Corporate & Commercial Law

I Invested in a Buy-and-Lease-Back Scheme Promising Fixed Monthly Rent and the Payouts Stopped: Can Investors Take the Company to the NCLT?

By Advocate Sharan Jain

I Invested in a Buy-and-Lease-Back Scheme Promising Fixed Monthly Rent and the Payouts Stopped: Can Investors Take the Company to the NCLT?

Yes, in at least one case. On 20 August 2026 the National Company Law Tribunal (NCLT) at Allahabad held that a cloud-storage buy-and-lease-back scheme, in which investors bought storage "particles" from one company and leased them to its affiliate for a fixed monthly rent over ten years, was a finance lease, so the unpaid rent was a financial debt under section 5(8)(d) of the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code, 2016 (IBC). On a joint application by a group of investors it admitted the lessee, Zebyte Rental Planet Private Limited, into the corporate insolvency resolution process (CIRP). The order was passed ex parte, because the company never appeared, so it is one bench's view on an unopposed record and not settled law. If you invested in that scheme, the urgent step now is a claim in the running CIRP, not a fresh case.

Part of the corporate and commercial law practice at S Jain & Attorneys, Bangalore.

This guide is for an investor whose fixed monthly "rent" from a buy-and-lease-back of storage units, servers or similar equipment has stopped. A company fixed deposit and a debenture are different products, covered in our guides on a matured company deposit and unpaid debentures.

How the Allahabad bench, in CP (IB) No. 112/ALD/2025, re-read the scheme's two agreements:

What the papers saidWhat the NCLT heldWhat it means for you
You buy particles from the seller and lease them to its affiliate under a second agreementParts of one sale-and-leaseback transaction (paragraphs 11 and 22)You are a financier of the lessee, not an owner collecting rent
A fixed monthly return for 120 monthsA finance lease under Ind AS 116, so a financial debt under section 5(8)(d) (paragraph 22)You can apply under section 7 and claim in the CIRP
The seller maintains and insures the particles, and you give up all accessSubstantially all risks and rewards left the investors (paragraphs 16 to 18)Your "ownership" gives you little to take back
A 120-month lock-in and a ten-year server life in the brochureThe lease covers the major part of the asset's economic life, paragraph 63(c) of Ind AS 116 (paragraphs 19 to 21)The same test can be run on another scheme's papers

The timeline in that case, from the order and the public announcement:

  1. September 2024: the last monthly payout.
  2. 31 October 2024: the first default.
  3. 18 August 2025: an unanswered demand notice.
  4. 14 October 2025: the joint application under section 7.
  5. 4 August 2026: the company set ex parte after notice and newspaper publication.
  6. 20 August 2026: admission, moratorium and an interim resolution professional.
  7. 22 August 2026: the public announcement, with claims due by 3 September 2026.
  8. 16 February 2027: the estimated close of the CIRP.

Three points from the order shape everything that follows:

Finance lease, financial debt

The Allahabad bench read the purchase and lease-back as one finance lease under Ind AS 116, so the unpaid rent became a financial debt under section 5(8)(d).

Decided ex parte

The company never appeared and was set ex parte on 4 August 2026, so nobody argued the other side before the tribunal admitted the application.

Investors as a class

The public announcement listed cloud particle owners as a class of financial creditors, who claim in Form CA and vote through an authorised representative.

Is the money I paid a purchase, rent or a loan in the eyes of the law?

For insolvency purposes it can be a loan in substance, whatever the agreements call it. Section 5(8) of the IBC defines a financial debt as one "disbursed against the consideration for the time value of money", and lists among its forms "the amount of any liability in respect of any lease or hire purchase contract which is deemed as a finance or capital lease under the Indian Accounting Standards" (clause (d)) and "any amount raised under any other transaction, including any forward sale or purchase agreement, having the commercial effect of a borrowing" (clause (f)). If it falls in either clause, you are a financial creditor under section 5(7), entitled to apply under section 7 and, under section 21(2), part of the committee of creditors. How this differs from a supplier's claim is in our guide on operational and financial debt.

Labels do not decide it. The Allahabad investors argued both clauses and the tribunal decided on clause (d) alone. If the asset is identifiable and yours to re-lease, the answer may differ, but where you agreed never to touch it and the seller kept every risk, the money looks like finance.

What exactly did the NCLT decide in August 2026, and how far can I rely on it?

