Skip to section content

Dubai & DIFC / Insights

Civil Litigation

Two Family Factions Both Claim to Run the Company: Can Either Get the Case Files From the Company's Lawyers?

By Advocate Sharan Jain November 20, 2026

Two Family Factions Both Claim to Run the Company: Can Either Get the Case Files From the Company's Lawyers?

Not while the fight over control is undecided, on the DIFC Courts decision that faced exactly this situation. In Charles Russell Speechlys LLP v Grand Valley General Trading LLC and others, CFI 080/2022, judgment of 5 April 2023, a DIFC-registered law firm held the files of two arbitrations and a DIFC Court case for a company outside the DIFC. One family faction, holding an amended trade licence, demanded the complete case files and terminated the retainer. The other, whose general manager had granted the power of attorney under which the engagement letters were signed, instructed the firm to release nothing. The Court declared that, having regard to its regulatory obligations, the firm was required to decline to supply the files to the demanding faction unless and until the UAE civil and criminal claims over the true ownership and management of the company were finally resolved in that faction's favour.

The firm's further request for a declaration on its lien for unpaid fees was refused as unnecessary, and the three defendants who demanded the files, not the company, were ordered to pay costs of AED 160,800. The table sets out who may instruct the company's lawyers.

QuestionThe demanding factionThe other factionThe firm, and the Court
Who signed the retainer?Nobody from this faction. A family member signed under a 2018 power of attorney from the then general manager (reasons 5 and 12)Its nominee was that general manager (reason 8)The client was the company. The firm asked on whose authority the new instructions came (reason 14)
What control evidence?A trade licence amended on or about 24 June 2022 to show its company as sole shareholder and a new general manager (reason 9)Pending Dubai Court claims and a criminal complaint disputing that transfer (reason 10)Control not decided, it is for the courts outside the DIFC (reasons 2 and 11)
What instructions?Stay the second arbitration, hand over the full files and an itemised invoice, retainer terminated (reasons 13, 15 and 20)Release no copies, act on nothing from the other side (reason 21)Await any final and binding UAE judgment, supply nothing meanwhile (reasons 16 and 19)
What threats?A legal notice against the firm, a partner and a legal director: comply within five days or face action (reason 17)A legal notice: do not comply, or face action (reason 22)A Part 8 claim, declaration granted in part, costs against the demanding faction (reasons 3, 46 and 60)

Three cautions. It is one first-instance decision on a Part 8 claim brought by the firm itself, with no appeal or Conflicts of Jurisdiction Tribunal application found at the time of writing. It was decided under the Judicial Authority Law and the 2019 Mandatory Code, both since replaced. Only the law firm and the company are named here, not the family members, and the judgment records nothing about who won the control dispute.

Who may instruct the company's lawyers while control is disputed?

Not the demanding faction, on this judgment, which says nothing about the other faction's instructions, and the firm does not decide between them. The Court described the facts as straightforward: the firm was receiving conflicting instructions from two groups, each claiming to be entitled to instruct on behalf of the client (reason 40). The client was the company, and which faction spoke for it turned on whether the share and management transfer recorded on the amended licence was valid, a question pending in four Dubai Court of First Instance cases, a grievance and a criminal complaint (reasons 10 and 11). The engagement letters had been signed for the company by a family member holding a power of attorney dated 18 December 2018 from the general manager then named on the licence (reason 12).

When the first new instruction arrived on 22 August 2022 by an email from a different company's address, with the exhibited licence missing, the firm asked who had sent it, on whose authority and in what capacity (reason 14).

What did the firm do when the demands and threats arrived?

It held the line on both sides and then asked the Court to confirm it. On 14 October 2022 the firm said it was aware of the ownership dispute and would act in accordance with any final and binding judgment of the UAE Courts (reason 16). The demanding faction's response was a legal notice through the Dubai Courts against the firm, a partner and a legal director: every document on all three matters within five days, or action for loss and professional breach (reason 17). The firm answered that confidentiality prevented disclosure until the dispute was resolved (reason 19). On 31 October 2022 the new general manager terminated the retainer and demanded the entire case file and an itemised invoice within seven days (reason 20). On 8 November 2022 the former general manager required the firm to release no copies (reason 21), a legal notice on his behalf six days later threatened action if it did (reason 22), and the firm's Part 8 claim form bears the same date.

The three features the judge treated as decisive, as cards.

Conflicting instructions, one client

Two groups each claimed the right to instruct for the company. The firm's duty of confidentiality ran to the company, so releasing files to the wrong group would breach it (reasons 27, 40 and 41).

Threats from both sides

Each faction threatened proceedings against the firm, a partner and a legal director, one if the files went out and one if they did not. The judge called the difficulty real and imminent (reason 43).

Control pending elsewhere

Ownership and management were before the Dubai Courts and the criminal authorities. The DIFC Courts did not decide them and the firm could not, so both awaited the outcome (reasons 11 and 49).

Why did the Court declare that the firm must refuse the files?

