A patient's death after a procedure makes you criminally liable for negligence only if the negligence was gross, and the death alone does not prove it. The offence of causing death by negligence in an FIR against a doctor is Section 106(1) of the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023 (BNS), which limits the punishment for a registered medical practitioner performing a medical procedure to two years and fine, and it is bailable. On 25 May 2026 the Supreme Court discharged a senior anaesthetist prosecuted over a 2002 post-operative death, holding among other things that the prosecution could not rest on an expert panel without an anaesthetist, that her part was too remote from the cause of death and that a consumer forum had exonerated her on the merits. A case like yours can end by discharge before the Magistrate or by quashing in the High Court under Section 528 of the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023 (BNSS), though quashing an FIR is reserved for exceptional cases.
Part of the bail and anticipatory bail practice at S Jain & Attorneys, Bangalore.
This guide is for the anaesthetist, surgeon or consultant in Bengaluru whose patient's family has registered an FIR against the doctor and the nurse, with consumer and medical council complaints threatened. The family's view of the same choice is in the guide on a consumer case or a criminal case for medical negligence.
| Point | Civil negligence (the consumer case) | Criminal negligence (Section 106(1)) | What the prosecution must have before it starts |
|---|---|---|---|
| Degree of fault | Below the skill of an ordinary competent practitioner | "Gross or of a very high degree" | Material of that degree, not an accident or an error of judgment |
| Medical opinion | The 2005 guidelines govern prosecutions only | A credible opinion of another competent doctor before a private complaint is entertained | An independent opinion, preferably from a government doctor qualified in your branch |
| Causation | In the 2026 case the hospital was held liable | A direct, proximate link between your act and the death | Facts tying your act, not someone's later error, to the death |
| The May 2026 Supreme Court line | Anaesthetist exonerated on the merits, exoneration left unchallenged | Anaesthetist discharged, nearly 24 years after the death | A panel with no anaesthetist held "inherently incompetent" |
Three points decide most of what follows.
Bailable, two-year ceiling
Section 106(1) caps a registered medical practitioner's punishment for a medical procedure at two years and fine, and the BNSS First Schedule lists it as cognizable, bailable and triable by a Magistrate.
A specialist on the board
In May 2026 the Supreme Court held that a panel with no anaesthetist was inherently incompetent to judge the technical nuances of an anaesthetist's epidural care.
A final exoneration counts
A consumer forum's exoneration on the merits, which the family never challenged, was the anaesthetist's most potent defence and helped end her prosecution in 2026.
Is a patient's death after treatment a crime, or only a claim for compensation?
It is a claim for compensation unless the negligence is gross, because only gross negligence reaches the criminal law. In Jacob Mathew v State of Punjab, decided by three judges on 5 August 2005, the Supreme Court held that negligence in civil law "may not necessarily be negligence in criminal law". For criminal negligence the degree "should be much higher i.e. gross or of a very high degree", and anything less "may provide a ground for action in civil law but cannot form the basis for prosecution". The test is whether you did or failed to do something which "no medical professional in his ordinary senses and prudence would have done or failed to do", and "a simple lack of care, an error of judgment or an accident, is not proof of negligence".
That is protection, not immunity: the Court said it was not "holding that doctors can never be prosecuted". Where the family's real complaint is that the risk was never explained, the question is one of consent, covered in the guide on informed consent to medical treatment.
What does Section 106(1) say about a registered medical practitioner, and why two years and not five?
It gives you a lower ceiling than anyone else. Section 106(1) of the BNS punishes causing death "by doing any rash or negligent act not amounting to culpable homicide" with up to five years and fine, "and if such act is done by a registered medical practitioner while performing medical procedure", with up to two years and fine. The Explanation limits this to a practitioner with a qualification recognised under the National Medical Commission Act, 2019 who is on the National or a State Medical Register.
