Property & Real Estate Law

The Corporation Has Issued a Provisional Order Under Section 243 Against My Building for Plan Deviations: How Do I Answer It Before Anything Is Demolished?

By Advocate Sharan Jain

The Corporation Has Issued a Provisional Order Under Section 243 Against My Building for Plan Deviations: How Do I Answer It Before Anything Is Demolished?

A provisional order under Section 243 of the Greater Bengaluru Governance Act, 2024 is not yet a demolition order. The Act requires the Commissioner to serve it with a notice giving you not less than fifteen days to show cause, and to hear you in person before the order can be confirmed, so your answer is a written reply, filed within that time, that measures each alleged deviation against your sanctioned plan and requests the hearing. That is the course the Karnataka High Court set for an owner on 12 June 2026 in W.P. No. 17625 of 2026: liberty to file a response within a week, a personal hearing and a reasoned order to follow, and no precipitous action in the meantime.

Part of the property and real estate practice at S Jain & Attorneys, Bangalore.

This guide is for the owner of a house or building within the Greater Bengaluru Area, and for flat owners in such a building, facing a provisional order for setback violations, extra coverage or a floor beyond the sanctioned plan. It does not cover structures on a road, footpath or water body, or demolitions ordered by a court, which the Supreme Court's 2024 demolition directions also leave out. The order is now issued by the City Corporation for your area under the Greater Bengaluru Governance Act, in force since 15 May 2025, which repealed the BBMP Act, 2020 by Section 361. Earlier notices came from the BBMP.

The order moves through six stages, and each one gives you something to check:

StageWhat the Act requiresWhat to check on your papers
1. InspectionSection 243(2): an officer checks the building against the sanctioned plan, and a notice calls you to a joint inspection, with at least ten days to produce documentsWhether you received that notice, and the inspection report and measurements relied on
2. Provisional orderSection 243(3): the Commissioner may require the unlawful work to be demolished or altered, and may stop further buildingWho signed it, what precisely is said to deviate, and whether it is addressed to you
3. Show causeSection 243(3)(d): a copy is served with a notice naming not less than fifteen days to show cause why it should not be confirmedThe date it reached you, the last date named, and any hearing date
4. Personal hearingProviso to Section 243(3)(d): a personal hearing before any confirmationA written request for a hearing date, and attendance with your architect
5. ConfirmationSection 243(3)(e): if your cause does not satisfy the Commissioner, the order is confirmed and binds youWhether it deals with your points and says if the deviation can be compounded
6. EnforcementSection 243(3)(f): if you do not comply, a criminal complaint, demolition by the Corporation and its cost recovered as property tax arrearsThe thirty days to appeal under Section 250, and the Supreme Court's fifteen-day pause
Key takeaway. Until the Commissioner confirms it after hearing you, a provisional order is a proposal. The fortnight it gives you is the most useful time in the whole proceeding: spend it on measurement and a written reply.

What is a provisional order under Section 243, and is it already a demolition order?

It is a proposal to demolish or alter the part of your building said to be unlawful, and it binds you only once it is confirmed. Section 243(1) treats construction otherwise than in accordance with the sanctioned plan as a continuing violation until it is regularised or demolished. Section 243(3) lets the Commissioner, if satisfied that a building was put up without permission, otherwise than in accordance with it, or in breach of the Act, rules or bye-laws, "make a provisional order" requiring the khatadar to demolish the work, "or so much of it as" was unlawfully executed, or to alter it into conformity, and he may also stop further building meanwhile.

Only clause (e) makes it binding: if the khatadar or builder fails to show cause to the Commissioner's satisfaction, the order is confirmed, "and such order shall then be binding on the khatadar". In the June 2026 case the court agreed with the Corporation's standing counsel that the order before it was "only a Provisional Order", and that action to remove the deviations would follow once there is an order under Section 243(3)(e) and the owner fails to act on it.

The signatory need not be the Commissioner. Section 87 lets him delegate any of his powers, "including quasi-judicial powers", by a written order to a subordinate officer, and the provisional orders in the two cases discussed below were made by a Joint Commissioner of the Bengaluru South City Corporation and a Deputy Director of Town Planning of the Bengaluru Central City Corporation. Ask to see the delegation if the signatory's power is unclear.

