Property & Real Estate Law

I Paid a House Building Co-operative Society for a Site Years Ago and It Has No Land: Can I Go to K-RERA or Must I Go Elsewhere?

By Advocate Sharan Jain

I Paid a House Building Co-operative Society for a Site Years Ago and It Has No Land: Can I Go to K-RERA or Must I Go Elsewhere?

No, not while the society has no land. On 8 September 2026 the Karnataka Real Estate Appellate Tribunal (K-REAT) upheld K-RERA's refusal to entertain such a member's complaint, deciding in Appeal No. (K-REAT) 3/2026, against the BSNL Employee Welfare House Building Co-operative Society, that a house building co-operative society which has acquired no land is not a "promoter", that there is no "real estate project" and that its member is not an "allottee", so the Real Estate (Regulation and Development) Act, 2016 does not apply. It left the member free to go to the Registrar of Co-operative Societies or the consumer forum, and this guide sets out both routes, with the police where money was misused.

Part of the RERA and homebuyer disputes practice at S Jain & Attorneys, Bangalore.

This guide is for a member of an employees' or other house building society in Karnataka who paid a site advance years ago, holds receipts and a seniority number, and is still waiting because the society never bought land. If your society has land, a layout and an identified site for you, the position can differ, and our guide on checking a project's RERA registration shows how to see whether a layout is registered.

Where each situation goes:

Your society's positionDoes RERA apply?Where to go
It holds land, is forming a layout and has offered sites, and your papers name a siteIt can, as orders of K-RERA in January 2026 and of K-REAT in October 2025 showA complaint to K-RERA
It has acquired no land, and your receipts name no siteNo, on K-REAT's ruling of 8 September 2026The Registrar of Co-operative Societies or the consumer commission
Office-bearers diverted or misused the moneyA separate question: the criminal law and the Registrar's powers run alongsideThe police, and a written complaint to the Registrar

What the tribunal held, in four points:

No land, no project

The society had not acquired any land for development, so no real estate project existed for the RERA Act to regulate, as paragraph 23 of the judgment notes.

Not a promoter

On the tribunal's minimum test, a house building society must have developed land for a layout and offered sites. This one had only enrolled members and collected money from them.

Member, not allottee

With no project, the member who paid Rs 7,66,800 in 2013 and 2014 was not an allottee, so no RERA refund with interest was open to him.

Free to go elsewhere

Like K-RERA, the tribunal left him at liberty to approach the Registrar of Co-operative Societies or the consumer forum to get back the amount due to him.

Key takeaway. The tribunal did not ask what the society is called or whether you are a member. It asked whether a project exists: land developed for a layout, with sites offered. No land, no project, no RERA case.

Can I take my house building society to K-RERA if it never bought land?

Not on the law as the tribunal stated it in September 2026. The member, a BSNL employee of more than eighteen years, had joined a society formed by employees to provide houses or plots at cheaper rates. Told that sites were available in Madhavanagar, he paid Rs 3,83,400 on 19 April 2013 and again on 26 June 2014, Rs 7,66,800 in all, towards a site in the proposed Madhavanagara project Phase-II off Nelamangala Road. No site came, and no refund. K-RERA dismissed his complaint on 2 September 2025 and the tribunal his appeal on 8 September 2026.

Section 18 of the RERA Act, which gives an allottee a refund with interest, turns on the defined terms "promoter", "allottee", "real estate project" and "agreement for sale" (paragraph 19). The tribunal held that the society "has not acquired any land for development and consequently it does not fall into the definition of Promoter and there is no project in existence let alone Complainant could be called as an Allottee" (paragraph 23). It had only enrolled members and gathered money "towards purchase of sites as and when it develop such project/layout".

The ruling decides its own facts, and the absence of land was not disputed. An appeal lies to the High Court under Section 58 within sixty days of communication of the decision, and we have seen no report of one at the time of writing.

What did K-RERA say about societies that collect money without land?

That collecting money for a future scheme gives it no jurisdiction, and that the Registrar should act. Its order of 2 September 2025 was a common judgment of the Chairman in seven complaints by members of two employees' house building societies, who had paid advances between 2013 and 2018 for sites in several proposed layouts around Bengaluru. In one, the member alleged that over Rs 22 crore had been gathered from more than 460 members against 9.25 acres, enough for about 150 sites.

