Yes, a company or LLP in default can apply for its own insolvency under section 10 of the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code, 2016, but filing does not stop the bank. The moratorium that bars SARFAESI enforcement starts only when the National Company Law Tribunal (NCLT) admits the application, and the NCLT will refuse an application it finds was made to stall recovery rather than to resolve the debt. On 25 August 2026 the National Company Law Appellate Tribunal (NCLAT) affirmed exactly that refusal in Panshul Agro Food LLP v State Bank of India, where the application followed the bank's recovery case by six days and machinery charged to the bank had gone missing, though it cut the penalty from Rs 10 lakh to Rs 5 lakh. The same tribunal held in 2024 that a bank's SARFAESI steps, on their own, do not make a section 10 application malicious, so the answer turns on what else your record shows.
Part of the money recovery practice at S Jain & Attorneys, Bangalore.
This guide is for the managing director of a company, or the designated partner of an LLP, whose account is a non-performing asset, who holds a notice under section 13(2) of the SARFAESI Act and a summons from the Debts Recovery Tribunal (DRT), and who has been told to "file our own IBC" for a moratorium. A company facing a supplier's demand notice should instead read our guide on replying to a section 8 notice.
The clock in the August 2026 case, as the NCLAT recorded it:
- 13 December 2019: a Rs 28.44 crore facility from State Bank of India, renewed at Rs 40.19 crore in July 2024.
- 18 April 2025: the account is classified as a non-performing asset.
- 20 June 2025: the bank issues its notice under section 13(2) of the SARFAESI Act.
- 5 August 2025: a resolution is passed approving a section 10 application.
- 20 August 2025: the bank files its original application in the DRT.
- 26 August 2025: the LLP files under section 10, stating a default of about Rs 42.2 crore.
- 6 September 2025: the bank takes symbolic possession.
- 10 February 2026: a bank inspection finds substantial plant and machinery missing from the factory.
- 29 April 2026: the NCLT at Ahmedabad dismisses the application and imposes Rs 10 lakh.
- 25 August 2026: the NCLAT upholds the dismissal and reduces the penalty to Rs 5 lakh.
What the NCLT weighs, set against that ruling and an earlier NCLAT ruling that went the other way:
| Question the NCLT asks | Panshul Agro, August 2026: application dismissed | Getz Cables, November 2024: rejection set aside |
|---|---|---|
| Is there a debt and a default? | Yes, about Rs 42.2 crore, but the NCLAT held that debt and default did not oblige the tribunal to admit | Yes, and the NCLAT said SARFAESI or DRT proceedings can themselves help prove the default |
| When was it filed, against the bank's steps? | Six days after the DRT case, as coercive SARFAESI action began | After the section 13(2) notice and the possession notice, which the NCLAT held was not enough by itself |
| Are the charged assets intact and accounted for? | Machinery missing, no purchase invoices, no fixed asset register | No finding that any asset had been moved |
| What else was shown? | The timing and the missing machinery together | Nothing beyond the SARFAESI proceedings |
| Result | Dismissal upheld as malicious, penalty cut to Rs 5 lakh | Rejection and Rs 1 lakh penalty set aside, application sent back to be decided afresh |
Three points to hold before anything else:
Filing stops nothing
The section 14 moratorium, which bars SARFAESI enforcement, is declared on the insolvency commencement date, which for a section 10 application is the date the NCLT admits it.
Default is not enough
In August 2026 the NCLAT held the NCLT must sift the record and need not admit a section 10 application merely because it shows a debt and a default.
SARFAESI alone is not malice
In Getz Cables the NCLAT held that a bank's section 13(2) and 13(4) steps before the filing cannot, by themselves, prove fraudulent or malicious intent.
Can our company file its own insolvency under Section 10, and who must approve it?
Yes, if it has defaulted on at least Rs 1 crore, the shareholders or partners approve, and the purpose is resolution rather than delay. Section 10(1) says that where a corporate debtor "has committed a default, a corporate applicant thereof may file an application". The corporate applicant, defined in section 5(5), is the company or LLP itself, a member or partner authorised by its constitutional document, the individual managing its operations, or the person who controls its financial affairs. An LLP is a "corporate person" under section 3(7). The minimum default for Part II is Rs 1 crore, fixed on 24 March 2020 by notification S.O. 1205(E), and our threshold guide explains how it is counted.