What must the corporation do before it can issue a provisional order?

It must inspect the building and give you the chance to attend a joint inspection. Section 243(2) allows the Commissioner to authorise an officer to verify the construction against the sanctioned plan, and if the officer finds prima facie that it does not conform, "notice shall be served to the khatadar or Licencee or the person responsible, calling upon to attend joint inspection in his presence and to submit supporting documents", giving a minimum of ten days.

The High Court has twice regarded this step as one an owner can rely on. In June 2026 it said the owner could still show cause if he could justify "that there is neither inspection nor a joint inspection of the property, or that there is no deviation in the terms of the Provisional Order". In October 2026 it said notice "must be addressed to the concerned after due inspection as contemplated under Section 243[2]". If you were never called to a joint inspection, make that the first point of your reply, and ask for the inspection report and measurements.

How long do I have to reply to the provisional order?

At least fifteen days, and the exact period is the one named in the notice served with the order. Section 243(3)(d) requires the Commissioner to serve a copy of the provisional order with a notice "requiring him to show cause within a reasonable time of not less than fifteen days to be named in such notice". Where a notice fixes a period for paying a sum, executing work or providing anything, Section 345(3) counts it, unless the Act says otherwise, from the date of service, or of sending by registered post. The Supreme Court's directions of 13 November 2024 in In Re: Directions in the matter of demolition of structures make a show cause notice before any demolition returnable within the local law's time or fifteen days from receipt, whichever is later.

Section 345(1) allows service by hand, by e-mail, by leaving the notice at your home or business or with an adult member of your family, by registered post if you do not live in the city, and, failing all these, by fixing it on the property, so check your e-mail as well as the gate. If the period has run, reply at once regardless: the June 2026 owner had filed no reply at all, and the court gave him one week.

Deadline warning. Take the earliest date that could apply. The Act counts a notice period from service, or from sending by registered post, while the Supreme Court counts fifteen days from receipt. If your architect needs more time, file a reply on the merits in time and ask leave to add documents. A bare request for time is not a reply.

The clocks that run once the inspection begins:

Ten days to attend

Section 243(2) requires the joint inspection notice to give the khatadar or person responsible at least ten days to attend and to submit supporting documents.

Fifteen days to reply

Section 243(3)(d) requires the provisional order to be served with a notice naming a time of not less than fifteen days to show cause why it should not be confirmed.

Hearing before confirmation

The proviso requires a personal hearing before any confirmation order. If you do not appear when you are called, the Commissioner decides the matter on its merits without you.

Thirty days to appeal

Section 250 allows an appeal against the Commissioner's decision to the Chief Commissioner of the Greater Bengaluru Authority within thirty days of receipt, to be decided within ninety days.

Can the corporation demolish my building without hearing me?

No. The proviso to Section 243(3)(d) says that "before passing confirmation order the Commissioner shall conduct personal hearing to decide on the submissions from the khatadar or person responsible", and demolition by the Corporation comes only under clause (f), after a confirmed order that you have failed to obey. The Supreme Court's 2024 directions add a minuted hearing, a final order that deals with your contentions and says whether the construction can be compounded and why demolition is the only option, and a pause of fifteen days from its receipt before it is implemented. Our guide on what to do after a demolition sets out those directions in detail.

Two cautions. If the khatadar or builder fails to appear when the hearing is intimated, the same proviso says "the Commissioner shall decide the matter based on merits", so a missed hearing is a hearing lost. And Section 243(4) lets the Commissioner seal the building "at any time, before or after making an order of demolition", the seal coming off only on his order or an appellate authority's order in an appeal under the Act.

What did the Karnataka High Court direct in June 2026?

It gave the owner a week to reply, and directed the corporation to hear him and give reasons. In W.P. No. 17625 of 2026, decided on 12 June 2026 by a single judge, the owner challenged a provisional order of 30 April 2026, arguing that it was made without the inspection Section 243(2) contemplates and that demolition was likely. The Corporation's standing counsel answered that it was only a provisional order and that no action had been taken "because the petitioner has not filed any reply".

