Usually nothing, and usually no appeal. An approved resolution plan binds the company's members under section 31(1) of the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code, 2016, equity shareholders stand last in the section 53 order of priority, and the National Company Law Appellate Tribunal has held that a shareholder, as such, is not a "person aggrieved" who may appeal under section 61. A larger bench said so in Park Energy Pvt Ltd v State Bank of India on 22 July 2025, and the Principal Bench applied it to orders approving plans on 30 September 2026 and again on 6 November 2026, in a case where the plan's backers said a surplus of about Rs 90 crore had been set aside for shareholders. What remains is narrower: whatever the plan gives the equity, an application under section 47 if the resolution professional has not reported a preferential or undervalued transaction or fraudulent trading, a disputed exception where the insolvency itself was collusive, and, for a listed company, the exit-price floor in the SEBI delisting rules.
Part of the corporate and commercial law practice at S Jain & Attorneys, Bangalore.
This page is for a minority shareholder of a company in the corporate insolvency resolution process (CIRP) whose approved plan extinguishes all existing equity. A homebuyer whose refund was cut should read our guide on challenging a plan as an allottee, a supplier our guide on filing a vendor's claim, and a director the guide on a director's position in CIRP.
Where your shares sit in section 53(1), the order the Code uses to distribute assets in liquidation and the measure behind the minimum a plan must pay operational creditors:
- (a) The costs of the insolvency process and of any liquidation, paid first and in full.
- (b) Workmen for the 24 months before liquidation, level with secured creditors who surrender their security.
- (c) Wages and dues of other staff for the last 12 months.
- (d) Unsecured financial creditors.
- (e) Central and State Government dues for two years, level with what secured creditors could not recover by enforcement.
- (f) Every other debt and due.
- (g) Preference shareholders.
- (h) Equity shareholders. You are here.
Four NCLAT rulings frame whether a shareholder can be heard:
| Ruling | What the shareholder challenged | What the NCLAT held |
|---|---|---|
| Park Energy, Chennai, three members on a reference, 22 July 2025 | The order admitting the company into CIRP | A shareholder or promoter is not an aggrieved person under section 61, and the appeal was later dismissed as not maintainable |
| Techindia Nirman appeal, Agri-Tech (India) Ltd as creditor, Principal Bench, three members, 15 December 2025 | The refusal to recall an admission said to be collusive, by an application under sections 60(5) and 65 | The shareholder had standing, the CIRP was set aside as fraudulently initiated, and the creditor was ordered to pay costs of Rs 25 lakh |
| Windsor Paradise appeal, Principal Bench, 30 September 2026 | Approval of a plan said to have been modified after the committee's vote | Not maintainable because the appellant was only a shareholder, merits not decided |
| NKAY Investment appeals, Gstaad Hotels, Principal Bench, 6 November 2026 | Approval of a plan that cancelled all equity for nil, with a residual sum for shareholders | Not maintainable, a residual amount does not enlarge a shareholder's standing |
Three rules explain most of what follows:
The plan binds members
Section 31(1) makes an approved plan binding on the company's members, and the Explanation to section 30(2)(e) deems any shareholder approval the plan needs to have been given.
Equity comes last
Equity shareholders sit at clause (h) of section 53(1), after every class of creditor and after preference shareholders, so they take only what is left over.
No appeal as shareholder
Park Energy held a shareholder is not an aggrieved person under section 61, and Principal Bench rulings in September and November 2026 applied that to orders approving plans.
Why does the approved plan give my shares nothing?
Because the Code puts the plan in the creditors' hands and puts you at the bottom. The committee of creditors comprises all financial creditors under section 21(2) and approves a plan by at least sixty-six percent of their voting share under section 30(4). Section 30(2) lists what every plan must contain: process costs paid first, a floor for operational creditors and a floor for dissenting financial creditors, moved into a new clause (ba) from 26 May 2026. Nothing in that list requires value for the equity. The order of priority in section 53(1) ends with preference shareholders "if any" at clause (g) and "equity shareholders or partners" at clause (h), so when the debts exceed the assets, as they usually do, nothing reaches you.
Your consent is not needed either. The Explanation to section 30(2)(e) says that where the Companies Act or any other law requires shareholders' approval for an action under the plan, "such approval shall be deemed to have been given", and regulation 39(6) of the CIRP Regulations lets a provision take effect even where the articles or a shareholders' agreement would otherwise require members' consent. Section 238 gives the Code overriding effect over any inconsistent law or instrument.