It decided that one pair of agreements created a finance lease, and admitted the lessee into CIRP on a record nobody contested. On limitation it applied Article 137 of the Limitation Act, 1963, three years from the default of 31 October 2024 (paragraph 10). On debt it read the Asset Sale and Partner Programme Agreement with Vuenow Marketing Services Limited, which the order calls the corporate debtor's associate company, together with the Asset Monetising Program Agreement with Zebyte (paragraphs 2 and 11). It applied paragraph 62 of Ind AS 116, under which a lease is a finance lease "if it transfers substantially all the risks and rewards incidental to ownership of an underlying asset", and the economic-life indicator in paragraph 63(c).

Three findings carried it. Clause 8 of the sale agreement put "maintenance, upkeep and insurance" on the seller, an associate of the lessee (paragraph 16). Clause 9 of the lease agreement made investors agree that they "will not be able to access the particle(s)", so the rewards were "solely enjoyed by the Corporate Debtor" (paragraphs 17 and 18). And the 120-month lock-in matched the ten-year server life in the brochure (paragraphs 19 to 21). The applicants' computation sheet put their dues at Rs 1,63,99,544.77 as on 31 July 2025, against Rs 2,78,02,432.29 invested (paragraphs 3 and 23).

Treat it as persuasive, not settled. It is one NCLT bench's order, not a ruling of the National Company Law Appellate Tribunal (NCLAT) or the Supreme Court. On our reading, a contesting company might have argued that the risks sat with the seller, a different company from the lessee, and the alternative case under section 5(8)(f) was never tested. Nor does the order discuss the joint-filing proviso explained below. At the time of writing we found no appeal against the admission on the NCLAT's case records, and no NCLAT order on it in the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Board of India's (IBBI) database.

Key takeaway. The Allahabad order shows how a buy-and-lease-back can be brought within section 7, but it was decided ex parte by one bench. Another bench, or the NCLAT, may read similar papers differently when a company contests them.

How much must be in default, and whose default counts?

At least Rs 1 crore must be in default, and money owed to other financial creditors can count towards it. Section 4(1) of the IBC applies the corporate insolvency Part where "the minimum amount of the default is one lakh rupees" and lets the Central Government raise that figure to not more than one crore rupees, which it did by notification S.O. 1205(E) of 24 March 2020, specifying "one crore rupees as the minimum amount of default". The Explanation to section 7(1) adds that "a default includes a default in respect of a financial debt owed not only to the applicant financial creditor but to any other financial creditor of the corporate debtor". In the Allahabad case the applicants' combined dues of about Rs 1.64 crore cleared the line. What may and may not be added to reach the figure is covered in our guide to the Rs 1 crore threshold.

Can I file at the NCLT on my own, or must investors file together?

If the investors in your scheme form a class, you must file together, as at least one hundred of them or ten percent of the class, whichever is fewer. Section 7(1) lets a financial creditor apply "either by itself or jointly with other financial creditors". Its first proviso, added by the IBC (Amendment) Act, 2020, says that for financial creditors "referred to in clauses (a) and (b) of sub-section (6A) of section 21" the application "shall be filed jointly by not less than one hundred of such creditors in the same class or not less than ten per cent. of the total number of such creditors in the same class, whichever is less". Clause (b) of section 21(6A) covers a financial debt "owed to a class of creditors exceeding the number as may be specified", and regulation 2(1)(aa) of the CIRP Regulations defines a class as one "with at least ten financial creditors". The IBC (Amendment) Act, 2026, in force from 26 May 2026, left section 7(1) and its provisos alone: it omitted the proviso to section 7(4) and replaced section 7(5).

With five hundred investors, fifty must sign. With two thousand, one hundred must. On the text, a single investor can file alone only if no such class exists, which is unlikely in a scheme sold to many people. The Allahabad application was filed by one investor "and 25 Others", without any mention of the proviso, yet the later public announcement listed a "Financial Creditor in Class (Cloud Particle Owner under Sale and Lease Back Model)". Whether the applicants met the proviso turned on the size of that class, which the order does not record.

Substituted section 7(5) now says the tribunal "shall", within fourteen days, admit the application once a default, a complete application and a proposed resolution professional without pending disciplinary proceedings are shown, and Explanation I adds that "no other ground shall be considered to reject an application". Under section 60(1) the application goes to the bench for the company's registered office, which may be in another State.

The company is already in insolvency: how and by when do I file my claim?

