The licence defect does not, by itself, defeat your claim, but whether the insurer pays you depends on what is proved and on the order the Tribunal makes. A driver who was not duly licensed is one of the few grounds on which the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988 lets an insurer defend a third party's claim (section 150(2)(a)(ii) for accidents from 1 April 2022, section 149(2)(a)(ii) before that), and the insurer has to prove it, including a breach by the owner. Even when it does, the Tribunal or a higher court can direct the insurer to pay the family first and recover the money from the owner and driver. The Supreme Court did exactly that on 30 July 2026, for a 2009 accident, on Reliance General Insurance Company Ltd's appeal (2026 INSC 767), holding that the insurer "cannot be held liable to make good the award" and yet applying "pay and recover". For accidents from 1 April 2022 the new section 150 has no recovery clause, and no Supreme Court ruling read for this guide settles the point. That direction is an order the Tribunal or court has to make on the facts of each case. It is not a right the family can assume.
Part of the civil litigation practice at S Jain & Attorneys, Bangalore.
This page is for the family of a man killed on a Bengaluru road, or a pillion rider injured, by a car or goods vehicle whose driver's licence had lapsed, was fake or was for another class, where the insurer's written statement before the Motor Accident Claims Tribunal says "breach of policy, no liability". Who can claim is in our guide to motor accident compensation claims, the arithmetic is in the MACT compensation calculator, and a mother's claim is in the guide on a dependent mother's share.
What the licence problem has meant for the family in the rulings read for this guide:
| The licence problem | Who pays the family first | Who bears it finally | Authority |
|---|---|---|---|
| Licence had expired and was renewed only after the accident, and the owner gave no evidence that he checked it | The insurer, under a pay and recover direction | The owner and the driver | Supreme Court, 30 July 2026, 2026 INSC 767, paras 12 to 18 |
| Fake licence | The insurer. If it proves the owner did not take adequate care to verify the licence, the Tribunal may still direct it to pay first and recover. | The insurer if the owner took reasonable care, otherwise the owner | Supreme Court, three judges, 5 January 2004, findings (iii), (iv) and (vii) |
| Learner's licence, used within its conditions | The insurer | The insurer | The same 2004 ruling, finding (viii) |
| Light motor vehicle licence, driving a transport vehicle of gross vehicle weight under 7,500 kg | The insurer. There is no licence breach on that ground. | The insurer | Supreme Court, five judges, 6 November 2024, 2024 INSC 840, para 131 |
| Driver never held a licence | In the 2004 batch the Court let such awards stand, paid subject to recovery, but said that order was not a precedent. | The owner and the driver, once the owner's breach is proved | The 2004 ruling, finding (iii) and its conclusion |
| Vehicle had no insurance at all | No insurer is there to pay first. The award runs against the owner and the driver. | The owner and the driver | Motor Vehicles Act section 146, and the Motor Vehicle Accident Fund Rules, 2022, rules 11 and 12 |
Key takeaway. The licence defence decides who carries the award in the end. On the 2004 ruling it does not, by itself, defeat the family's claim, but the family has to make the insurer prove it from the licensing authority's own records and has to ask, in terms, for a pay and recover direction.
Four points carry most of what follows.
Insurer must prove it
The 2004 three-judge ruling puts the burden on the insurer to prove both the licence defect and a breach of the policy condition by the owner of the vehicle.
Pay and recover
For accidents before 1 April 2022 the Tribunal or court may order the insurer to pay first and recover from the owner and driver. Later accidents remain unsettled.
Owner must show care
The 2026 judgment applies the rule that an owner must show he verified the licence and took reasonable care to see it was renewed in time.
Accident date decides section
For accidents from 1 April 2022 the licence defence sits in section 150(2), before that in section 149(2), and the policy date can also matter.
Does the insurer escape if the driver had no valid licence on the day?
Not as against your family, and not on that fact alone. The Supreme Court's three-judge ruling of 5 January 2004 on National Insurance Co. Ltd.'s petitions (SLP (C) 9027 of 2003, reported at (2004) 3 SCC 297) laid down, in finding (iii) of its summary, that "Mere absence, fake or invalid driving licence or disqualification of the driver for driving at the relevant time, are not in themselves defences available to the insurer against either the insured or the third parties."