A board resolution is not enough. Section 10(3)(c) requires "the special resolution passed by shareholders of the corporate debtor or the resolution passed by at least three-fourth of the total number of partners of the corporate debtor, as the case may be, approving filing of the application". For a company, that means the shareholders in a general meeting. For an LLP, three-fourths of all its partners, not three-fourths of those who turn up. The meeting itself must be valid. In the Intarvo Technologies appeals, decided on 30 October 2026, the NCLAT upheld a finding that the directors who convened the meeting had ceased to hold office, so the special resolution was "unauthorised, invalid and non est in law".
Section 11 shuts the door on a company already in a resolution process or a pre-pack, one that completed a resolution process in the preceding twelve months, one that breached a plan approved twelve months before, and one under a liquidation order. The application goes to the NCLT bench with territorial jurisdiction over the registered office, under section 60(1).
The Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code (Amendment) Act, 2026, in force on these points from 26 May 2026, changed section 10 in three ways. The company no longer proposes its interim resolution professional: clause (b) of section 10(3) was omitted and new section 16(3A) has the NCLT ask the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Board of India (IBBI) to recommend one. Section 10(3)(a) now calls for "any other information, as may be specified". And a tribunal that does not decide within fourteen days must record its reasons. Section 10(3)(c) and section 65(1) are unchanged. For financial creditors under section 7 the Act added an Explanation that once the clause (a) requirements are met, "no other ground shall be considered to reject an application", and it added none to section 10. On our reading that leaves room for the scrutiny the NCLAT described in August 2026, though no ruling on the point has been found.
Will filing stop the bank's SARFAESI sale of the factory?
No, not until the NCLT admits the application. Section 10(5) says the process commences on admission, and section 14(1) has the tribunal declare the moratorium "on the insolvency commencement date". Only then does clause (c) bar "any action to foreclose, recover or enforce any security interest created by the corporate debtor in respect of its property including any action under" the SARFAESI Act. A pending section 10 application carries no interim moratorium. In the August 2026 case the bank took symbolic possession eleven days after the filing.
The wait is real. Section 10(4) gives the NCLT fourteen days, but where the bank opposes, the Ahmedabad bench took about eight months to dismiss the August 2025 application, and in Getz Cables the New Delhi bench took about eleven months, while the bank remained free to continue under SARFAESI. Admission binds the company too: section 14(1)(b) then bars it from transferring, encumbering or disposing of its assets, and the moratorium ends when a plan is approved or liquidation is ordered.
Common mistake. Treating the date of filing as the date of protection. The moratorium runs from admission, so a filing made to beat a possession notice or an auction date does not stop either, and the timing can be read against you if the bank later alleges malice.
What did the NCLAT decide in August 2026 about a Section 10 filing made after SARFAESI began?
It upheld the dismissal of the application as malicious. The LLP argued that a section 10 tribunal looks only at debt and default, that the SARFAESI proceedings were no ground for rejection, and that it could not be blamed for missing machinery once the bank had taken possession. The bank answered that the filing was meant to stop it proceeding in the DRT, that the machinery was taken away before the filing, and that the factory land belonged to the partners and their families, who were guarantors and whose own petitions under section 94 had been rejected.
The NCLAT, recording the NCLT's order of 29 April 2026, noted the bank's inspection findings, the absence of purchase invoices for the machinery, the lack of any fixed asset register, and the NCLT's view that the business was not a going concern. It then held three things. First, the "unexplained removal of hypothecated assets" and the timing, filed as coercive action under SARFAESI began, led it to conclude that, prima facie, "the intent of the application was not of resolution, rather it was to obtain moratorium in order to defeat the proceedings of SARFAESI Act". Second, it is "not only the jurisdiction but the duty" of the NCLT to sift the record and decide whether the filing is a genuine attempt to resolve the debt or is meant to derail recovery, so the tribunal is not to act "like a rubber stamp". Third, "removal of plant and machinery from the factory site during the process of recovery is a very serious incident".
On the penalty the LLP partly succeeded. The NCLAT held that a penalty needs reasons and "a maxim of proportionality", found Rs 10 lakh "on the higher side, more so when no reason has been given", and reduced it to Rs 5 lakh, payable to the Prime Minister's National Relief Fund within thirty days. The appeal was decided at the admission stage, after the bank was heard.
What makes a Section 10 application "fraudulent or malicious"?