The court disposed of the petition at its preliminary hearing with four directions. The owner could file a response within a week, without waiting for a certified copy of the order. The Joint Commissioner was to ensure "that there is personal hearing and a reasoned order as contemplated in law". There was to be no precipitous action until a further order under Section 243(3), and the owner was not to undertake further construction meanwhile. It was a short oral order, made after hearing the Corporation's counsel, and it did not decide whether the deviations exist. Its value lies in the procedure it laid down.

We bought flats in the building: must the corporation hear us if the builder made the deviation?

Yes, on the High Court's order of 5 October 2026 in W.P. No. 31128 of 2026, passed by the same judge. Owners of flats in an apartment complex in east Bengaluru challenged a provisional order recording setback deviations and an additional floor, a later confirmation order, and notices to BESCOM and BWSSB directing that power and water to the building be disconnected. They said construction was complete, that the developer and the landowner had sold every unit, and that the purchasers had never been given notice of the inspection or of the provisional order.

The court noted that the provisional order "does not even refer to whom these notices are addressed", that neither the purchasers nor the owner and builder had been put on notice, and that this "lends credence" to the case that the confirmation order lacked the opportunity Section 243(3) makes imperative. It read the confirmation order down as a continuation of the provisional order, gave the owners eight weeks to respond, directed that copies be served "on every occupant of the complex" with a chance to reply and a personal hearing before any decision to confirm, and quashed the communications for disconnecting electricity and water.

The proceedings followed a complaint and a writ petition by a person with an agreement to buy a unit from the builder. The court called his grievance "a private dispute" with the builder, said he "has exhausted his locus in initiating the process", and said it was now for the purchasers to answer the allegations of deviation. It did not decide whether the building deviates from its plan.

Do not wait to be served personally. Section 345(2) says a notice to a khatadar or occupier need not name him, and that serving one of several joint khatadars or occupiers is enough, a provision the October 2026 order did not discuss. On our reading, every flat owner who learns of the proceedings should write in at once, ask for copies of the inspection report and the orders, and ask to be heard.

Can the corporation cut our power and water while the case is pending?

In the one High Court order on the point that we have read, the disconnection directions did not survive: in October 2026 the court quashed the Corporation's communications to BESCOM and BWSSB. The Act's provision on connections is Section 246(5), which says that where no partial or final occupancy certificate has been issued, it "would not be within the competence" of the Bengaluru Water Supply and Sewerage Board or the Bengaluru Electricity Supply Company to give "a permanent Connection" to the building. On our reading, its words govern the grant of a permanent connection, not the cutting of an existing supply. What else a missing occupancy certificate costs a buyer is explained in our guide on a buyer's remedies without an OC.

Sealing under Section 243(4) is a separate power. If a disconnection letter reaches you or your association, ask BESCOM or BWSSB for the communication and the order behind it, write to the Corporation the same day, and take advice on a writ if the occupants were never heard.

What should my written reply to the provisional order say, and what should I file with it?

It should answer the order point by point, procedure first and facts second, and end with a request for documents and a hearing. It usually covers:

  • Procedure: whether you received a Section 243(2) joint inspection notice, whether the order says to whom it is addressed, and who signed it.
  • Facts: each deviation alleged, against the sanctioned plan, with your architect's measurement of each setback, the coverage, the built-up area floor by floor and the number of floors.
  • Remedies: any deviation within the bye-law condonable limits, with an offer to pay the compounding fee, what you will remove, and any claim to regularisation under Section 249.
  • For a flat owner: when you bought, that you did not build, and that Section 246(2) names the promoter, as well as the khatadar, to demolish a violation at his own cost.
  • Requests: copies of the inspection report and measurements, a date for the personal hearing, and a reasoned order dealing with each point raised.

Annex the papers that let the officer measure the building against what was approved: the sanctioned plan and sanction letter, any modified plan and any plinth certificate under Section 239, the occupancy certificate or your application for one, as-built drawings certified by an empanelled architect or engineer as Section 241(2) requires for an occupancy certificate, the deviation statement, the khata extract and tax receipts, and, for a flat, the sale deed and the builder's plans.