Electronically, to the interim resolution professional, in the class form, and as soon as you can. The public announcement of 22 August 2026 called for claims by 3 September 2026, said that financial creditors "shall submit their claims with proof by electronic means only", and asked creditors in the cloud particle class to choose an authorised representative from three named insolvency professionals "in Form CA". That follows regulation 8A of the CIRP Regulations and the forms the IBBI notified on 2 June 2026. Form CA asks for the total claim, the documents, how and when the debt arose, your bank account and your choice of representative, and you declare what the company owed you "at the insolvency commencement date".

A late claim is still possible, within limits. Under regulation 12(1) a creditor who missed the announced date may still file "up to the date of issue of request for resolution plans under regulation 36B or ninety days from the insolvency commencement date, whichever is later", explaining any delay past the ninetieth day. Beyond that, regulation 13(1B) lets the professional verify a claim received no later than seven days before the meeting at which the committee votes on a resolution plan, but under regulation 13(1C) it then needs the committee's recommendation and the tribunal's condonation of delay. Under regulation 13(1A) you must be told, with reasons, within seven days of the decision on your claim, and the list of creditors is filed on the IBBI's platform under regulation 13(2)(ca). The class form is explained in our guide on Form F and Form CA, written for homebuyers but resting on the same class rules.

Deadline warning. In the Zebyte process the announced date was 3 September 2026, and, counting from the commencement order of 20 August 2026 and leaving out that day, the ninety days end on 18 November 2026. If you have not filed, file now with reasons for the delay, and do not wait for the company or the seller to offer a settlement first.

What does the moratorium mean for me as an investor?

It freezes your remedies against the lessee company, but not against anyone else. From 20 August 2026 the order (paragraph 28(v)) and section 14(1) prohibit "the institution of suits or continuation of pending suits or proceedings against the corporate debtor", including execution of any decree, any disposal of the company's assets by the company, enforcement of security over its property, and "the recovery of any property by an owner or lessor where such property is occupied by or in the possession of the corporate debtor". A consumer complaint, civil suit or arbitration against Zebyte stops where it is, and payouts are unlikely to resume outside the process. Under section 14(4) the moratorium lasts until the tribunal approves a resolution plan or orders liquidation.

The section speaks only of the corporate debtor, so on its words it does not protect the seller company, the directors or a guarantor. Section 14(3)(b) says the moratorium does not apply to "a surety in a contract of guarantee to a corporate debtor", and the 2026 Act adds an Explanation that the bar still applies where the surety itself proceeds against the company. If anyone personally guaranteed your payouts, that guarantee can be pursued now.

Can I take back the cloud units or servers I bought?

Not while the moratorium lasts, and probably not in practice afterwards. Section 14(1)(d) bars recovery of property by an owner or lessor while the company occupies or possesses it, and the Allahabad order repeats that bar. For premises, see our guide for landlords whose tenant company is in CIRP. These schemes add two problems: clause 9 of the Allahabad lease agreement made investors agree they "will not be able to access" the particles, and a one-terabyte unit of cloud storage is not an asset you can identify and carry away.

What happens to the rent promised for the remaining years?

It becomes part of your claim, valued as on the commencement date, and what you receive depends on the resolution plan. Section 3(6)(b) defines a claim to include a "right to remedy for breach of contract" that gives rise to a right to payment, whether "fixed, matured, unmatured, disputed, undisputed, secured or unsecured", and regulation 14 lets the professional make "the best estimate" of a claim that is not precise. Claims are verified "as on the insolvency commencement date" under regulation 13(1). Valuing the remaining years is the hard part: the Allahabad applicants claimed about Rs 1.64 crore against Rs 2.78 crore invested, and the order does not explain the computation. Work out what you paid, what you received and what the agreements entitled you to on the commencement date, and keep the workings.

After that, the money follows the plan. The authorised representative votes for the class, an approved plan binds every creditor under section 31(1), and since 26 May 2026 section 31(6) extinguishes every pre-approval claim against the company and its assets unless the plan provides otherwise. In a liquidation, section 53(1) pays "financial debts owed to unsecured creditors" at clause (d), after process costs, workmen's dues ranking with secured creditors who give up their security, and other employees' dues. A creditor who never filed is discussed in our guide on a claim never filed in a builder's CIRP.

Can we go after the seller company, a guarantor or the directors?