Something beyond the fact that the filing will halt the bank's recovery. Section 65(1) penalises a person who initiates an insolvency process "fraudulently or with malicious intent for any purpose other than for the resolution of insolvency". In Getz Cables Pvt Ltd v State Bank of India on 21 November 2024, where the bank's section 65 application rested only on its SARFAESI steps, the NCLAT set aside the rejection. It held that proving malice needs "a wrongful act with absence of any justification and intent of causing a particular harm", that SARFAESI steps under section 13(2) and (4) before the filing "cannot be a ground to hold that Section 10 application is filed with malicious and fraudulent intent", and that "something more is required to be pleaded and proved". A filing "consequent of which the recovery proceedings may be halted" is not malicious for that reason alone, though where another purpose is proved the tribunal is "fully justified" in rejecting.
The rulings show what the "something more" has looked like:
- Charged assets moved or unaccounted for, with the filing timed to the start of coercive recovery, as in the August 2026 case.
- A record of avoiding the bank and stacking litigation, ending in a filing after the auction. In Agroha Paper Industries Pvt Ltd v Bank of Maharashtra in July 2024 the application was complete and section 11 did not apply, yet the NCLAT upheld its dismissal: the company had dodged wilful-defaulter hearings, its property had been taken and auctioned under SARFAESI before it filed, and it had made "incessant efforts to put a spanner in the recovery proceedings".
- Concealing a creditor, as in the Intarvo Technologies appeals, where the NCLAT said section 65 exists to stop the process being used "as a shield against creditors or as a device to obtain an undeserved moratorium".
- Doubtful authority for the filing and an unexplained write-off of related-party receivables, also in Intarvo.
The test cuts both ways. A company in genuine distress whose books are complete, whose charged assets are where the bank's charge says they are, and whose application discloses the bank's claim in full is not shut out because the bank moved first. A company whose real aim is a stay order should expect the bank to oppose it with a section 65 application and documents, and on the 2026 rulings the NCLT will listen.
What penalty can the Tribunal impose, and on whom?
Under section 65(1), a penalty of not less than Rs 1 lakh and up to Rs 1 crore on the person who initiated the process. It fell on the LLP in the August 2026 case and on the company in Intarvo, Rs 5 lakh in each after the appeals, and in Getz Cables the Rs 1 lakh penalty fell with the finding of malice. Section 64A, in force from 26 May 2026, adds a second penalty, of Rs 1 lakh to Rs 2 crore, for any person who has initiated "a frivolous or vexatious proceeding" before the NCLT under Part II. On our reading that wording can reach a section 10 application, though we have not found an order applying section 64A to one.
The individuals carry a separate risk. Section 77 makes it an offence for a corporate debtor to give information in a section 10 application that is false in material particulars, knowing it to be false, and to omit a material fact, knowing it to be material, and it extends to any person who knowingly and wilfully authorised or permitted it. The punishment is three to five years in prison, a fine of Rs 1 lakh to Rs 1 crore, or both. None of the rulings discussed here applied section 77, but it is written for the people who sign and approve Form 6.
Key takeaway. The penalty for a malicious filing is usually the smaller cost. The larger one is losing the moratorium you filed for, a recorded finding of bad faith that stays with the company, and in a case like Intarvo the collapse of a process that had already produced a plan approved by the creditors' committee.
Do we lose control of the company the day it is admitted?
Yes. Section 17(1) hands the management of the company's affairs to the interim resolution professional once appointed and suspends "the powers of the board of directors or the partners of the corporate debtor, as the case may be". Officers report to the professional, and the company's bankers act on the professional's instructions. Since 26 May 2026 the professional is not someone the company chooses: section 16(3A) has the NCLT ask the IBBI for a recommendation whenever the application is made under section 10. The suspended directors' duties and exposure are set out in our guide on a director's position after admission.
What happens to the personal guarantees the directors or partners signed?
They stay enforceable. Section 14(3)(b) leaves "a surety in a contract of guarantee to a corporate debtor" outside the moratorium, so the bank can pursue the directors or partners on their guarantees, including by a petition under section 95, while the company is protected. The 2026 Amendment Act added an Explanation that works the other way: a guarantor who wants to proceed against the company under its guarantee is caught by the moratorium. The August 2026 case shows the limits of a company filing for its guarantors' sake. The factory land there belonged to the partners and their families, not to the LLP, so on our reading the LLP's moratorium would not have reached it, and their own section 94 petitions were rejected. A guarantor's own options are in our guarantor's guide.