Common mistake. Admitting a deviation in the first letter before it has been measured. Orders can be framed in round terms, such as "setback violation" or "additional floor", and a measured statement against the plan sheet can show a smaller or different deviation from the one alleged.

Is my deviation small enough to be compounded instead of demolished?

It may be, if it falls within the condonable limits fixed by the building bye-laws. Section 246(2) directs demolition of violations "beyond condonable limits", and Section 243(3)(f) refers to an owner who "fails to remit the compounding fee within the time specified", which assumes that an order may allow compounding instead. Since January 2026 the Greater Bengaluru Governance (Second Amendment) Act, 2025 (Karnataka Act No. 01 of 2026) has made Section 241(4) refer to "the condonable limits and the compounding fee as may be specified in the bye-laws with approval of the Government", and has omitted the proviso that capped the condonable limit at ten percent of the permissible limits.

The number is therefore in the bye-laws in force for your City Corporation. As reported, a draft amendment of 1 April 2026 proposed raising the deviation that can be condoned from 5 to 15 percent for some parameters, but not for a floor beyond the sanctioned number, and the amended bye-laws were notified in May 2026. Check which text applied on the date of your order before you rely on a number.

Can the building be regularised under Section 249 instead?

Only if it is old enough and the machinery is in place. Section 249(1) lets the Commissioner regularise a building completed in contravention of the Chapter and the bye-laws only if it was "constructed at least one year prior to the date of notification of this Act", subject to restrictions, "such rules as may be prescribed" and payment. Setback violations of up to fifty percent in a residential building, and twenty-five percent in a non-residential one, may be regularised, but not basement development or use contrary to the bye-laws.

Section 249(2) puts the fee at not less than six percent of the market value of the violating portion where the setback and floor area violation does not exceed twenty-five percent, and eight percent up to fifty percent, with a fixed twenty percent (up to twelve and a half percent) and thirty-five percent (up to twenty-five percent) for a portion used for non-residential purposes. Section 249(1)(d) applies sub-sections (2) to (14) of Section 76FF of the Karnataka Town and Country Planning Act, 1961, the regularisation provision behind the akrama-sakrama scheme, whose position our guide on B khata to A khata conversion explains. If your building may qualify, say so in the reply and ask whether rules under Section 249 have been notified, but do not assume an application stops the proceedings.

What follows if I ignore the provisional order?

It will very likely be confirmed without you, and then the costs and penalties start. A confirmed order binds the khatadar under Section 243(3)(e). If you then fail to demolish, pay the compounding fee or meet a condition in time, Section 243(3)(f) allows the Commissioner to file a criminal complaint and requires him to have the work demolished, the expenses being "recovered from the khatadar as if it were an arrears of property tax". Where no other penalty is specified, Section 244(3) provides, on conviction, a fine of up to twenty percent of the prevailing guidance value of the site and building. Paying property tax does not protect you: the first proviso to Section 147(3) says that tax collected from such a building "does not confer any right to regularize violation made".

The order has been confirmed: do I appeal under Section 250 or go to the High Court?

Appeal under Section 250 where you were heard and the dispute is about measurements, and consider a writ petition where you were never served or never heard. Section 250(1) gives a person aggrieved by the Commissioner's decision an appeal to the Chief Commissioner of the Greater Bengaluru Authority "within thirty days from the date of receipt of such decision", and Section 250(2) requires the Chief Commissioner to decide it within ninety days, his decision being final. The Act does not say that an appeal stops demolition, so ask for an interim order when you file, within the fifteen days in which the Supreme Court's directions bar implementing a final order.

Owners often reach for a civil suit for an injunction. Sections 172(1) and 174, though placed in the Act's taxation chapter, bar civil courts from matters the Commissioners are empowered to decide and require a plaintiff suing a City Corporation to prove first that every appeal open to him was presented, so on our reading a suit is the weakest option. Both 2026 orders discussed here were writ petitions under Article 226, and in each the court gave directions on notice and hearing without either order discussing the Section 250 appeal. Our guide on how to file a writ petition in the High Court explains the alternative remedy rule a corporation will raise.

Is the builder answerable for the deviation?