Yes, outside the moratorium, but only on a legal basis that reaches each of them. The seller is a separate company that Zebyte's moratorium does not cover, and at the time of writing we found no public announcement of an insolvency process for Vuenow Marketing Services Limited on the IBBI's list. Whether the seller owes you money depends on what the sale agreement obliged it to do. The order quotes clause 8 of the lease agreement, under which the lease "shall have no effect and is null and void without any liability of ZEBYTE" if the sale agreement ends, which shows how tightly the documents were tied.

Directors are not liable for a company's debts merely because they are directors. They can be reached through a personal guarantee, their own fraud, or the IBC itself. Section 66 lets the tribunal, on the resolution professional's application, make "any persons who were knowingly parties" to business "carried on with intent to defraud creditors" contribute to the company's assets. Section 47, as substituted in 2026, lets "a creditor, either by itself or jointly with other creditors" apply where such trading, or a preferential, undervalued or extortionate transaction, has occurred and the professional has not reported it. Explanation I to section 31(6) leaves unaffected any claim against a person who was "a promoter or in the management or control" of the company or a guarantor, though it creates none. The director's side is in our guide to a director's exposure in CIRP.

What if the scheme was a fraud, and should we also go to the police?

A police complaint can run alongside the insolvency, and the usual complaint is cheating under section 318 of the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023 (BNS), punishable with up to seven years where the deception induced you to hand over property (section 318(4), section 420 of the Indian Penal Code for earlier acts), and, where money entrusted for a purpose was diverted, criminal breach of trust under section 316 (section 406 IPC earlier). Both offences are cognizable, so the complaint goes to the police station under section 173(1) of the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023 (BNSS), a refusal to the Superintendent of Police under section 173(4), and then to the Magistrate under section 175(3), provisions that take the place of sections 154 and 156(3) of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973. How to make the police act is in our guide on registering an FIR.

The Banning of Unregulated Deposit Schemes Act, 2019 is a possible further route, not an automatic one. It bans "Unregulated Deposit Schemes" (section 3), punishes accepting deposits under them (section 21) and wrongful inducement (sections 5 and 23), and lets a State Competent Authority attach the deposit taker's property for a Designated Court to distribute among depositors (sections 7, 8, 14, 15 and 18). But it reaches only a "deposit" under section 2(4), which for a company takes its Companies Act, 2013 meaning, and a purchase price for an asset is not obviously one. Its priority for depositors in section 12 also gives way where the IBC provides otherwise.

The routes open to an investor, in short:

Claim in the CIRP

File electronically in the form the public announcement names, Form CA for the class, give reasons if late, and check that your name appears on the list of creditors.

Police complaint

Cheating under section 318 of the BNS is cognizable, so the complaint goes to the police station, and a refusal to the Superintendent of Police and then the Magistrate.

Seller and guarantors

The moratorium does not protect the seller company, a guarantor or the directors, but each needs its own legal basis, such as a guarantee, the contract or fraud.

Can I go to the consumer commission or file a civil suit instead?

The consumer route probably does not fit, and a civil suit works only against someone the moratorium does not protect. Section 2(7) of the Consumer Protection Act, 2019 excludes a person who buys goods "for resale or for any commercial purpose" or avails of a service "for any commercial purpose", with a carve-out only for goods "bought and used by him exclusively for the purpose of earning his livelihood, by means of self-employment". Buying an asset only to lease it out for a fixed return looks like a commercial purpose, and any complaint against Zebyte is caught by section 14(1)(a) anyway. If your facts differ, see our guide to consumer commissions and their jurisdiction.

A civil suit for the money lies against a party outside the moratorium, such as the seller or a guarantor, for what the contract or guarantee obliges it to pay. Where the claim is a debt or liquidated sum on a written contract or a guarantee, the summary procedure in Order XXXVII of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 may be quicker, as our guide on summary suits explains. Limitation runs under the Limitation Act, 1963, so do not let the dates slide while the insolvency works towards a plan.

Step by step from the last missed payout

  1. Collect the sale agreement, the lease or monetisation agreement, invoices, the brochure, bank records of every payment and payout, and all messages.
  2. Prepare a one-page schedule: amount paid, payouts received, the first missed payout and the balance claimed.
  3. Search the IBBI's list of public announcements for the lessee, the seller and any group company.
  4. If a process has begun, file electronically in the form the announcement names, choose an authorised representative if you are in a class, and give reasons if late.
  5. If not, count the investors, gather the proviso's minimum if they form a class, check that Rs 1 crore is in default, and file within the three years the Allahabad bench allowed from the default.
  6. Check for an existing FIR, give your documents to the investigating agency or file a complaint, and note the case number.
  7. Look for any guarantee or seller obligation enforceable outside the moratorium.
  8. After filing, check the list of creditors, follow the authorised representative's notices, and read any settlement offer for waivers before signing.