The statute is built the same way. Section 150(1) of the Act, in the form substituted by the Motor Vehicles (Amendment) Act, 2019, makes the insurer pay a person holding an award against its insured "notwithstanding that the insurer may be entitled to avoid or cancel or may have avoided or cancelled the policy". Section 150(2) then gives an insurer with notice of the claim a closed list of defences. Clause (a)(ii) is breach of a policy condition "excluding driving by a named person or by any person who is not duly licenced or by any person who has been disqualified for holding or obtaining a driving licence during the period of disqualification". Sections 150(4) and 150(5) make any other policy restriction of no effect for these liabilities and bar avoidance in any other way.
So the licence ground is open to the insurer, but it has to prove it. Finding (iv) of the 2004 ruling says the insurer "must also establish 'breach' on the part of the owner of the vehicle", and puts that burden on the insurer. Finding (vi) adds that even a proved breach does not let the insurer avoid its liability to the insured unless it is "so fundamental as are found to have contributed to the cause of the accident". The 2026 judgment held the insurer not finally liable for a lapsed licence without discussing whether the lapse caused the accident, so expect each side to rely on a different ruling.
What is "pay and recover", and who actually pays our family?
Pay and recover is a direction that the insurer satisfies the award in the family's favour first and then recovers what it paid from the owner and driver. The 2004 ruling records that "the liability of the insurance company to satisfy the decree at the first instance and to recover the awarded amount from the owner or driver thereof has been holding the field for a long time", and its conclusion adds that "the Tribunal and the court must, however, exercise their jurisdiction to issue such a direction upon consideration of the facts and circumstances of each case".
The 2026 judgment shows how it works. A two-wheeler rider was hit on 14 October 2009. The Tribunal held only the driver and owner liable, the High Court made the insurer liable, and the Supreme Court restored the Tribunal's view on the licence. In paragraph 18 it held that "The appellant insurer cannot be held liable to make good the award. The final burden shall be on both the employer and the driver." In the same paragraph it held "pay and recover" applicable and left the insurer "at liberty to take steps in accordance with law" against the owner and driver.
In plain terms, the insurer stayed answerable to the family first, and the final burden was put on the owner and driver. Without such a direction, the award would sit against an owner and a driver who may have no means to pay, and the family would be left to execute it against them, which is the slower road described in our guide on execution of a money decree. That is why the family should ask for the direction specifically, in the claim and again in final arguments.
Expired, fake, learner's or wrong-class licence: does the kind of defect matter?
Yes, and the written statement should name the defect.
An expired licence. In the 2026 case the licence had been renewed only after a gap that covered the accident date, with a penalty charged for that period (paras 12 and 14). The Court quoted, at paragraph 9, a 2025 police recruitment ruling that "The theory that once a licence is renewed, even after a gap, the renewal would operate from a back date implying that the licence was continuing and valid even for and during the interregnum cannot be countenanced". It also quoted, at paragraph 17, an earlier three-judge ruling that contrasted a licence not renewed for three years on a truck with one lapsed "for a short period of time, say a month", where the 2004 ruling had given the benefit to the third party. For an accident from 15 August 2026, a new proviso to section 14(2), inserted by the Jan Vishwas (Amendment of Provisions) Act, 2026 and in force under S.O. 4100(E), keeps every driving licence "effective for a period of thirty days from the date of such expiry". On our reading such a lapse is no defect.
A fake licence. The 2004 ruling held that "Such defence can certainly be raised but it will be for the insurer to prove that the insured did not take adequate care and caution to verify the genuineness or otherwise of the licence held by the driver." An owner who checked a convincing forgery with reasonable care can leave the insurer liable.
A learner's licence. Finding (viii) of the 2004 ruling is direct: "If a vehicle at the time of accident was driven by a person having a learner's licence, the insurance companies would be liable to satisfy the decree." Its reasoning covers a learner driving "subject to the conditions mentioned in the licence".
A licence for another class of vehicle. On 6 November 2024 a Constitution Bench of five judges, deciding Bajaj Alliance General Insurance Co. Ltd.'s appeal (2024 INSC 840), held at paragraph 131(I) that a holder of a light motor vehicle licence may drive a transport vehicle of gross vehicle weight under 7,500 kg without a separate transport endorsement. The additional criteria still apply above 7,500 kg, that is to medium and heavy goods and passenger vehicles (para 131(III)), and to e-carts, e-rickshaws and vehicles carrying hazardous goods (para 131(I)). A heavy truck driven on a car licence gets no help from the 2024 ruling.
A disqualified driver. Driving while disqualified is named in the same clause of section 150(2)(a)(ii), so the same rules of proof apply.