K-RERA held that "mere collection of money from members for a proposed future scheme without creation of a registered real estate project does not confer jurisdiction on this Authority to direct refund or compensation. Unless and until land is procured, plans are sanctioned, and a project is registered, the remedies under RERA are not attracted" (paragraph 28). It noted "several similar matters" of societies taking money "with a promise of future allotment of sites" without first securing land (paragraph 31), said it had already communicated with the Registrar of Co-operative Societies, Bengaluru (paragraph 33), and said the forums the members approach next "shall consider condonation of delay liberally" (paragraph 34). Its order reserved liberty under the Karnataka Co-operative Societies Act, 1959 or the Consumer Protection Act, 2019.

Both orders speak of registration: the tribunal said a member has no relief under the Act "unless and until a layout is formed and registered with the Authority" (paragraph 13). On our reading that is no shelter for a society that holds land and sells sites without registering. Section 3(1) bars a promoter from booking or selling plots in a planning area without registering, as the tribunal itself noted (paragraph 20), and the Mysuru order below treated such a layout as within RERA.

When would RERA apply to a house building co-operative society?

When there is a project: land the society holds and is developing into a layout, with sites offered. Section 2(zk)(ii) of the Act covers a person who "develops land into a project ... for the purpose of selling to other persons all or some of the plots", and Section 2(zk)(iv) names "a primary co-operative housing society which constructs apartments or buildings for its Members". The tribunal's "minimum requirement" is a society that "has developed a land for formation of layout and offered sites to its members" (paragraph 23), and K-RERA accepted that a co-operative society "must register the real estate project" (paragraph 24).

Two orders show the opposite case. On 12 January 2026, in Complaint No. 00547/2025, K-RERA held a Mysuru welfare society to be a promoter and ordered it to repay a buyer with interest: it was forming a layout at a named village, the buyer had booked Plot No. 193 against receipts that specified plot details, and the buyer was "an external party" in a transaction that was "commercial, not internal". And in October 2025, in Appeal No. (K-REAT) 03/2025, the tribunal dealt with a member of the Karnataka Postal and Telecom Employees Housing Co-operative Society who had paid Rs 19,20,000 between 2011 and 2014 for a site in its project "Sandesh Nagar-2". The society's own appeal against a K-RERA delay-interest order had been dismissed in 2021 because it did not make the deposit Section 43(5) requires of a promoter, and the tribunal directed the society, which its order describes as the promoter, to pay interest.

The BSNL member, by contrast, held receipts the society called "not allotment letters", for money "not towards purchase of any particular plot", and a place on a seniority list for phases not yet formed (paragraphs 5 and 7). Membership is not the dividing line, since the tribunal's own test speaks of sites offered "to its members" (paragraph 23). Land and a layout are.

Common mistake. Going to K-RERA first because a site sounds like real estate. The member in the September 2026 case filed in December 2023, failed before K-RERA in September 2025 and before the tribunal in September 2026, and was then left to start again before the Registrar or the consumer forum.

Where do I go instead: the Registrar or the consumer commission?

Either. Both are named in the tribunal's order and in K-RERA's, but they run on different clocks and give different relief.

PointRegistrar of Co-operative SocietiesDistrict Consumer Commission
The lawSection 70, Karnataka Co-operative Societies Act, 1959Consumer Protection Act, 2019
Who decidesThe Registrar, a person the Government invests, or an arbitrator he appoints (Section 71(1))The District Commission, where the amount paid is up to Rs 50 lakh
Time to fileSix years from the cause of action, later on sufficient cause (Section 70A)Two years, later on sufficient cause with reasons recorded (Section 69)
Time to decideTwelve months, extendable to eighteen (Section 71(5))An endeavour to decide within three months of notice (Section 38(7))
What it ordersA binding decision, executable as a decree or as arrears of land revenue (Section 101)Refund with interest, and compensation (Section 39(1)(c) and (d))
AppealKarnataka Appellate Tribunal, within sixty days (Section 105)State Commission, within forty-five days, with a 50 percent deposit by the party ordered to pay (Section 41)

On our reading, three points decide the choice:

  • Age of the claim. An old claim is safer before the Registrar, with six years against two, unless you can show a continuing wrong.
  • Relief and reach. A consumer commission can add compensation to the refund. The Registrar's inquiry and surcharge powers reach office-bearers who diverted funds.
  • One forum at a time. The Supreme Court said in Thirumurugan that where both are approached, the consumer forum may leave the parties to the other remedy, so running both invites delay.