Often yes, in separate proceedings, but the Section 243 reply still has to come from you. Section 246(1) says approvals do not relieve the khatadar or promoter "from full responsibility" for building to the sanctioned plans, and Section 246(2) puts demolition of a violation beyond condonable limits on the khatadar or promoter "at his own cost and risk". Where the project is one RERA covers, Section 14(1) of the Real Estate (Regulation and Development) Act, 2016 requires the promoter to complete it "in accordance with the sanctioned plans", Section 18(3) makes him liable to compensate allottees for failing in his other obligations, and Section 71 provides for an adjudicating officer to adjudge compensation under Sections 12, 14, 18 and 19.

The October 2026 order separated the two tracks: the complainant's quarrel with the builder was a private dispute for him to pursue, while the purchasers had to answer the deviation proceedings themselves. Our guide on the builder's defect liability under Section 14 explains how a complaint under that section runs, and our RERA homebuyer disputes practice acts on such claims.

Step by step: from the day the order arrives to the hearing

  1. Note the date the order reached you, preserve the envelope or e-mail, and work out the earliest possible last date for your reply.
  2. Stop all construction work, since the order may direct you to refrain from building and the June 2026 order barred further construction.
  3. Ask the Corporation in writing for the inspection report, the measurements relied on and the signing officer's delegation.
  4. Have an architect or engineer measure the building against the sanctioned plan and draw up a deviation statement.
  5. File a reply on the merits before the last date, with the documents annexed, against an acknowledgment, and ask for a date for the personal hearing.
  6. Attend the hearing with your architect or engineer, and ask that the minutes record what you said.
  7. When the order comes, check that it deals with your points, and note the fifteen and thirty day dates.
  8. Appeal to the Chief Commissioner under Section 250 within thirty days with a request for interim protection, or take advice on a writ if you were not heard. In an apartment building, let every owner write in.

What does it cost, and how long does it take?

The statutory clocks are short, and the spending depends mostly on the building. The June 2026 petition was disposed of at its preliminary hearing, about six weeks after the provisional order, and the October 2026 order gave the flat owners eight weeks to respond. The largest cost is usually the measured survey and drawings, which grow with the size of the building. Professional fees depend on the number of owners, hearings and forums, so any amount is indicative only.

Where do owners go wrong when they answer a provisional order?

What we see go wrong is seldom the law. It is the first fortnight. Owners read the word demolish and either do nothing or go straight to the High Court without replying, which is how a corporation's counsel came to inform the court in June 2026 that no action had been taken because no reply had been filed. Others send a one-line letter asking for time, admit a deviation nobody has measured, or continue building to finish before the hearing. In apartment buildings, owners often assume the builder will answer for them, when the October 2026 order expects the purchasers to respond themselves. The hearing usually turns on a plan sheet read against an honest measurement, and both deserve care before the reply is written.

What to have in hand before the hearing:

The sanctioned plan

The approved plan with its sanction letter, and any modified plan or plinth certificate, is the yardstick against which every deviation alleged in the provisional order is measured.

A measured statement

An architect's or engineer's measurement of each setback, the ground coverage, the built-up area on each floor and the number of floors, set against the plan item by item.

Proof of dates

The date the order reached you and any joint inspection notice fix your time limits, while the khata extract and tax receipts show who the khatadar is.

A written request

A request for the inspection report and measurements, a date for the personal hearing, and a reasoned order that deals with each point raised in your reply.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is a provisional order under Section 243 the same as a demolition order?

No. It is a proposal that binds you only when the Commissioner confirms it under Section 243(3)(e), after you have had the chance to show cause and a personal hearing. Demolition by the Corporation follows only a confirmed order that has not been obeyed.

How many days do I get to reply to a provisional order?

The time named in the notice served with it, which Section 243(3)(d) says must not be less than fifteen days. The Act counts it from service, or from sending where the notice was sent by registered post, so take the earliest possible date as day one and file a reply on the merits within it.

Can the City Corporation demolish my building without a personal hearing?

No. The proviso to Section 243(3)(d) requires a personal hearing before any confirmation order, and the Supreme Court's 2024 directions require it to be minuted. If you do not attend when you are called, though, the Commissioner may decide the matter on its merits.