Who must prove the licence was invalid, and with what records?
The insurer. Finding (iv) of the 2004 ruling puts the burden on it, and finding (v) says the way the burden is discharged "would depend upon the facts and circumstance of each case". The 2026 judgment adds how a licence question is proved. At paragraph 10 the Court described a driving licence as an official document whose validity is proved by the official records of the authority that issued it, and at paragraph 11 it explained that secondary evidence is allowed only when the reason the original record cannot be produced is first established.
Applied to the facts, the High Court had relied on a 2015 letter from the licensing office saying the 2007 to 2010 records were lost when data moved between two outsourced agencies. The Supreme Court rejected that, noting at paragraph 12 that "The officer of the Authority has not produced any document recording the loss of data and the steps taken by the Authority to recover the same", and at paragraph 15 that the High Court had not even considered the licence extract that contradicted the officer's oral evidence.
For the family, ask that the insurer prove its plea through the licensing authority named on the licence, with the extract showing the classes, validity dates and renewal history.
The owner says he checked the licence: does that change anything?
It changes who bears the award in the end. Whether the insurer pays the family first still turns on the Tribunal's direction. Section 5 of the Act, as the Supreme Court set it out at paragraph 8 of the 2026 judgment, says that "No owner or person in charge of a motor vehicle shall cause or permit any person who does not satisfy the provisions of section 3 or section 4 to drive the vehicle", and section 3(1) requires "an effective driving licence".
At paragraph 17 the 2026 judgment followed a High Court passage that an earlier three-judge ruling had approved: "The owner must show that he has verified the license. He must also take reasonable care to see that his employee gets his license renewed within time." The same passage says it is "no defence for the owner to plead that he forgot" the renewal. At paragraph 16 the Court noted that the owner had not entered the witness box, either to say the licence was valid or to say he had taken steps to get it renewed.
The 2004 ruling, in finding (vii), leaves the question whether the owner took reasonable care to be "determined in each case". If the owner proves he checked a licence that looked valid, the insurer may have to bear the award itself. If he does not give evidence at all, the 2026 judgment shows the result.
Will the defence delay our payment?
It can add hearings, mostly to bring the licensing authority's record and witness before the Tribunal, but the law has ways to keep the family's claim moving. The 2004 ruling says that "where such adjudication is likely to entail undue delay in decision of the claim of the victim, the tribunal in its discretion may relegate the insurer to seek its remedy of reimbursement from the insured in the civil court", and finding (xi) repeats the point. In the 2026 case the Supreme Court, when it issued notice, directed the computed amount to be released to the claimants, before it decided the insurer's appeal (para 18).
Since 1 April 2022, section 149 of the Act has required the insurer, once it learns of the accident, to designate an officer to settle the claim, and that officer may make an offer before the Claims Tribunal within thirty days. If the family accepts, the Tribunal records the settlement and the insurer pays within thirty days. If it rejects the offer, the claim is heard on merits. Read any offer with care, because section 166(1) now provides that "where a person accepts compensation under section 164 in accordance with the procedure provided under section 149, his claims petition before the Claims Tribunal shall lapse."
What if the vehicle had no insurance at all?
Then there is no insurer to pay first, and the award runs against the owner and the driver personally, although section 146(1) forbids using a motor vehicle in a public place without a policy. Since 1 April 2022, section 150(6) makes the owner tell the Tribunal whether the vehicle was insured on the accident date and with whom, where the family does not know.
For accidents from 1 April 2022, section 164 gives a fixed no-fault sum of "five lakh rupees in case of death or of two and a half lakh rupees in case of grievous hurt", payable by "the owner of the motor vehicle or the authorised insurer", without proof of negligence. On the words of the section, for an uninsured vehicle that means the owner. Since 1 April 2022, section 169(4) has given the Tribunal "all the powers of a Civil Court in the execution of a decree" to enforce its award.
Under rules 11(b) and 12(4) of the Central Motor Vehicles (Motor Vehicle Accident Fund) Rules, 2022, the Fund's Account for Uninsured Vehicles or Hit and Run Motor Accident pays hospitals for cashless treatment of victims of uninsured vehicles and may be used for "compensation to such other person as may be specified", and the owner must repay the treatment cost once the Tribunal makes an award against him. At the time of writing, the rules read for this guide specify no Fund compensation for a death caused by an identified but uninsured vehicle.