The two years is the old ceiling: Section 304A of the Indian Penal Code allowed up to two years, "or with fine, or with both", for anyone. The Sanhita, in force from 1 July 2024 under S.O. 850(E), raised the general maximum to five years and kept two for a practitioner performing a medical procedure. A case about a death before that date stays under Section 304A, which Section 358 of the Sanhita saves, so the 2026 judgment on a 2002 death speaks only of Section 304A: the medical limb did not exist then and played no part.
The First Schedule to the BNSS lists both limbs as cognizable, bailable and triable by a Magistrate of the first class. On our reading the limb also decides the procedure: a case punishable with more than two years is a warrant case under Section 2(1)(z) BNSS, and a two-year case is a summons case. Whether telephone advice given away from the bedside is "performing medical procedure" is a point on which we found no ruling at the time of writing.
Will the police arrest me, and should I apply for anticipatory bail now?
Arrest is possible but should not be routine, and on an FIR under Section 106(1) alone anticipatory bail is not the application the law provides, because the offence is bailable. Section 482 BNSS (old Section 438 CrPC) is for a person who fears arrest "on an accusation of having committed a non-bailable offence". For a bailable offence, Section 478 BNSS (old Section 436 CrPC) says a person arrested without a warrant who is prepared to give bail "shall be released on bail".
The offence is cognizable, so the police may arrest without a warrant, but for an offence of seven years or less Section 35(1)(b) requires the officer to have reason to believe you committed it, to be satisfied that arrest is necessary for a listed purpose such as proper investigation, and to record his reasons. Otherwise he issues a notice to appear under Section 35(3), the old Section 41A CrPC notice, and if you comply, Section 35(5) bars arrest without recorded reasons. Section 35(7) requires the prior permission of an officer not below Deputy Superintendent of Police to arrest a person who is infirm or above sixty for an offence punishable with less than three years, which on our reading includes the two-year limb. Jacob Mathew adds that a doctor "may not be arrested in a routine manner (simply because a charge has been levelled against him)".
That changes if the FIR adds a non-bailable offence, such as culpable homicide not amounting to murder under Section 105 BNS, when anticipatory bail under Section 482 becomes the route.
Key takeaway. On Section 106(1) alone the offence is bailable: arrested and offering bail, you must be released. Anticipatory bail matters only once a non-bailable offence is added.
Who decides whether I was negligent, and what if no doctor of my specialty sat on the medical board?
In practice the first answer comes from a medical opinion, and the expert's specialty matters. Jacob Mathew directs the investigating officer, "before proceeding against the doctor", to obtain "an independent and competent medical opinion preferably from a doctor in government service qualified in that branch of medical practice". A private complaint "may not be entertained" without "a credible opinion given by another competent doctor".
The 2026 case shows what an unsuitable board costs the prosecution. A four-member panel reported in July 2008 that the death was due to "gross negligence on the part of the hospital staff". It had no anaesthetist. The Supreme Court held that "the absence of a peer specialist renders the panel inherently incompetent to evaluate the technical nuances of epidural anaesthesia and catheter management". The Sessions Court had read the guidelines as directory because of the word "preferably". The Supreme Court said they "strictly mandate" an independent medical opinion before a doctor is prosecuted.
On our reading the guideline protects the process, not the outcome: a board of the right specialty that finds gross negligence is a different matter, so ask early who is on it.
Can I ask for discharge, or for the case to be quashed?
Yes, before two different courts, but quashing an FIR is the exception. Once the police report is filed, Section 230 BNSS requires the Magistrate to supply you copies of it and its documents within fourteen days of your appearance. Charged under the five-year limb, it is a warrant case, and Section 262 (old Section 239 CrPC) allows a discharge application "within a period of sixty days from the date of supply of copies", the Magistrate discharging you if the charge is "groundless". Charged under the two-year limb alone, it is on our reading a summons case with no charge framed, and the proviso to Section 274 requires the Magistrate to release you, with the effect of a discharge, if he finds the accusation groundless.