Can the promoters bid for the company in the resolution process?
Only where section 29A allows it. Clause (c) excludes a person whose account, or that of a company they manage or promote, was classified a non-performing asset a year or more before the process commences, unless every overdue amount with interest and charges is paid before the plan goes in. For a micro, small or medium enterprise, section 240A(1) lifts that clause and clause (h) on invoked guarantees. The other bars, and how each falls on a suspended director, are in our director's guide.
Is the MSME pre-pack a better route for us?
Only if the bank agrees, where it holds most of the financial debt. Chapter III-A, from section 54A, is open to a corporate debtor classified as a micro, small or medium enterprise, with a minimum default of Rs 10 lakh fixed by notification S.O. 1543(E) of 9 April 2021. Section 54A(3) requires approval from financial creditors who are not related parties, holding not less than fifty-one per cent in value of the financial debt due to them, a figure lowered from sixty-six per cent by the 2026 Amendment Act. The same creditors must propose the resolution professional. The shareholders must pass a special resolution, or three-fourths of the partners a resolution, and a majority of the directors or partners must declare that the process "is not being initiated to defraud any person". The company must hand the creditors a base resolution plan before asking for their approval.
Under section 54H the board or the partners keep management during the process, subject to conditions, and section 54D requires the process to be completed within 120 days. Section 65(3) carries the same penalty for a pre-pack initiated fraudulently or with intent to defraud. Where one bank holds most of the financial debt and has already started SARFAESI, the pre-pack is a negotiation with that bank, not a way round it.
The rules that decide the choice, as the Code sets them:
Section 10 application
Shareholders' special resolution or three-fourths of partners, minimum default Rs 1 crore, management passes to an interim resolution professional on admission, and no moratorium until then.
MSME pre-pack
Needs approval of unrelated financial creditors holding fifty-one per cent of their debt, a base plan, a Rs 10 lakh minimum default and a declaration against fraud.
Penalty for abuse
Section 65 allows Rs 1 lakh to Rs 1 crore for a fraudulent or malicious filing, and section 64A up to Rs 2 crore for a frivolous or vexatious one.
No walking away
Once admitted, the company cannot pull out on its own. Section 12A needs the resolution professional to apply with ninety per cent of the voting share in the creditors' committee behind the request.
What must the Form 6 application disclose, and what if we leave a creditor out?
Everything, because an omission can unwind the process years later. Rule 7 of the Application to Adjudicating Authority Rules, 2016 requires Form 6, which asks creditor by creditor for the debt, the amount in default and any security held, and annexes the books evidencing the default, audited accounts for two years, provisional accounts made up to a date not earlier than fourteen days before the application, and a statement of affairs listing assets, secured claims, every creditor and the guarantees given. Since 2 June 2026, regulation 2E of the IBBI's resolution process regulations adds, among other things, three years of information on bank accounts and assets including a fixed assets register "along with asset location", a list of all creditors, all ongoing litigation and arbitration, and assets under attachment.
The Intarvo Technologies appeals show what concealment costs. The company filed under section 10 on 15 December 2022, about six weeks after a civil court decreed a sum of about Rs 47 lakh against it, and left the decree holder out of Part III of Form 6. The application was admitted in October 2023, and the creditors' committee approved a resolution plan in July 2024. The decree holder then applied under section 65, and the NCLT recalled the admission, restored the company to its pre-insolvency position and imposed Rs 5 lakh. Upholding that on 30 October 2026, the NCLAT held that a section 10 applicant must make "a full and truthful disclosure of its financial position and liabilities", that the concealment of the decree was "by itself sufficient" to sustain the finding, that a second, older decree had also been left out, and that a plan approved by the committee but not yet by the tribunal could not survive a process started by fraud.
Deadline warning. Provisional accounts must be made up to a date not earlier than fourteen days before the application, and so must the statement of affairs. A Form 6 assembled over a month from old figures does not meet that requirement and invites the question of what changed in between.
Can we withdraw once it is admitted?
Not on your own say. Before admission, rule 8 lets the NCLT permit withdrawal on the applicant's request. After admission, section 12A, substituted in 2026, permits withdrawal only on the resolution professional's application backed by ninety per cent of the voting share in the committee, and never before the committee is formed or after the first invitation to submit resolution plans. The mechanics are in our guide on settling and withdrawing after admission.