Drunk driving, no permit, extra passengers: how the other policy defences work
They sit in the same closed list in section 150(2), and on our reading the insurer carries the same burden of proving whichever ground it pleads. Clause (a)(i) covers use for hire without a permit or outside the permit, racing and speed testing, and a two-wheeler without a side-car. Clause (a)(ii) adds, after the licence condition, driving "under the influence of alcohol or drugs as laid down in section 185", which the old section 149(2) did not list. Clause (a)(iii) covers war, civil war, riot or civil commotion. Clause (b) lets the insurer say the policy is void for non-disclosure or misrepresentation of a material fact, and clause (c), also new, covers non-receipt of premium under section 64VB of the Insurance Act, 1938.
Passengers are a separate question from the licence. Since 1 April 2022, section 147(1)(b)(ii) requires cover for passengers of a transport vehicle "except gratuitous passengers of a goods vehicle". If the person killed was riding free in the goods vehicle itself, rather than walking or riding on the road, the insurer's answer may rest on that section, not on the licence. Our guide on drunk driving penalties covers the criminal side of section 185, and the guide on insurance claim repudiation covers an owner's claim on his own policy, which is a different question.
How does the insurer recover from the owner, and is that our concern?
Once the family is paid, recovery is between the insurer and the owner and driver. For an accident before 1 April 2022, the old section 149(4) proviso and section 149(5) let the insurer recover from its insured what it paid only because of the statute. The 2004 ruling relied on those clauses, and on long practice, for pay and recover. Its finding (x) lets the Tribunal direct that the insurer "is liable to be reimbursed by the insured", with the sum recoverable through the Collector under section 174 as arrears of land revenue if the insured does not deposit it within thirty days under section 168(3). Its conclusion lets the insurer realise the amount "in execution of the same award", and allows a separate action only in exceptional cases, such as evidence that comes to light later or collusion between the claimant and the owner.
For an accident from 1 April 2022, the substituted section 150 keeps the insurer's duty to pay the award and the same licence defence, but it has no counterpart to the old section 149(4) proviso or section 149(5). No Supreme Court ruling read for this guide decides how pay and recover works under it. On our reading the family should still ask for the direction in terms, but cannot treat it as settled.
It becomes the family's concern in two situations. The first is where the Tribunal finds the defence proved and makes no pay and recover direction, so the award runs only against the owner and driver. The second is any collusion between a claimant and an owner over the licence evidence, which can let the insurer sue separately later.
Which section of the Motor Vehicles Act applies to our accident date?
Two dates matter: the accident date and, on our reading, the date the policy was issued. By notification S.O. 859(E) dated 25 February 2022, the Central Government appointed "the 1st day of April, 2022" as the date on which sections 50 to 57 and section 93 of the 2019 Amendment Act came into force. Section 51 of that Act substituted the whole of Chapter XI, the third-party insurance chapter, including the new sections 149, 150, 161, 164 and 164B.
- Accident before 1 April 2022: the old section 149, with the licence condition in section 149(2)(a)(ii), which is the provision the 2004 ruling applied. The 2026 judgment, on a 2009 accident, decided the licence question without setting out the insurance section.
- Accident on or after 1 April 2022: section 150, with the licence condition in section 150(2)(a)(ii).
- Accident after 1 April 2022 under a policy issued before that date: the new section 147(4) says such a policy "shall be continued on the existing terms under the contract and the provisions of this Act shall apply as if this Act had not been amended by the said Act". Section 1(2) of the 2019 Act reads a reference to its commencement as a reference to the coming into force of the provision concerned. On our reading, a policy issued before 1 April 2022 and still running on the accident date may keep the old text. No ruling on this was read for this guide.
The licence condition, driving by a person "not duly licenced", appears in both texts. On our reading the 2004 and 2026 approach to proving the defence carries over to section 150, but neither ruling decided a claim under it, and the recovery clauses did not carry over.
Step by step: what to file and prove at the Tribunal
- Collect the police papers early, including any record of the driver's licence: its number, issuing authority, classes and validity dates.
- Make the owner, the driver and the insurer parties to the claim. If the insurer is not known, demand the details from the owner under section 150(6), in force since 1 April 2022.
- Read the insurer's written statement for the exact ground: expired, fake, learner's, wrong class or disqualified.
- Ask the Tribunal to put the insurer to strict proof through the licensing authority's own record, not a photocopy or a letter about lost data. You may also summon that record yourself.
- Where the owner says he checked the licence, ask that he give that evidence himself and be cross-examined on what he checked and when.