The High Court's power to quash under Section 528 BNSS (old Section 482 CrPC), to prevent abuse of process or secure the ends of justice, is not a trial. On 19 August 2026 a Division Bench of the Chhattisgarh High Court refused to quash a Section 106(1) FIR against a doctor who ran the hospital: it accepted the higher threshold but would not weigh the evidence while the FIR set out allegations about the treatment. The Kerala High Court had likewise left every contention in the 2026 case to the trial court. Refused discharge in 2011 and in revision in 2018, the anaesthetist was discharged by the Supreme Court on the record.
Deadline warning. In a warrant case the sixty days for a discharge application under Section 262 run from the date the copies of the police report and documents are supplied. Note that date on the day the papers reach you, and count the sixty days if the limb is unclear.
Is a nurse's or a junior's mistake my crime?
Not by itself: criminal liability needs your own act to cause the death. In the 2026 case the prosecution said the anaesthetist was on call and was expected to give the post-surgery anaesthesia herself, but instructed the nurse to do it. The Court held that "an anaesthetist whose duty hours have concluded cannot be held criminally liable for a subsequent procedural error committed by a staff nurse". Even assuming she advised a painkiller by telephone, relying on the staff on duty, who included an on-duty anaesthesiologist, "cannot be deemed factually negligent", and the drug was "undisputedly the correct and necessary analgesic".
Causation was a separate ground. Criminal liability "necessitates a direct, proximate nexus between the negligent act and the death (causa causans)", and the post-mortem showed an undisclosed 80 percent coronary blockage and death from acute coronary insufficiency. In Jacob Mathew, over an empty oxygen cylinder, the hospital might be liable in civil law, the Court said without deciding it, but the doctor could not be proceeded against under Section 304A.
The judgment does not make every delegation safe. Its reasons rest on the ended hours, the correct prescription, the doctors on duty and the cause of death, not on a rule that a nurse's error never reaches the doctor.
What should a doctor named in an FIR do this week?
Secure the record, answer the police properly, and start on the expert question now.
- Get the FIR and read the sections: Section 106(1) alone is bailable, and a non-bailable section such as Section 105 calls for an application under Section 482.
- If a notice to appear under Section 35(3) arrives, attend on the date and at the place it names, after advice. Compliance is a duty under Section 35(4), and it is what Section 35(5) protects.
- Leave the medical record exactly as it is. Ask the hospital in writing for a complete copy of the case sheet, nursing notes, anaesthesia chart, drug charts and duty roster, and keep the acknowledgment.
- Write a dated account for your advocate of what you did, when and on whose call, before any written explanation goes to the family or the management.
- Report to your professional indemnity insurer in writing, as your policy requires.
In our practice the doctors who find these cases hardest are rarely the ones who made the worst clinical call. They put a hurried account in writing, to the family or the management, before checking the record, and it later read like an admission, or they asked about the board only after the charge-sheet was filed. None of this calls for a confrontation with the police, only a calm, written and early file.
Common mistake. Treating the consumer complaint as the hospital's fight. The anaesthetist's exoneration by the consumer forum, which the family never challenged, was the defence the Supreme Court called "the most potent" in the criminal case.
How do the consumer complaint and the medical council complaint run alongside the FIR?
Each runs on its own track, with one exception in your favour: an exoneration on the merits that becomes final. The 2026 judgment relied on the rule the Supreme Court stated in 2011 for adjudication proceedings. The proceedings are "independent in nature to each other" and a finding against the accused "is not binding" in the prosecution, but after an exoneration "on merits where the allegation is found to be not sustainable at all and the person held innocent, criminal prosecution on the same set of facts and circumstances cannot be allowed to continue". An exoneration on a technical ground is different. The forum had held the hospital liable and exonerated the anaesthetist, and the family appealed only the compensation of Rs 12 lakh, leaving the exoneration "unchallenged and finalized".
