipt as a photograph on a messaging app, and never ask the accounts team to confirm the credit. When the builder demands the money again, some pay a second time without protest to save the flat and later find it hard to argue that the first payment counted. If you must pay again to keep the unit, say in writing first that you pay under protest and without prejudice to your claim that the earlier payment stands credited.
Three points to keep in view.
Authority can be apparent
Under Section 237 the builder is bound by an employee's unauthorised act if its own words or conduct led you to believe the act was within his authority.
Police case runs separately
The tribunal held that the builder's criminal complaint against its employee did not, by itself, allow it to make the buyer pay the same amount again.
Sixty days to appeal
Appeals lie to the tribunal within sixty days of receiving a copy of a K-RERA order, and from the tribunal to the High Court within sixty days of communication.
Frequently Asked Questions
The sales manager has been arrested. Should I deal with the builder or wait for the criminal case?
Deal with the builder now. The tribunal held that a builder's police complaint against its employee does not, by itself, let it make the buyer pay again, and the criminal case will not decide whether your payment counts towards the price. Send the written demand and, if it is refused, file at K-RERA while the criminal case runs.
I paid in cash and have only his message. Does the Karnataka ruling help me?
Less than it helped the buyer there, whose payment was recorded in an invoice on the builder's format with its seal and signature. Without a builder document you must prove the employee's role, the instruction and the payment from other material, and the builder's own conduct towards him becomes the main question under Section 237.
The builder says my receipt is forged. Who has to prove that?
In the Karnataka case K-RERA held that the builder had not established the forgery and noted that it produced neither the original invoice nor its counterpart, while the tribunal made its own finding subject to the invoice being shown to be genuine. Be ready to explain when, where and from whom you received the receipt, and ask that the builder's own records be produced.
Must I make the sales manager a party to my K-RERA complaint?
The builder in the Karnataka case objected that the complaint could not proceed without him. K-RERA allowed the complaint against the builder alone without discussing the objection in its order, and the tribunal left the builder free to pursue the employee itself.
Can the builder simply refund what it admits receiving and cancel my booking?
Section 11(5) permits cancellation only in terms of the agreement for sale. In the Karnataka case the builder asked to be allowed to cancel, refund and sell, and the tribunal dismissed its appeal and confirmed the direction to execute the sale deed.
What if the builder appeals the K-RERA order?
It must appeal within sixty days under Section 44(2), and the proviso to Section 43(5) requires a promoter to deposit at least thirty percent of any penalty, or whatever the order makes payable to the allottee with interest and compensation, before its appeal is heard. The guide on a builder's appeal and the pre-deposit explains how that works.
What if the builder ignores the order?
Section 63 makes a promoter who fails to comply with K-RERA's orders liable to a penalty for every day of default, up to five percent of the estimated project cost in all, and the Karnataka order expressly left the buyer at liberty to act if it was not complied with. The guide on executing a RERA order in Karnataka covers the next steps.
How long does this take and what does it cost?
Form N carries a fee of Rs 1,000 under Rule 29(1). The Karnataka complaint took about eleven months to decide and the tribunal's judgment came about eleven months after that, and lawyers' fees are separate, so treat these figures as indicative.
This article is for general informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Consult a qualified advocate for advice on your specific situation.