- Check the vehicle class and its gross vehicle weight against the licence classes. A light motor vehicle licence covers a transport vehicle under 7,500 kg (2024 INSC 840, para 131).
- In the claim and again in final arguments, ask in terms that if any policy defence is proved, the insurer be directed to pay the award and recover it from the owner and driver.
- If the insurer appeals, ask the appellate court to release the amount, or part of it, while the appeal is pending, as the Supreme Court directed at the notice stage in the 2026 case.
Where families lose ground on the licence question
What we see go wrong is seldom the law. The insurer's written statement is left unanswered, the licence question rests on a photocopy in the police file, the owner is served but never examined, and final arguments close without anyone asking for a pay and recover direction in so many words. When the award then goes against an owner with one vehicle and little else, the family holds a decree that is slow to execute. In our practice we ask for the licensing authority's record early, put the owner's verification to him in cross-examination, and press for the direction in writing, so that the licence dispute is fought between the insurer and the owner rather than at the family's expense.
Common mistake. Accepting the insurer's no-fault offer without advice. Since 1 April 2022, section 166(1) has provided that accepting compensation under section 164 through the section 149 procedure makes the claim petition before the Tribunal lapse. Check the full value of the claim before signing anything.
What does it cost and how long does it take?
As an indicative range, a contested claim before a Claims Tribunal commonly runs one to three years, and a licence dispute can add some months to that, mostly in summoning the record and examining the official. An appeal adds its own time, which is why release of the amount during the appeal matters. Professional fees depend on the stage, the number of hearings and whether an appeal follows, so ask for the fee in writing at the start.
Three practical points from the rulings to keep in view.
Ask for the direction
Pay and recover is not automatic. Ask the Tribunal in terms to direct the insurer to pay the award and recover it from the owner and driver.
Records, not photocopies
In the 2026 case a licensing office letter about lost data did not prove the licence. The licensing authority's official record decided the question on the accident date.
Owner in the box
An owner who says he checked the licence must say so in evidence. In the 2026 case the owner never entered the witness box at all.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can the insurer refuse to pay just because the driver's licence had expired?
It can plead the expired licence under section 150(2)(a)(ii), or section 149(2)(a)(ii) for older accidents, but it must prove it and a breach by the owner. Even then, for an accident before 1 April 2022, the Tribunal or court may direct it to pay the family first and recover from the owner and driver, as the Supreme Court did on 30 July 2026. For later accidents no Supreme Court ruling read settles this, so still ask for the direction. For an accident from 15 August 2026, a licence within thirty days of expiry is still effective under the new proviso to section 14(2).
The driver had a fake licence. Will the insurer pay?
The 2004 three-judge ruling allows the defence but puts it on the insurer to prove the owner did not take adequate care to verify the licence. If the owner checked with reasonable care, the insurer may bear the award itself.
Does pay and recover mean the money comes from the owner?
Not first. Under the direction, the insurer pays the family and then recovers from the owner and driver. It is a direction the Tribunal or court must make on the facts, so ask for it specifically. For accidents from 1 April 2022 the new text has no recovery clause, so the point is unsettled.
The goods vehicle driver had only a light motor vehicle licence. Is that a breach?
Not if the vehicle's gross vehicle weight was under 7,500 kg, on the five-judge ruling of 6 November 2024 (2024 INSC 840). Above that weight, and for hazardous goods vehicles, the 2024 ruling does not help and the insurer may plead the defence.
Do we have to prove the driver's licence was valid?
No. The insurer has to prove its defence, through the licensing authority's official records. It helps to collect the licence particulars from the police papers early and to ask for strict proof.
Can we get anything while the licence dispute is argued?
In the 2026 case the Supreme Court, when it issued notice, directed the computed amount to be released to the claimants. If the insurer makes a settlement offer under section 149, accepting compensation under section 164 that way makes the claim petition lapse, so take advice first.
Which section applies if the accident happened in 2021?
The old section 149, because the substituted chapter came into force only on 1 April 2022 under S.O. 859(E). For later accidents it is section 150, unless, on our reading, the policy was issued before that date.
What if the vehicle was not insured at all?
The award runs against the owner and driver personally, and the Tribunal can execute it with a civil court's powers under section 169(4). The Motor Vehicle Accident Fund pays for cashless treatment in such cases, not the family's compensation, on the rules read for this guide.
This article is for general informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Consult a qualified advocate for advice on your specific situation.