The Supreme Court has already answered the minority shareholder who objects. In Jaypee Kensington Boulevard Apartments Welfare Association v NBCC (India) Ltd, decided on 24 March 2021, the plan cancelled the promoters' shares for nothing and gave public shareholders an exit price of Rs 1 crore in aggregate. The Court held at paragraphs 152 to 153.2 that the minority shareholders' objections "must fail", that the attempt to object "simply flies in the face of this Explanation", and that there was "very little likelihood of the shareholders getting even dewdrops" in a liquidation, so the nominal exit price was not unfair and was a matter of the committee's commercial wisdom. The creditor's side of the same waterfall is in our vendor's guide.
Key takeaway. A plan that cancels all existing shares for nil is lawful in the ordinary case. The real question is whether this plan, or how the company got here, gives you a route the law recognises.
Could I have objected before the committee voted, and to whom?
Only to the resolution professional, because you had no seat in the room. Section 24(3) sends notice of each committee meeting to its members, the suspended directors and, where their dues reach ten percent of the debt, the operational creditors, and section 24(4) lets the directors and one operational creditors' representative attend without a vote. A shareholder who is not a director is on neither list.
The NCLAT's reasoning points you to the professional. Park Energy said, at paragraph 18, that "as far as the interest of the shareholders is concerned, it is protected by the agent or the authority appointed by the NCLT i.e., Resolution Professional, or the liquidator". Every plan must, under regulation 38(1A) of the CIRP Regulations, contain "a statement as to how it has dealt with the interests of all stakeholders", and the compliance certificate the professional files with the plan, Form H in IBBI circular No. IBBI/CIRP/94/2026 of 2 June 2026, reports the fair value, the liquidation value and the realisable amount under the plan, with a separate line for shareholders. We have not found a provision that gives a shareholder, as such, a copy of the plan or of Form H, so write to the professional early, record your holding, ask how the plan treats the equity, and keep the reply.
You can also object before the National Company Law Tribunal when it hears the plan, but expect little. In the Gstaad Hotels insolvency minority shareholders filed objections on 31 August 2026, the plan was approved on 3 September 2026, and on their account the objections were never heard. The tribunal's review under section 31(1) is whether the plan meets section 30(2), and Jaypee Kensington is against the minority shareholder on the rest.
Can I appeal the approval order under section 61?
You can file one, but on the present law it will be dismissed as not maintainable before its merits are read. Section 61(1) gives the right of appeal to "any person aggrieved", section 61(2) sets a thirty-day limit that can be stretched by fifteen days at most, and section 32 says an approval may be appealed only on the five grounds of section 61(3). The NCLAT has held repeatedly that a shareholder is not that person.
Park Energy is the reference ruling. Two-member benches had disagreed on whether a shareholder could challenge an order admitting a company into CIRP, so a three-member bench answered the reference. It followed the three-member ruling of the Principal Bench in Clarion Health Food LLP v Goli Vada Pav Pvt Ltd and held at paragraph 19 that, "the status of the shareholders being that of an investor, who have profit interest only in the Company", the proceedings at their behest "will not be maintainable". The reference concerned admission orders, but its reasoning is general, and on 18 August 2025 the appeal itself was dismissed as not maintainable.
The Principal Bench then applied it to approvals. In the appeal concerning Windsor Paradise Heights Pvt Ltd, Company Appeal (AT) (Ins) No. 1496 of 2024, a shareholder argued that the plan had been materially altered after the committee approved it, a material irregularity under section 61(3)(ii). The bench did not decide that argument. It held on 30 September 2026 that, "Exclusively, owing to the fact that, the appellant is a shareholder", his appeal was not maintainable, adding that homebuyers who never filed appeals of their own could not argue their case through his.
The NKAY Investment ruling of 6 November 2026 is the closest to your facts. The Gstaad Hotels plan, with a resolution amount of Rs 1,611 crore, extinguished "the entire existing equity share capital" for nil and gave the resolution applicant all the equity. Shareholders holding about 10 and 20 percent argued that the amount exceeded both the average fair value of Rs 1,250.58 crore and the average liquidation value of Rs 1,028.33 crore, and that nothing showed the value was exhausted before it reached the equity. The bench held that "Maintainability is a threshold jurisdictional issue" and dismissed both appeals without examining the plan.
The question is not entirely closed. The NKAY bench itself noted that Park Energy did not consider the Supreme Court's Independent Sugar Corporation ruling, which read "any person aggrieved" widely for an unsuccessful resolution applicant, in a case not about shareholders. Clarion's own appeal, Civil Appeal No. 14150 of 2024, was argued in the Supreme Court, which reserved judgment on 8 October 2026. We have found no decision on it at the time of writing. Until the Supreme Court speaks, the NCLAT treats Park Energy as binding.