So defend the consumer complaint on its merits, with your own expert, rather than leaving it to the hospital, whose interests may differ from yours. The guides on replying to a consumer complaint and on where a medical negligence claim is filed cover the defence and the family's routes.
A medical council complaint is disciplinary. Where a State Act gives a State Medical Council power over professional or ethical misconduct, Section 30 of the National Medical Commission Act, 2019 requires it to act under the Commission's regulations and to hear you before any action, with an appeal to the Ethics and Medical Registration Board and then to the Commission within sixty days of that decision being communicated.
Three rules to keep in view.
Sixty days for discharge
In a warrant case on a police report, Section 262(1) BNSS allows the discharge application within sixty days from the date the copies of the police report are supplied.
Notice before arrest
For offences carrying seven years or less, Section 35 requires recorded reasons for an arrest, and a doctor who complies with a notice to appear is not arrested without them.
Your act, not hers
Criminal liability needs a direct, proximate link between your own act and the death, which the 2026 judgment found missing for an off-duty anaesthetist.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can the police arrest me simply because the family insists?
Not as a matter of routine. For an offence carrying seven years or less, Section 35(1)(b) BNSS requires the officer to be satisfied that arrest is necessary and to record his reasons, and otherwise to issue a notice to appear. Jacob Mathew adds that a doctor may not be arrested merely because a charge has been levelled. Section 106(1) is bailable, so a doctor who is arrested and offers bail must be released under Section 478.
The FIR invokes Section 105 BNS, not Section 106. What changes?
Section 105 (old Section 304 IPC) punishes culpable homicide not amounting to murder, which needs an intention to cause death or bodily injury likely to cause death, or knowledge that the act is likely to cause death. The First Schedule makes it non-bailable and triable by the Court of Session, so an application for anticipatory bail under Section 482 BNSS becomes the route, and whether the facts show anything beyond negligence becomes the first question.
Does the two-year limb apply automatically because I am a doctor?
It applies to a registered medical practitioner, meaning a holder of a recognised qualification whose name is in the National Medical Register or a State Medical Register, and to an act done "while performing medical procedure". Outside those words the five-year limb applies. On our reading the limb also decides whether the case runs as a warrant case or a summons case.
The hospital's internal committee has cleared me. Does that end the case?
Not by itself. The guidelines ask the investigating officer for an independent and competent opinion, preferably from a doctor in government service qualified in your branch. An internal committee's report can support your account, but on our reading it is not the independent opinion the guidelines describe.
Can the criminal case be withdrawn if the family settles the compensation claim?
Not by compounding. Section 106 is not in either table of compoundable offences in Section 359 BNSS (old Section 320 CrPC), and Section 359(9) allows no compounding outside those tables. A settlement can be placed before the High Court in a petition under Section 528, but whether the case ends on that ground is for the court to decide.
The nurse has also been named. Can one advocate act for both of us?
Your defences may pull apart. In the 2026 case the nurse's statements gave different accounts of who had instructed her, and the Supreme Court held them devoid of evidentiary value against the anaesthetist. Discuss separate representation before either of you gives a statement.
I was off duty and only advised over the phone. Does the 2026 judgment cover me?
Its facts are close to yours, but it turned on more than the phone call: hours that had ended, other doctors on duty, a correct prescription, contradictory statements, a remote cause of death and a final consumer finding. It was decided under Section 304A, so the two-year limb of Section 106(1) was not in issue.
How long can a case like this take?
There is no fixed timeline. The 2026 case ran from a death in 2002 to a discharge in May 2026, through a first charge-sheet quashed by the High Court, a second charge-sheet, two further High Court petitions, a refused discharge and a revision. Under the BNSS the first time limit for an application of your own is the sixty-day window for a discharge application in a warrant case, so read the police papers the day they arrive.
This article is for general informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Consult a qualified advocate for advice on your specific situation.






