Corporate & Commercial Law

The Resolution Professional Wants Back the Money the Company Repaid Me Before Insolvency: Do I Have to Return It?

By Advocate Sharan Jain

The Resolution Professional Wants Back the Money the Company Repaid Me Before Insolvency: Do I Have to Return It?

Only if the payment meets every test in section 43 of the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code, 2016 and no exception applies. The resolution professional must show that the company transferred its money or property for your benefit on account of a debt it already owed you, that this left you better off than a liquidation distribution under section 53 would, and that it happened inside the look-back window, which since 26 May 2026 runs from two years before the insolvency application was filed for a related party, or one year for anyone else, to the admission date. The main defence, the ordinary course of business, is yours to prove with documents: on 6 February 2026 the National Company Law Appellate Tribunal (NCLAT) upheld an order making a director repay about Rs 19.66 lakh, finding he had produced no document showing ordinary business (the M.K. Printech director's appeal, CA(AT)(Ins) 2025/2024).

Part of the corporate and commercial law practice at S Jain & Attorneys, Bangalore.

This guide is for a relative, friend, supplier or former director repaid by the company and now served with the resolution professional's application under section 43 or 45. The suspended director's side of the look-back is in our guide on which past transactions will be dug up in a CIRP.

The testWhere it is in the CodeWhere the case is won or lost
The company transferred its money or property for your benefitSection 43(2)(a)Whether the company made the transfer. A book entry counts, a bank's unilateral transfer did not
For a debt it already owed youSection 43(2)(a)A gift, or a sale not made against a debt, is not a preference but may be undervalued under section 45
It left you better off than a liquidation distribution wouldSection 43(2)(b) with section 53Hard to answer for an unsecured creditor paid while secured lenders were not
Inside the windowSection 43(4), amended from 26 May 2026The dates of the application, the admission and each payment
The ordinary-course exception, yours to proveSection 43(3)(a)Invoices, orders, delivery records and a payment pattern older than the trouble

Three facts decide most of these applications.

Your window

Two years for a related party and one year for anyone else, counted back from the day the insolvency application was filed and running to the admission date.

Proof is on you

Once a related-party payment of an old debt inside the window is shown, the onus shifts to you to prove the ordinary-course exception with invoices and delivery records.

Entries count too

A set-off or journal entry that cancels a debt owed to the company, or moves its assets into your loan account, is a transfer of property under section 43.

It depends on your relationship with the company when you were paid. Section 5(24) of the Code makes a related party of, among others, a director or partner, a key managerial person, a relative of any of them, and a private company in which a director of the debtor is a director and holds, with relatives, more than two per cent of its capital. A related party's window is two years, everyone else's one. Since the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code (Amendment) Act, 2026 amended section 43(4) from 26 May 2026 under S.O. 2625(E), each window starts that far before the initiation date, the day the application was filed, and ends on admission, so for a petition filed in 2024 and admitted in June 2026 a related party's window opens in 2022. Where several applications were pending at admission, the first one filed sets the date.

A friend or unconnected supplier is not a related party for that reason alone, unless a clause such as (h), a person on whose advice a director is accustomed to act, or (j), control of more than twenty per cent of the votes, fits. A supplier company with a common director should read clause (d), which the NCLT Kolkata, in a creditor-classification dispute, held is met on the shareholding figures alone, without proof of control, though a nominee directorship alone did not satisfy clauses (h) and (m)(i) (Abinandan Holdings Pvt Ltd v the Howrah Mills interim resolution professional, 15 September 2026, now under appeal). Clause (a) speaks of "a director", so our reading is that one who resigned before the payment may fall in the one-year class unless (j), a spouse still on the board or another clause applies. No order we have read decides that.

The 2026 Act gives the amended section 43(4) no transitional rule. In October 2026, on a process that began in November 2021, the NCLT Mumbai quoted the new words but counted two years back from 22 November 2021. No order we have read decides which version governs a process admitted before 26 May 2026, so a payment caught only by the wider window is worth contesting.

What is the ordinary-course defence, and what papers prove it?

It is section 43(3)(a), which excludes a transfer made "in the ordinary course of the business or financial affairs of the corporate debtor or the transferee", and it is harder than it reads. The Supreme Court in the Jaypee Infratech case (the interim resolution professional v Axis Bank Ltd, 26 February 2020) read the "or" as "and": the transfer must be in the ordinary course of both the company's affairs and yours, so a lender or supplier cannot rely on its own routine alone, and it must "fall into place as part of the undistinguished common flow of business done". The burden is yours. In the Nirmangold Alloys insolvency (IA 2595/2022, 16 October 2026) the NCLT Mumbai said the fact "needs to be established and it just cannot be assumed", and reversed Rs 87,25,174 paid to a business run by the promoter's wife because no invoices, purchase orders or delivery challans were produced. In the M.K. Printech case the NCLAT added that repaying a director's unsecured loan while the company was in difficulty and a secured lender was owed money "cannot be regarded as a routine business transaction".