The order was not addressed to me, but I own a flat in the building. Can I still reply?

Yes. In October 2026 the High Court directed that copies of the orders be served on every occupant of an apartment complex, with a chance to reply and a personal hearing. Write in as soon as you learn of the proceedings, because the Act does not require the notice to name each occupier.

Who hears an appeal against a confirmed order?

The Chief Commissioner of the Greater Bengaluru Authority, under Section 250. The appeal must be filed within thirty days from the date you received the decision, and the Chief Commissioner is to decide it within ninety days.

Can I keep building while I reply to the provisional order?

You should not. Section 243(3) lets the order direct you to refrain from building until it is complied with, and in June 2026 the High Court barred further construction even while it shielded the owner from precipitous action.

Can my electricity and water be cut because of a provisional order?

In October 2026 the High Court quashed a City Corporation's communications to BESCOM and BWSSB for disconnection where the occupants had not been heard. Section 246(5) speaks of giving a permanent connection to a building without an occupancy certificate, not, in its words, of cutting an existing supply.

The order reached me only by e-mail. Does that count as service?

It can. Section 345(1) of the Act allows service by e-mail or other electronic means, so do not ignore it. The Supreme Court's 2024 directions require a show cause notice before demolition to go by registered post with acknowledgment due and to be fixed on the structure, so a notice that came only by e-mail is a point for your reply, not a reason to wait.

This article is for general informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Consult a qualified advocate for advice on your specific situation.

References

  1. Greater Bengaluru Governance Act, 2024 (Karnataka Act No. 36 of 2025), English text published by the Department of Parliamentary Affairs and Legislation, Karnataka, in force from 15 May 2025: sections 87, 147(3), 172, 174, 241, 243, 244, 246, 249, 250, 345 and 361.
  2. Greater Bengaluru Governance (Second Amendment) Act, 2025 (Karnataka Act No. 01 of 2026), published in the Karnataka Gazette Extraordinary on 7 January 2026: section 7 makes Section 241(4) refer to condonable limits and a compounding fee specified in the bye-laws with the Government's approval, and omits the ten percent proviso.
  3. Karnataka High Court, W.P. No. 17625 of 2026 (LB-BMP), an owner v the Greater Bengaluru Authority and others, 2026:KHC:28700, oral order of 12 June 2026: a provisional order under Section 243 challenged for want of inspection, disposed of with liberty to respond within a week, a personal hearing and a reasoned order, no precipitous action meanwhile and no further construction.
  4. Karnataka High Court, W.P. No. 31128 of 2026 (LB-BMP), flat owners v the Chief Commissioner, Greater Bengaluru Authority and others, 2026:KHC:55241, oral order of 5 October 2026: the provisional order did not say to whom it was addressed, the confirmation order was read down as a continuation of it, copies were to be served on every occupant with a personal hearing under the proviso to Section 243(3)(d), and the disconnection communications to BESCOM and BWSSB were quashed.
  5. Supreme Court of India, In Re: Directions in the matter of demolition of structures, W.P. (Civil) No. 295 of 2022, 2024 INSC 866, judgment of 13 November 2024: directions under Article 142 on the show cause notice, personal hearing, final order, a fifteen-day pause and the conduct of demolitions (paragraphs 90 to 95), not applicable to structures in public places or to demolitions ordered by a court (paragraph 91).
  6. Real Estate (Regulation and Development) Act, 2016, as published by K-RERA: sections 14(1), 18(3) and 71(1).

Related Legal Services

Dealing with a matter like this? Our Bangalore advocates can help. Explore the relevant practice areas:

SJ

About the Author

Advocate Sharan Jain

Advocate based in Bangalore, practising before the Karnataka High Court and District, Sessions, Consumer and Family courts. Writes on civil, criminal, corporate, family and constitutional law to make Indian law more accessible.

Related Articles

S Jain & Attorneys · Legal Consultation

Have a Legal Question? We're Here to Help.

Our experienced lawyers in Bangalore offer confidential consultations tailored to your specific legal needs.

All matters handled with complete confidentiality and legal discretion.