Deadline warning. The appeal period is thirty days, plus at most fifteen more if the NCLAT accepts your reason for the delay. When the clock starts is explained in our guide on challenging a plan. A shareholder who means to rely on a ground other than being a shareholder must still file in time.
I am also owed money by the company: does that change anything?
It can, because the rulings bar you only in your role as a shareholder. The NKAY bench said a shareholder "simpliciter" cannot appeal "only in the role of a simpliciter shareholder" and held the appellants had no standing "being only in the role of shareholders". On our reading, if you also hold an admitted claim as a lender or supplier, your rights as that creditor are unaffected, and an appeal about that claim's treatment is a creditor's appeal, though no ruling we have found decides the point.
One limit applies. A related party financial creditor keeps its claim but, under the proviso to section 21(2), has no "right of representation, participation or voting" in the committee, and section 5(24)(j) makes any person who controls more than twenty percent of the voting rights through ownership or a voting agreement a related party. File that claim separately from anything you say as a shareholder.
The plan sets aside a surplus for shareholders: how is it shared, and can I argue it should be larger?
A surplus is paid as the plan and the tribunal direct, and arguing for a bigger one does not make you an aggrieved person. Surpluses are rare, because the plan money must exceed what every creditor is owed, as it did in Gstaad Hotels. The NCLT Mumbai bench, approving the plan on 3 September 2026, held at paragraph 89 that "the residual resolution money, if any, after settlement of the creditors claim in the aforesaid manner has to accrue to the shareholders", added at paragraph 92 that because the creditors were being paid in full, recoveries from avoidance applications still to be decided "will accrue to the shareholders", and at paragraph 101 directed an updated Form H with the resolution applicant's affidavit and the committee's ratification to show the allocation of residual money to the shareholders.
Before the NCLAT the plan's supporters said a surplus of Rs 90,12,66,290 had been realised and kept in a separate account, ready for distribution once shareholders gave their bank details. The shareholders argued that section 53(1)(h) gave them a right to the surplus and that the plan did not provide for it. The bench answered at paragraph 34: "The residual interest of equity is purely consequential upon the distribution decided by the Committee of Creditors in its commercial wisdom. Receipt of a residual amount does not enlarge the statutory standing of a shareholder so as to enable him to maintain an appeal under Section 61. The grievance that the residual amount might have been higher is not a ground that may convert a shareholder into a 'person aggrieved'." Other appeals in the same insolvency were still pending before the NCLAT at the time of writing.
Since 26 May 2026 a new proviso to section 31(1) lets the tribunal, on the professional's application approved by sixty-six percent of the committee, first approve implementation of the plan and then approve its manner of distribution within thirty days. If your plan is approved in two stages, watch the second order, which approves the distribution. Within the equity, preference shareholders rank ahead of you in section 53(1), and the split among equity holders is whatever the plan provides.
Common mistake. Treating a surplus for shareholders as a key to the appeal. The NCLAT has held it is not. Use it as a reason to prove your holding and give your bank details, not to reopen the committee's numbers.
Is there an exception where the insolvency itself was collusive?
There was one ruling recognising it, but a later bench refused to follow it and the next left it open, so do not plan around it without strong evidence. Section 65(1) lets the tribunal penalise anyone who "initiates the insolvency resolution process ... fraudulently or with malicious intent for any purpose other than for the resolution of insolvency", with a penalty of one lakh to one crore rupees. In the Techindia Nirman appeal, Company Appeal (AT) (Ins) No. 970 of 2025, a shareholder of both Techindia Nirman Ltd, a listed company, and its creditor, Agri-Tech (India) Ltd, applied under sections 60(5) and 65 to recall the admission order. The two companies shared management, the public shareholders had voted down the promoters' resolutions at both companies' general meetings in September 2024, and the creditor's section 7 petition followed weeks later on a loan its own accounts called interest-free. On 15 December 2025 a three-member bench held that he was an aggrieved person, distinguishing Park Energy because his appeal arose from a section 65 application and not a section 7 order, found the petition collusive and filed to avoid the shareholders' special resolution that section 10 requires for a company's own application, set aside the CIRP and imposed costs of Rs 25 lakh on the creditor.
The Windsor Paradise bench declined to treat that as an exception. It held that Park Energy, decided by a bench specially constituted to answer a reference, prevails over a three-member bench sitting on the ordinary roster, and rejected as "not tenable" the argument that alleged fraud let a solitary shareholder appeal, fraud being "a very fertile ground". The NKAY bench said it "may not be in agreement" with how Windsor Paradise read the earlier ruling, but left the exception to "an appropriate case" because it found no fraud before it.