What proves it is what an ordinary supplier would hold: invoices and delivery records, purchase orders, the contract or loan agreement and its schedule, both sides' ledgers, bank statements showing the same rhythm of payment before the trouble began, board approval for an insider, and matching GST returns. A supplier paid on usual terms for goods delivered stands best, an insider repaid early or ahead of the bank worst.

Key takeaway. The ordinary-course exception is the recipient's to prove, and it must fit the company's business as well as yours. A loan repaid to an insider while lenders went unpaid rarely fits.

Does it matter that I did not know the company was failing?

Not for deciding whether the payment was a preference. The Supreme Court held in the Jaypee Infratech case that section 43 creates a legal fiction, so a transaction answering its terms is preferential "irrespective whether the transaction was in fact intended or even anticipated to be so", and the NCLAT applied that in the Toshniwal Enterprises Controls insolvency (CA(AT)(Ins) 1437/2023, 21 January 2026): once transfers to related parties inside the window are shown, "the onus shifts" to explain the ordinary course. On that question what counts is the company's condition at the time, not your knowledge of it.

Knowledge returns at the remedy stage. The proviso to section 44 bars an order requiring a person who received a benefit "in good faith and for value" to pay a sum to the professional. Explanation I presumes the absence of good faith where that person is a related party or had sufficient information of the insolvency process. Our reading is that an unrelated creditor who knew nothing of the insolvency application when paid can raise the proviso, but whether repaying an old debt is "for value" is untested in the orders we have read.

The payment was only a book entry or a set-off: can that be a preference?

Yes. In the WSH Pvt Ltd promoters' appeal (CA(AT)(Ins) 2273/2024, 25 March 2026) about Rs 2 crore owed to the company by an associated firm was squared off against what the company owed a promoter's proprietorship. The NCLAT held that "a transfer under Section 43 is not confined to the physical movement of funds", that reducing a receivable by accounting entries is itself a transfer, and that bypassing the company's bank without corporate authority was not the ordinary course. The Supreme Court dismissed the promoters' appeal on 26 May 2026, finding no substantial question of law.

The Nirmangold promoter was caught the same way: debit balances of four other accounts and two vehicles were moved into his loan account, cutting what the company owed him from Rs 4,36,65,431 to Rs 2,38,46,796, and he and his wife were ordered to refund Rs 2,85,43,809 with interest.

Two limits run the other way. The company must itself have given the preference: the NCLT Ahmedabad dismissed a Rs 26.79 crore application where a bank had moved the funds on its own, with nothing showing the company authorised it or owed the recipient a prior debt (Bank of Baroda v Sintex Industries Ltd, 12 June 2026, now under appeal). And money you put in can be set against what you took out: in the Asten Properties and Developers insolvency (NCLT Kochi, 6 January 2026) Rs 7,31,75,140.50 the holding company infused in the same period was adjusted against Rs 15,24,10,709 of preferential transfers, because avoidance is meant "not to impose a punitive liability on the beneficiary". That is one bench's order, but it is the right request where the account ran both ways.

Common mistake. Treating a journal entry, a set-off or a car moved against a loan account as harmless book-keeping. The tribunals treat the entry itself as the transfer.

Was it a preference or an undervalued deal: section 43 or section 45?

Section 43 applies when you were paid for a debt. Section 45 applies when the company gave you something for nothing, or for "significantly less" than it gave, outside the ordinary course of its business, such as a gift or a flat sold to a relative below value. Section 46 sets the same windows, amended the same way, and lets the tribunal call an independent expert on value, and section 48 lets it vest the property back or order you to pay for the benefit or an expert's figure. A deliberate undervalue to keep assets from creditors falls under section 49, whose text has no look-back period.

The applicant may not be the professional: substituted section 47 lets a creditor, member or partner apply over a preferential, undervalued or extortionate transaction, or fraudulent or wrongful trading, that the professional has not reported. Whoever applies must plead the case: the Supreme Court has said the applicant "should cogently set out the basis" and the respondent "should be clearly put on notice" (Gloster Ltd v Gloster Cables Ltd, 2026 INSC 81).