What will the process cost, and how long will it take?

Expect months to admission and most of a year in the process, even unopposed. The Allahabad application took about ten months, from 14 October 2025 to 20 August 2026, much of it spent serving a company that never appeared: notice in December 2025, newspaper publication ordered in March 2026, a last chance in June and the ex parte order in August. After admission, section 12 gives the CIRP 180 days, one extension of up to 90 days and an outer limit of 330 days including litigation, and the Zebyte announcement estimated closure on 16 February 2027.

Early costs fall on the applicants. The Allahabad bench directed the investors to deposit Rs 1,00,000 with the interim resolution professional for initial expenses, subject to adjustment by the committee (paragraph 28(xxv)), and regulation 6(3) makes the applicant bear the cost of the public announcement, reimbursable to the extent the committee ratifies it. In a running CIRP, regulation 11 makes each creditor bear the cost of proving its own debt. Professional fees vary with the number of applicants and whether the company contests.

In our experience the investors who lose most in these schemes are not those with weak papers but those who wait. They accept months of assurances about a "technical delay", miss the claim date, file the wrong form or hand originals to an agent, and then sign a settlement offer that waives the balance. A group that agrees early on one schedule of payments and payouts, one lawyer and one contact person tends to present a cleaner file than a hundred separate complaints.

Common mistake. Asking the company to hand your units back while also claiming as a financial creditor. The two positions pull against each other, and in a class the claim that counts is the one filed in Form CA.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is the money paid in a buy-and-lease-back scheme a financial debt under the IBC?

It can be. On 20 August 2026 the NCLT at Allahabad held a cloud-storage sale-and-leaseback to be a finance lease under Ind AS 116, and so a financial debt under section 5(8)(d). The order was passed ex parte, so treat it as one bench's view, not settled law.

Can one investor start insolvency against the lessee company?

Only if the investors do not form a class. Where ten or more financial creditors are in a class under section 21(6A)(b), the first proviso to section 7(1) requires at least one hundred of them or ten percent of the class, whichever is less, to file together, and at least Rs 1 crore must be in default.

I missed the 3 September 2026 claim date in the Zebyte insolvency. Is it too late?

Not necessarily. Regulation 12(1) keeps the door open until the request for resolution plans is issued or until ninety days from commencement, if that is later, with reasons for any delay beyond the ninetieth day, and regulation 13(1B) reaches claims that arrive at least seven days before the vote on a plan, subject to the tribunal condoning the delay.

Which form do cloud particle investors use to claim?

The public announcement of 22 August 2026 placed them in a class and asked for Form CA, filed electronically, with a choice of one of three named insolvency professionals as authorised representative.

Can I take my storage units back from the company?

Not during the moratorium, which under section 14(1)(d) bars recovery of property by an owner or lessor while the company possesses it. The lease agreement in the Allahabad case also barred investors from accessing the particles at all.

Does the moratorium stop a police case against the promoters?

Section 14 protects the corporate debtor and does not, on its words, protect directors, promoters or other companies, so it does not stop a police complaint against them.

Has the Allahabad admission order been appealed?

We found no appeal on the NCLAT's case records, and no NCLAT order in the IBBI's database, at the time of writing. That is the result of a search, not a certificate, so check again before relying on it.

Can I file a consumer complaint instead?

Probably not. Section 2(7) of the Consumer Protection Act, 2019 excludes purchases for a commercial purpose, buying an asset to lease it out for a return looks like one, and any complaint against a company in CIRP is caught by the moratorium.

This article is for general informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Consult a qualified advocate for advice on your specific situation.

Related Legal Services

Dealing with a matter like this? Our Bangalore advocates can help. Explore the relevant practice areas:

SJ

About the Author

Advocate Sharan Jain

Advocate based in Bangalore, practising before the Karnataka High Court and District, Sessions, Consumer and Family courts. Writes on civil, criminal, corporate, family and constitutional law to make Indian law more accessible.

Related Articles

S Jain & Attorneys · Legal Consultation

Have a Legal Question? We're Here to Help.

Our experienced lawyers in Bangalore offer confidential consultations tailored to your specific legal needs.

All matters handled with complete confidentiality and legal discretion.