On our reading, if the exception survives, it serves a shareholder who attacks the start of the insolvency as collusive, promptly and by an application under sections 60(5) and 65 supported by documents, not one who objects to the price of the plan after the committee has voted. If your complaint is about the plan's numbers, this route is unlikely to succeed.
What happens to my demat shares and the listing?
Your shares are cancelled as the plan provides, whether they sit in a demat account or on a paper register. Section 2(55)(iii) of the Companies Act, 2013 makes every person entered as a beneficial owner in a depository's records a member, and section 31(1) binds members. Keep the account statement showing your holding before the cancellation, the approval order and the plan's capital clause as proof of what you held.
If the company is listed, the SEBI rules give you a price floor, not a veto. Regulation 3(2)(b) of the SEBI (Delisting of Equity Shares) Regulations, 2021 says the regulations do not apply to a delisting under a plan approved under section 31 if the plan provides for delisting or for "an exit opportunity to the existing public shareholders at a specified price". The first proviso requires that exit price to be "not less than the price, by whatever name called, at which a promoter or any entity belonging to the promoter group or any other shareholder" gets an exit, and the second requires the details and the justification for the exit price to be disclosed to the stock exchanges within one day of approval. Item 16 of Part A of Schedule III to the SEBI (Listing Obligations and Disclosure Requirements) Regulations, 2015 separately requires a listed company to disclose the plan's specific features on approval, including the pre and post shareholding pattern and any delisting plan. Where the promoters get nothing, as in Jaypee Kensington, that floor can be very low.
A private or already delisted company has nothing to delist. The tax treatment of the cancelled holding is outside this guide: take the approval order and your purchase records to a chartered accountant.
The routes that remain for a shareholder, in short:
Write to the professional
Park Energy says the resolution professional protects the shareholders' interest, so record your holding with the professional and ask how the plan treats the equity before the committee votes.
Claim any surplus
Where the plan leaves residual money for shareholders, prove your holding and give your bank details. Arguing for a larger surplus does not make you an aggrieved person.
Report hidden transactions
As a member you may now ask the tribunal yourself to undo a preference or undervalue, or to make directors contribute for fraudulent or wrongful trading, if the professional stays silent.
Is there anything I can pursue against the promoters or directors, and who can bring it?
Yes, and here the Code now names you. Section 47, as substituted by the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code (Amendment) Act, 2026 and in force from 26 May 2026, provides that where a preferential transaction under section 43, an undervalued transaction under section 45, an extortionate credit transaction under section 50, or fraudulent or wrongful trading under section 66 has occurred and the professional has not reported it, "a creditor, either by itself or jointly with other creditors, a member, or a partner" may apply to the tribunal. If the tribunal finds the transaction proved it passes orders as though the professional had applied, and if it finds the professional sat on information he had, it must direct the IBBI to start disciplinary proceedings against him.
Such an application outlives the process, because substituted section 26 provides that completing the CIRP "shall not affect the continuation of proceedings" of this kind. CIRP regulation 38(2)(d) makes each plan state how pending avoidance and wrongful trading cases will be run after approval and where any money recovered will go, so read that clause before you apply. In Gstaad Hotels, where creditors were paid in full, the tribunal directed those recoveries to the shareholders.
Claims against the people also survive. Section 31(6), new in 2026, wipes out claims that arose before approval against the company and what it owns, unless the plan keeps them alive, while Explanation I preserves claims and proceedings against anyone who was "a promoter or in the management or control" of the company. That leaves, and does not create, whatever claim you have against them under another law. Section 66 and the directors' exposure are explained in our guide to a director's position in CIRP.
What do shareholders get if the company is liquidated instead?
Whatever is left after every creditor, if anything, and the liquidator stands where the professional stood. Under section 33 a liquidation order follows if no plan is filed with the tribunal before time runs out, if the tribunal rejects the plan, in either case subject since 26 May 2026 to one restoration under section 33(1A), or if sixty-six percent of the committee votes for liquidation. The liquidator distributes in the section 53(1) order, so equity shareholders receive something only if preference shareholders and every creditor above them are paid first. Park Energy treats the liquidator, like the professional, as the protector of the shareholders' interest. Claims in a liquidation are covered in our vendor's guide.
Step by step: from the public announcement to the end of the appeal window
- Read the public announcement in Form A and note the interim resolution professional's details.
- Write to the professional with your folio or demat details and the number and class of shares you hold, and ask to be told how the plan treats shareholders.