Does the case survive if the resolution plan is approved?

Yes, and since 26 May 2026 the Code says so. Section 26, as substituted, provides that an avoidance application "shall not affect" the CIRP or the liquidation, and its Explanation clarifies that completing either process "shall not affect the continuation of proceedings in respect of an avoidance transaction". A liquidator may "continue or institute" such proceedings under section 35(1)(l), and section 54(1A) has the committee of creditors decide how pending proceedings and their proceeds are handled before dissolution. Regulation 38(2)(d) of the CIRP Regulations requires every resolution plan to say how avoidance proceedings will be pursued after approval and how their proceeds are distributed, and regulation 38(2A) bars a plan from assigning avoidance claims that were not disclosed to bidders.

If I return the money, can I claim it in the CIRP?

In principle yes, and you should ask for it in your reply. Section 44(1)(g) lets the tribunal provide, in the same order, how far a person who pays back may prove in the CIRP or liquidation for the debts the preference discharged. In the Asten Properties order the NCLT Kochi said avoidance "shall not result in the extinguishment or waiver of the underlying debts", that the original claims "shall revive" and be paid in the section 53 order, and that the professional must treat the respondents as creditors, though related parties have no vote in the committee. A revived loan is usually a financial debt and a supplier's invoice an operational one, explained in our guide to operational and financial debt, and the forms are in our guide on filing a claim in a customer's CIRP.

Timing is the risk. Once a plan is approved, section 31(6)(a), inserted in 2026, extinguishes claims against the company under any other law that arose before approval, "unless otherwise provided in the resolution plan". Our reading is that a claim revived by an order made after approval survives only if the plan's clause under regulation 38(2)(d), or the order itself, provides for it, so read that clause and ask the tribunal to deal with it.

What should I do in the first weeks after being served?

  1. Read what the application pleads: each payment, its date and amount, the clause of section 5(24) relied on and the window counted.
  2. Fix the filing date of the insolvency application and the admission date, and place every payment against them.
  3. Collect both sides' papers, including the payment history from before the window.
  4. List what you put back into the company in the same period, with proof.
  5. File your reply on time with those documents and ask, in the alternative, for netting and a section 44(1)(g) direction reviving your claim.
  6. Attend every hearing, and if you are set ex parte apply at once to set that order aside.
  7. If the order goes against you, weigh an appeal within the section 61(2) time limit, and file or revise your claim.
Deadline warning. In the M.K. Printech case the director was set ex parte, the application was allowed on the papers, and his recall application failed as a review the tribunal cannot hear. The NCLAT said he should have applied at once to set the ex parte order aside.

In our practice these applications are rarely lost on the law. They are lost on the reply: a short denial calling every payment business as usual without a single invoice, an argument about where the money came from, and no word about money put back in or the claim that should revive. The other loss is a missed date. In the orders discussed here the tribunals took from under seven months to almost five years to decide, and costs follow the volume of the ledger to be explained, so any figure is an indicative range, never a tariff.

Four outcomes from the 2026 orders and Act.

Fresh money netted

The Kochi bench set Rs 7.32 crore the holding company put in during the same period against Rs 15.24 crore of transfers, leaving Rs 7.92 crore to refund.

Interest from payment

The Nirmangold order added interest at SBI PLR plus two per cent from each transaction date, payable with the refund within thirty days.

Plan approval no shield

Since 26 May 2026 section 26 says completing the CIRP or the liquidation does not affect an avoidance proceeding already under way.

Your claim revives

The Kochi bench held that reversing a preference does not extinguish the underlying debt, which revives and is paid in the section 53 order.

Frequently Asked Questions

The company repaid me after the insolvency application was filed but before admission. Is that payment caught too?

Yes. Since 26 May 2026 both windows start before the application was filed and run to the insolvency commencement date, so a payment made while the petition was pending is inside the window whatever your relationship with the company. For a process admitted before that date, see the transitional point under the related-party heading.

I lent money to a friend's company and was repaid. Am I a related party?

Not because of the friendship. Section 5(24) lists relationships, and a friend falls outside them unless, for example, a director is accustomed to act on your advice or you control more than twenty per cent of the votes. Your window is then one year, not two.

The money came from my family's business and only passed through the company's account. Does that help?

Not if it reduced what the company owed you. In the M.K. Printech case the NCLAT held that once the amounts were routed through the company's accounts and used to reduce its liability to a related party, the transaction could not be taken outside section 43 by pointing to the source of the funds.

The resolution professional filed long after the 130th day of the CIRP. Is the application time-barred?