How does a dispute before the Registrar of Co-operative Societies work?

You refer a dispute against the society, and the Registrar decides it or sends it to another officer or an arbitrator. Section 70(1) of the Karnataka Co-operative Societies Act, 1959 sends a dispute "touching the constitution, management, or the business of a co-operative society" between a member and "the society, its board or any officer, agent or employee of the society" to the Registrar for decision, and shuts out civil, labour and revenue courts and the Industrial Tribunal, as Section 118(1)(c) also does. The BSNL society was formed "for the purpose of providing sites to its members" (paragraph 13 of the judgment), so, on our reading, a member's claim for his site or his money touches its business, and if the society denies it, Section 70(3) makes the Registrar's decision on that point final.

Under Section 71(1) the Registrar may decide the dispute himself, transfer it to a person the State Government has invested with the power, or "refer it for disposal to one arbitrator appointed by the Registrar". That is the Act's arbitration: a statutory reference the Registrar chooses and may withdraw (Section 71(2)), ending in an award binding subject to appeal or revision (Section 71(3A)). Whoever hears the dispute has a civil court's powers to summon witnesses and compel documents (Section 117(1)) and may pass interim orders (Section 71(3)), and the rule that a lawyer could appear only with permission was omitted in 2013. The State Government may confer the Registrar's powers on Additional, Joint, Deputy and Assistant Registrars (Section 2A(5)), so ask which officer hears disputes for your society.

A dispute "shall be decided within a period of twelve months", extendable to eighteen (Section 71(5)). A decision or award not carried out is executed as a civil court decree on the Registrar's certificate, recovered as arrears of land revenue, or enforced by attachment and sale (Section 101). An office-bearer who wilfully disobeys it risks up to one year's imprisonment or a fine of up to three thousand rupees (Section 109(11)), though a prosecution under the Act needs the Registrar's sanction (Section 111(2)).

Can the Registrar look into where the money went?

Yes, and members acting together can require him to. Section 64 lets the Registrar inquire into "the constitution, working and financial condition" of a society on his own motion, and an inquiry "shall be held" on the application of "not less than one-third of the total number of members" (Section 64(2)(c)), to be completed in twelve months, extendable by six (Section 64(2A)). A society whose working shows defects must explain them and take steps to rectify them within forty-five days of the report (Section 64(5)).

Where an audit, inquiry or inspection finds that office-bearers made payments contrary to the Act or the bye-laws, caused a deficiency in the society's assets "by breach of trust or negligence", or "misappropriated or fraudulently retained any money", Section 69 lets the Registrar frame charges and order them personally to repay with interest, "notwithstanding that the act is one for which the person concerned may be criminally liable" (Section 69(2)). He may act on his own motion, and an application for surcharge is to be decided within twelve months, extendable to eighteen (Section 69(4)). The money goes back to the society, which is where a member's refund must come from.

Am I a "consumer" if I complain against my own society?

Probably yes, on our reading of a Supreme Court ruling. In Secretary, Thirumurugan Co-operative Agricultural Credit Society, Civil Appeal 92 of 1998, decided on 11 December 2003, a society contended that the Tamil Nadu co-operative statute's dispute section left its members' complaints to the Registrar alone. The Court held that its members could bring consumer complaints, because the consumer law's remedies are "in addition to and not in derogation of" other laws, and "Merely because the rights and liabilities are created between the members and the management of the society under the Act and forums are provided, it cannot take away or exclude the jurisdiction conferred on the forums" under the consumer law. That was a credit society under the 1986 Act, but Section 100 of the Consumer Protection Act, 2019 keeps the same wording, and the Karnataka bar in Sections 70 and 118 names courts and the Industrial Tribunal, not consumer commissions.