- If the company owes you money, file your claim on the form for your class of creditor, separately and on time.
- Put any transaction that moved value to promoters or their friends to the professional in writing with documents, and if it is not reported, consider section 47.
- Watch for the invitation for expressions of interest in Form G, and after the committee approves a plan by sixty-six percent, for the professional's application to the tribunal with Form H.
- If you mean to object at the approval hearing, file before the tribunal reserves or pronounces orders, and keep it to compliance with section 30(2).
- On approval, obtain the order, the plan's capital and distribution clauses and, for a listed company, the stock exchange disclosures.
- Within thirty days of the order, decide whether you have any ground other than being a shareholder. If not, an appeal is unlikely to be heard on its merits.
- If the plan leaves residual money for shareholders, prove your holding and give your bank details to the professional or the monitoring committee.
If the promoters are trying to settle with the creditors and take the company out of the process, the route and its limits are in our guide on withdrawal under section 12A. If your stake was diluted by a share allotment before any insolvency, that is a different question, covered in our guide on a contested allotment.
What does it cost to be heard, and is it worth it?
On the present law, an appeal as a shareholder costs fees, time and some risk to buy a dismissal on maintainability. The NKAY appeals were dismissed about six weeks after filing, while the Windsor Paradise appeal, filed in July 2024, was decided in September 2026, although section 61(6) now asks the NCLAT to decide an appeal within three months. Since 26 May 2026 section 64A also lets the NCLT fine anyone who brings a frivolous or vexatious proceeding before it under Part II, from one lakh up to two crore rupees, and the collusive-initiation ruling shows the tribunal will also make a party pay where the process itself is abused.
In our experience the shareholders who lose most first act after the approval order. They never wrote to the professional, they appeal on price, and they miss the surplus or the section 47 application the law does allow. The useful work is early and narrow: proving the holding, asking how the equity is treated, and putting documents about any suspicious transaction on record while the professional can still act. A minority shareholder of a company admitted on a related creditor's petition, with evidence of collusion, is in a different position from one who simply thinks the plan was too cheap, and the first conversation should be about which of the two you are.
Where the plan leaves nothing for the equity and you hold no evidence of collusion, keep the papers and concentrate on any claim against the promoters personally.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can a resolution plan cancel my shares without my consent?
Yes. Section 31(1) makes an approved plan binding on members, the Explanation to section 30(2)(e) deems any shareholder approval to have been given, and regulation 39(6) lets the plan take effect despite the articles or a shareholders' agreement. In Jaypee Kensington the Supreme Court rejected minority shareholders' objections to such a plan.
Can a minority shareholder appeal against the order approving the plan?
Not on present NCLAT law. Park Energy held a shareholder is not an aggrieved person under section 61, and the Principal Bench applied that to approval orders on 30 September 2026 and 6 November 2026, dismissing those appeals on maintainability alone.
The plan pays more than the liquidation value. Should the excess not come to shareholders?
The NCLAT has held that the size of any residual is decided by the committee's commercial wisdom and that a grievance about it does not give a shareholder standing. Where a plan does leave residual money for shareholders, as in Gstaad Hotels, it is paid as the plan and the tribunal direct.
Does holding a large minority stake, such as 20 percent, change the answer?
Not as a shareholder. The NKAY appellants held about 10 and 20 percent and were still held to lack standing. A holding above twenty percent of the voting rights may also make you a related party under section 5(24)(j) if you are owed money as a creditor.
What if I believe the promoters and a friendly lender pushed the company into insolvency?
A 2025 three-member bench set aside a CIRP on a shareholder's section 65 application where the creditor and the company shared management and the petition was found collusive. A later bench refused to treat that as an exception and the next left it open, so you need documents, and you need to act at the start, not after the plan is approved.
Can I bring an application against the directors myself?
Yes, where the professional has failed to report the transaction or trading. Section 47 as it stands from 26 May 2026 names a member among those who may apply, and section 26 keeps the application going after the CIRP has ended.
The company was listed. Am I entitled to an exit price?
Only if the plan provides for delisting or an exit at a specified price, in which case regulation 3(2)(b) of the Delisting Regulations requires the public shareholders' price to be not less than the price at which a promoter or any other shareholder exits. If the promoters get nothing, the floor may be nominal.
How long do I have to act after the plan is approved?
Thirty days to appeal under section 61(2), extendable by no more than fifteen. For a shareholder, the more useful steps, writing to the professional and placing evidence of suspicious transactions on record, belong before the committee votes.
This article is for general informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Consult a qualified advocate for advice on your specific situation.