Probably not. In the M.K. Printech case the NCLAT treated the timelines in regulation 35A of the CIRP Regulations as directory, and noted that a liquidator is separately empowered to pursue avoidance after a liquidation order.

Can a creditor bring this application if the resolution professional does not?

Yes, since 26 May 2026. Substituted section 47 lets a creditor, a member or a partner apply over an unreported preferential, undervalued or extortionate transaction or fraudulent or wrongful trading, and the tribunal then directs disciplinary proceedings against a professional who sat on the information.

Will I have to pay interest on top of the amount?

You may. Section 44(1)(d) lets the tribunal require you to pay such sums as it directs, and the NCLT Mumbai in the Nirmangold matter added interest at SBI PLR plus two per cent from each transaction date until the money reached the company.

The company has gone into liquidation. Does the application lapse?

No. Section 26 now says completion of the CIRP or the liquidation does not affect avoidance proceedings, the liquidator can continue them, and the M.K. Printech application was itself decided after the liquidation order.

How long do I have to appeal an adverse order?

Thirty days to the NCLAT under section 61(2), which it may extend by up to fifteen days for sufficient cause, and section 61(6) now says it shall dispose of the appeal within three months of receiving it. A further appeal lies to the Supreme Court within forty-five days, on a question of law only.

This article is for general informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Consult a qualified advocate for advice on your specific situation.

References

  1. Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code, 2016, IBBI consolidated text up to 12 August 2021, read with the 2026 Amendment Act: section 5(11) and 5(24) on the initiation date and related parties, sections 43 and 44 on preferential transactions and the orders that reverse them, sections 45, 46, 48 and 49 on undervalued transactions and transactions defrauding creditors, and sections 61(2) and 62 on appeals.
  2. Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code (Amendment) Act, 2026 (6 of 2026), Gazette of India Extraordinary, 6 April 2026: section 3 adds the proviso to section 5(11), section 16 substitutes section 26, section 19 inserts section 31(6), section 23 substitutes section 35(1)(l), section 26 moves the start of the section 43(4) windows back to one or two years before the initiation date, ending on the insolvency commencement date, section 27 does the same for section 46, section 28 substitutes section 47, section 33 inserts section 54(1A) and section 43 inserts section 61(6), all in force from 26 May 2026 under S.O. 2625(E).
  3. IBBI (Insolvency Resolution Process for Corporate Persons) Regulations, 2016, consolidated to 9 June 2026: regulation 35A on the professional's opinion and application on avoidance transactions, and regulation 38(2)(d) and (2A) on how a resolution plan deals with avoidance proceedings and their proceeds. The Fifth Amendment of 30 October 2026 does not touch these regulations.
  4. Appeal of a suspended director of M.K. Printech Pvt Ltd against its resolution professional, later its liquidator, Company Appeal (AT) (Insolvency) Nos. 2025 of 2024 and 735 of 2025, NCLAT Principal Bench, judgment of 6 February 2026: repayments of about Rs 19.66 lakh to a director within two years of admission were preferential, the ordinary-course defence failed for want of documents, the source of funds routed through the company's account was irrelevant, and the regulation 35A timelines are directory.
  5. The interim resolution professional of Jaypee Infratech Ltd v Axis Bank Ltd, Civil Appeal Nos. 8512-8527 of 2019, Supreme Court, judgment of 26 February 2020: section 43 creates a legal fiction that applies whatever the intention, and the ordinary-course exception in section 43(3)(a) requires the transfer to be in the ordinary course of both the corporate debtor and the transferee.
  6. Nirmangold Alloys Pvt Ltd insolvency, IA (IBC) No. 2595 of 2022 in CP (IB) No. 4309 (MB) of 2018, NCLT Mumbai, order of 16 October 2026: the ordinary-course exception must be established by the recipient, book adjustments and vehicle transfers against a promoter's loan account were preferential, Rs 2,85,43,809 was ordered refunded with interest, and a payment outside the two-year window was not reversed.

Related Legal Services

Dealing with a matter like this? Our Bangalore advocates can help. Explore the relevant practice areas:

SJ

About the Author

Advocate Sharan Jain

Advocate based in Bangalore, practising before the Karnataka High Court and District, Sessions, Consumer and Family courts. Writes on civil, criminal, corporate, family and constitutional law to make Indian law more accessible.

Related Articles

S Jain & Attorneys · Legal Consultation

Have a Legal Question? We're Here to Help.

Our experienced lawyers in Bangalore offer confidential consultations tailored to your specific legal needs.

All matters handled with complete confidentiality and legal discretion.