The definitions can fit a member who paid for a site: a "consumer" includes one who "hires or avails of any service for a consideration" (Section 2(7)(ii)), and "service" includes "housing construction" (Section 2(42)). In Consumer Complaint No. 48/2023, decided on 6 October 2023, the Bangalore I Additional District Consumer Commission dealt with a member who had paid Rs 10,60,000 between 2013 and 2019 for a site in a layout his house building society proposed near Nelamangala, and nine years on had neither a site nor his money. It held this a deficiency in service and directed the society to allot the site and execute a sale deed within three months or, if no site was available, to repay the whole amount with interest at 12 percent a year from each payment, plus Rs 50,000 compensation and Rs 5,000 costs. The society never appeared and the order was passed ex parte, so it shows what a commission can do, not what one will do against a society that contests.

The District Commission hears complaints where the amount "paid as consideration" does not exceed Rs 50 lakh (rule 3 of the 2021 jurisdiction rules), and you may file where the society carries on business or where you live (Section 34(2)). Complaints are filed online on e-Jagriti, and members with the same grievance may file one complaint with the Commission's permission (Section 35(1)(c)). Our guide to consumer court types and jurisdiction covers the mechanics.

I paid ten years ago: how long do I have?

Everything hangs on when the cause of action arose, and both laws let a forum admit a late case. A dispute must be referred to the Registrar "within six years from the date of the cause of action", and later only if "the person making the reference had sufficient cause" (Section 70A). A consumer complaint must be filed "within two years from the date on which the cause of action has arisen", and later only on sufficient cause, with reasons recorded (Section 69). The co-operative Act's Limitation Act provision, Section 119, covers only appeals and revisions.

Neither Act says when the cause of action arises for a site that never came. In Samruddhi Co-operative Housing Society v Mumbai Mahalaxmi Construction, decided on 11 January 2022, the Supreme Court held that "A continuing wrong occurs when a party continuously breaches an obligation imposed by law or agreement", and treated a builder's continuing failure to obtain an occupancy certificate as one, so the complaint was in time. On our reading a member can argue that a society which keeps his money and neither allots a site nor repays is in continuing breach, but the forum decides that on the facts. K-RERA's statement that those forums "shall consider condonation of delay liberally" does not, on our reading, bind them, but it can be placed before them. And a written demand, met by refusal or silence, marks a date to work from, though it cannot revive a claim already out of time.

Deadline warning. The consumer clock is two years, against six before the Registrar, and both run from the cause of action, not from the day you decide to act. If you have never asked in writing for your money back, do it now, by a mode you can prove.

Must I wait for my seniority number to come up?

Not if you would rather have your money. The tribunal said that "at any point of time the Complainant is at liberty to withdraw the amount paid ... with interest" (paragraph 12). The society's case was that it allots sites in "the upcoming Phases" by a seniority list (paragraph 7). A seniority list orders allotment once there is a layout. It does not oblige a member to wait for land that has not been bought. One complaint before K-RERA showed the cost of waiting: members "at the bottom of the seniority list" were "left with no certainty of allotment" and were being offered smaller sites or repayment without interest (paragraph 6 of the K-RERA order, as the member put it).

Ask for your papers first. Section 19A gives every member "access to the books, information and accounts of the cooperative society kept in regular transaction of its business with such member". Study the scheme circular, your application and the bye-laws for what they say about withdrawal.

The society offers my money back with 6 percent interest: should I take it?

That is your decision, but know what the tribunal said. It recorded that the society's counsel "made a fair offer to the complainant to refund the amount with interest at 6%" and that the member "was not agreeable" (paragraph 24). It set no rate, having held the Act inapplicable, and so the interest RERA prescribes is unavailable. Before a Registrar or a commission the rate is for the forum: the consumer law speaks of "such interest on such price or charges as may be decided" (Section 39(1)(c)), and the ex parte Bengaluru order awarded 12 percent.

Set the offer against time and risk, not only the rate. A contested claim can take a year or more, and an order is worth what the society can pay. If you accept, get the amount, rate, period and payment date in writing, check whether you are giving up other claims, and see that the return of your share money is recorded. If you refuse, say so in writing, with what you would accept.

Is this a police matter?