Step by step: the thirty days before filing
- List every lender and creditor with the non-performing asset date, each notice, each DRT or civil case, and every decree or award against the company, including old ones.
- Walk the factory with the bank's hypothecation schedule and the fixed asset register, and account in writing for every item that has been sold, scrapped or moved, with invoices.
- Put a settlement or restructuring proposal to the bank, and if the company is an MSME, test whether the bank would approve a pre-pack.
- Check on the MCA records that the directors are validly in office, then have the board convene a general meeting for the special resolution, or for an LLP obtain a resolution of three-fourths of all partners.
- Prepare Form 6 with the books, two years of audited accounts, provisional accounts and a statement of affairs no older than fourteen days, and the regulation 2E information.
- State the SARFAESI and DRT proceedings in the application yourself, with the bank's figures, rather than leave the bank to raise them.
- Serve a copy on the IBBI before filing, as rule 7(2) requires, and pay the fee.
- File at the bench with jurisdiction over the registered office, expect the bank to oppose, and answer any section 65 application on affidavit with documents.
- If the application is refused, appeal to the NCLAT within thirty days, with up to fifteen more days only for sufficient cause.
What does it cost and how long does it take?
The statutory costs are modest and the delay is the larger price. The Schedule to the Application Rules, as the IBBI publishes it, sets Rs 25,000 for an application by a corporate debtor. In July 2026 the New Delhi bench admitted the section 10 application of Nicia Food And Drinks Pvt Ltd on its audited losses, the Form 6 creditor lists and a special resolution, declared the moratorium and directed the company to deposit Rs 2 lakh with the interim resolution professional for initial expenses. A finding of malice adds the penalties described above.
On time, the fourteen days in section 10(4) did not hold in the contested cases discussed here, where the NCLT took between about eight months and a year. The NCLAT decided the August 2026 appeal three months after it was filed, while the Intarvo Technologies appeals took more than fifteen months, and section 61(6) now sets three months as the target. If admitted, section 12 gives the process 180 days, one extension of up to 90, and an ordinary outer limit of 330 days including litigation.
In our experience the consultant's pitch is a stay order with a statutory label, and the applications that fail share a pattern: they are filed in the week the bank moves, the Form 6 carries the bank but not the decree holder or the disputed supplier, and nobody can account for machinery the bank's charge covers. The applications that stand a chance start with a reconciled list of creditors and assets, a valid resolution, and an honest account of why the company cannot pay. Where those are missing, the better first step is usually a settlement proposal to the bank or, for an MSME, a pre-pack conversation.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can a company file under Section 10 after the bank has issued a SARFAESI notice?
Yes. In Getz Cables the NCLAT held that SARFAESI steps taken before the filing cannot by themselves show malice, but in August 2026 it upheld a dismissal where the filing was timed to coercive recovery and charged machinery was missing.
Does filing a Section 10 application stop a SARFAESI auction?
No. The section 14 moratorium is declared on the insolvency commencement date, which is the date the NCLT admits the application. Until then the bank may continue.
Is a board resolution enough to file?
No. Section 10(3)(c) requires a special resolution of the shareholders, or for an LLP a resolution of at least three-fourths of the total number of partners, approving the filing.
Can the NCLT reject a Section 10 application that is complete?
Yes. In Agroha Paper in 2024 the NCLAT upheld the rejection of an application it accepted was complete, and in Panshul Agro in 2026 it held that showing a debt and a default did not oblige the tribunal to admit.
Who pays the penalty for a malicious filing?
Section 65(1) imposes it on the person who initiated the process, which in both 2026 rulings was the company or LLP. Section 77 separately reaches any person who knowingly and wilfully authorised false information in the application.
Can we propose our own interim resolution professional?
Not since 26 May 2026. Clause (b) of section 10(3) was omitted, and section 16(3A) has the NCLT ask the IBBI to recommend a professional for a section 10 application.
Will the moratorium protect the directors' personal guarantees?
No. The bank can proceed against the guarantors, including under section 95, because section 14(3)(b) keeps sureties for the corporate debtor outside the moratorium.
Can we appeal if the NCLT dismisses our application?
Yes. The appeal lies to the NCLAT under section 61(2) and must be filed within thirty days, with a further fifteen days available only for sufficient cause.
This article is for general informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Consult a qualified advocate for advice on your specific situation.