Only if the money was misused, not merely because the site never came. Criminal breach of trust under Section 316(1) of the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023 is committed by a person "entrusted with property" who "dishonestly misappropriates or converts to his own use that property". Office-bearers who diverted site money are the obvious case. Cheating under Section 318 is narrower, because it needs deception when the money was paid: the Sanhita's own illustration (g) treats a promise that was honest when made, and later broken, as a civil wrong only.

For acts before the Sanhita, the corresponding offences are Sections 406 and 420 of the Indian Penal Code, which Section 358 of the Sanhita keeps alive. Criminal breach of trust and cheating that induces delivery of property (Section 318(4)) are cognizable under the First Schedule to the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023, so the complaint goes to the police station under its Section 173. Our guide on lodging an FIR covers what to do if the police will not act. A criminal case punishes but does not return your money, so it sits beside your claim, not in place of it. Name an individual only where your papers show what that person did.

Step by step: from the receipts in the drawer to an order

  1. List every payment: date, amount, mode, receipt number and what the receipt says, with the matching passbook record beside it.
  2. Collect the membership papers, share certificate, scheme circular for your phase, seniority list and letters about land.
  3. Ask the society in writing, citing Section 19A, for your account and your place on the list, and ask what land it holds for your phase.
  4. Check the project on the K-RERA portal, using our guide to checking RERA registration. If land and a layout exist and sites were offered, take advice on a K-RERA complaint first.
  5. If there is no land, send a written demand for repayment with interest by a mode you can prove, and keep the reply or note the silence.
  6. Choose the forum, the Registrar under Section 70 or the District Consumer Commission, by the age of the claim and the relief you need.
  7. If other members are in the same position, consider one consumer complaint with permission, or an application by one-third of the members for an inquiry under Section 64.
  8. Where the papers suggest money was diverted, ask the Registrar in writing for an inquiry and action under Section 69, and lodge a police complaint on the facts you can prove.
  9. When an order comes, diary the appeal period and seek execution if the society does not pay.

What we see go wrong

Patience is the common thread in these consultations. Members of employees' societies trust the colleagues who run them, pay in two or three tranches, and wait through phase after phase because a seniority number feels like a place in a queue. By the time they ask for advice the advance is a decade old, the office-bearers have changed, and the papers that matter most, the circular that assured a site within a stated time and the letters admitting the land had not been bought, have been thrown away. Repayment offers, when they come, tend to be for the principal alone or at a low rate, with a request to sign off. This is rarely fatal, but each step costs time, and time is what limitation counts.

What will it cost, and how long will it take?

The fees are modest and the real cost is time. A consumer complaint where the amount paid is up to Rs 5 lakh carries no fee, and one above Rs 5 lakh and up to Rs 10 lakh a fee of Rs 200, under the scale substituted by G.S.R. 606(E) in August 2023. Before the Registrar, ask what fee the co-operative rules prescribe. The Registrar is to decide within twelve months and the District Commission is to try to decide within three months of notice, but in our experience a contested case takes one to two years, and an appeal lengthens it. Lawyers' fees depend on whether the society contests and the length of the case, so any figure is indicative.

The four clocks to keep in mind:

Six years to file

A dispute before the Registrar of Co-operative Societies must be referred within six years of the cause of action, unless the Registrar accepts sufficient cause for the delay.

Two years to complain

A consumer complaint must be filed within two years of the cause of action. A later complaint needs sufficient cause, and the Commission must record its reasons.

Twelve months to decide

The Act asks the Registrar to decide a dispute within twelve months, which may be extended to eighteen for recorded reasons and by the State Government beyond that.

Sixty and forty-five days

An appeal from the Registrar lies to the Karnataka Appellate Tribunal within sixty days, and an appeal from the District Commission to the State Commission within forty-five days.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can K-RERA order my house building society to refund my site advance?

Not if the society has acquired no land. On 8 September 2026 K-REAT held in Appeal No. 3/2026 that such a society is not a promoter, that no project exists and that its member is not an allottee, so the RERA Act does not apply.

Is a member of a house building co-operative society a consumer?

The Supreme Court held in Thirumurugan in 2003 that the Tamil Nadu co-operative statute's dispute section did not exclude the consumer forum for members. A Bengaluru District Commission treated a house building society's failure to allot a site as a deficiency in service in October 2023, in an ex parte order.

What is the time limit for a dispute before the Registrar of Co-operative Societies?

Six years from the date of the cause of action, under Section 70A of the Karnataka Co-operative Societies Act, 1959. The Registrar may admit a dispute referred later if the member shows sufficient cause for the delay.

Can I file a civil suit for my site advance instead?

Not for a dispute that Section 70 sends to the Registrar. Sections 70(1) and 118(1)(c) of the Karnataka Act bar civil, labour and revenue courts from entertaining it, so the choice is between the Registrar and the consumer commission.

Does the Registrar decide the dispute himself?

He may decide it, transfer it to a person invested by the State Government, or refer it to one arbitrator he appoints, under Section 71(1). A decision or award can be appealed to the Karnataka Appellate Tribunal within sixty days.

The society says I must wait for my turn on the seniority list. Must I?

No. The tribunal said the member was at liberty at any point of time to withdraw the amount he paid, with interest. A seniority list orders allotment once a layout exists, and it does not oblige a member to wait for land that has not been bought.

Will a police complaint get my money back?

Not by itself. A criminal case punishes criminal breach of trust or cheating, while recovery comes through the Registrar or the consumer commission. The Registrar's surcharge power under Section 69 can make office-bearers who misappropriated funds repay the society.

When would my society come under RERA?

When it holds land it is developing into a layout and has offered sites, or, under Section 2(zk)(iv), when it is a primary co-operative housing society that constructs apartments or buildings for its members. An October 2025 K-REAT order describes a housing co-operative with a layout project as the promoter.

This article is for general informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Consult a qualified advocate for advice on your specific situation.

References

  1. Karnataka Real Estate Appellate Tribunal, Appeal No. (K-REAT) 3/2026, a member v BSNL Employee Welfare House Building Co-operative Society Ltd and K-RERA, judgment of 8 September 2026: the society had acquired no land, so it was not a promoter, no project existed and the member was not an allottee (paras 12, 13, 20, 23 and 24); liberty to approach the Registrar of Co-operative Societies or the consumer forum; appeal dismissed and K-RERA's order of 2 September 2025 confirmed.
  2. Karnataka Real Estate Regulatory Authority, Bench-4 (Chairman), common judgment of 2 September 2025 in Complaint No. 01852/2023 and six connected complaints against two employees' house building co-operative societies (portal copy, not an official copy): no real estate project without land, sanctioned plans and registration (paras 25 and 28); liberty under the Karnataka Co-operative Societies Act, 1959 or the Consumer Protection Act, 2019; condonation of delay to be considered liberally (para 34).
  3. Karnataka Co-operative Societies Act, 1959, English text published by the Department of Parliamentary Affairs and Legislation, Karnataka: sections 2A(5), 19A, 64, 69, 70, 70A, 71, 101, 105, 109(11), 111(2), 117, 118 and 119.
  4. Consumer Protection Act, 2019 (No. 35 of 2019), Gazette of India: sections 2(7), 2(42), 34, 35(1)(c), 38(7), 39(1), 41, 69 and 100.
  5. Supreme Court of India, The Secretary, Thirumurugan Co-operative Agricultural Credit Society v a member (dead) through LRs, Appeal (civil) 92 of 1998, judgment of 11 December 2003: the dispute section of the Tamil Nadu Co-operative Societies Act did not oust the consumer forum's jurisdiction over members' complaints against their society.
  6. Real Estate (Regulation and Development) Act, 2016, as published by K-RERA: sections 2(zk)(ii) and (iv), 3(1), 18, 43(5) and 58.

Related Legal Services

Dealing with a matter like this? Our Bangalore advocates can help. Explore the relevant practice areas:

SJ

About the Author

Advocate Sharan Jain

Advocate based in Bangalore, practising before the Karnataka High Court and District, Sessions, Consumer and Family courts. Writes on civil, criminal, corporate, family and constitutional law to make Indian law more accessible.

Related Articles

S Jain & Attorneys · Legal Consultation

Have a Legal Question? We're Here to Help.

Our experienced lawyers in Bangalore offer confidential consultations tailored to your specific legal needs.

All matters handled with complete confidentiality and legal discretion.