Because the firm's duty of confidentiality to the company could not be performed by picking a side. The firm relied on the 2019 Mandatory Code's rule that a practitioner keeps a client's information confidential unless disclosure is authorised by the client, ordered by the Court or required by law (reason 25), and on the Best Practice Code's requirements to confirm an agent's authority and keep the client's papers confidential (reason 26). If the former general manager's faction turned out to control the company, the firm submitted, releasing documents to the other faction would breach that duty, and the judge agreed it might (reasons 27 and 41).

The demanding faction's answers, disputed facts and a court not there to advise a seasoned firm on its duties among them (reason 4), did not hold. Its counsel appeared to accept that the firm could not realistically hand over any documents until the courts outside the DIFC had decided control, while still pressing for the entire file (reason 39). Resigning would not solve what to do with the files (reason 41), even itemised invoices might carry privileged material (reason 42), and the claim was not premature because the threats were real and unwithdrawn (reasons 43 and 44).

The Court then applied the English practice on declaratory relief the firm had cited, Rule 36.52 of the Rules of the DIFC Courts being in the same terms as the English rule (reason 28). The question was real, it concerned lawyers regulated by this Court, both sides had been heard, and a declaration was the most effective way to resolve the impasse (reason 46).

Key takeaway. In CFI 080/2022 the demanding faction's own counsel accepted that the firm could not hand over the files until the courts outside the DIFC had decided control, yet the faction kept the demand and the threats alive. The Court read that inconsistency against it on the declaration and on costs (reasons 39, 46 and 55).

Does an English-law engagement letter take the dispute out of the DIFC Courts?

Not the regulatory question, on this judgment, though it did take the contractual one. The engagement letters were governed by English law with exclusive English jurisdiction (reason 6, clause 19.1), and the demanding faction said the DIFC Courts therefore had no jurisdiction (reason 4). The firm relied on the gateways in Article 5(A)(1) of the Judicial Authority Law then in force: it was a Centre Establishment, the retainer was made and performed in the DIFC, and the issues were DIFC regulatory obligations (reason 24). The judge drew the line at the retainer: he declined to express any view on the engagement letters, would not override the jurisdiction clause, and said that what was really under consideration was the firm's regulatory responsibilities, underpinned by its retainer (reason 47). Any action against the firm under the Dubai advocates' regulations would in any event have to be in the DIFC, the judge observed (reason 18).

The jurisdiction statute has since changed. Dubai Law No. 12 of 2004 was superseded by Article 43(A) of Dubai Law No. 2 of 2025. Article 14(A) gives the DIFC Courts exclusive jurisdiction over claims by or against DIFC Establishments, defined in Article 2 to include any entity licensed, registered or permitted to carry on an activity in or through the DIFC, and over claims related to contracts performed wholly or partly within the DIFC. Article 14(C)(1) lets them decline a claim where the parties agreed in writing to another court, and Article 23 applies the DIFC laws except where the parties expressly agreed another law. No published decision applying the 2025 Law to a law firm's own Part 8 claim was found at the time of writing.

Can the firm hold the files for unpaid fees?

The Court would not say so, and said it did not matter. The engagement letters, as English-law contracts, provided for the return of original documents on completion following payment of all bills and for retention of all files while money was owing on any matter (reason 6, clauses 17.1 and 18.2). The firm asked for a declaration that it could exercise that lien (reasons 3 and 30).

The judge refused it as unnecessary. Even if all fees were paid and any lien discharged, the firm still could not release the files to the demanding faction until ownership and control were finally determined (reason 49). Nor was it clear that the fees could even be assessed before then without touching confidential information, redaction being unrealistic (reason 50). Recovery of the fees was for the English courts unless the parties opted into the DIFC Courts (reasons 30 and 51). The lien was never tested as a matter of English law, and nothing in the judgment says what a DIFC-law retainer would carry.

What does the current Mandatory Code say, and what has changed since 2023?

The 2019 Code has been repealed and its confidentiality rule re-enacted in the same words. DIFC Courts' Order No. 2 of 2025, issued by the Chief Justice on 30 July 2025 under Article 10(B)(9) of Dubai Law No. 2 of 2025, repeals and replaces Order No. 4 of 2019. Part C(10) provides that practitioners shall keep information communicated to them by their client confidential unless such disclosure is authorised by the client, ordered by the Courts or required by law, a duty that continues after the practitioner has ceased to act. The judgment quoted it as Part C-19, "the Court" now reading "the Courts".

Two further provisions bear on a control fight. Part E(6): practitioners shall not agree to act in any matter before the Courts other than at the direct request of the client party concerned or their clearly authorised agent. Part A(6): a breach may be reviewed by the DIFC Courts' Professional and Disciplinary Ethics Committee, established on 30 July 2025, with the Part F suspension and removal powers exercised through a Part 8 claim by the Registrar. Registration is governed by DIFC Courts Order No. 1 of 2025, Part I for law firms and Part II for individuals. No published decision applying the 2025 Code to these facts was found at the time of writing.

The limits of the decision, as cards.

One judge, Part 8

A first-instance declaration on a claim brought by the firm under the alternative procedure for claims. No appeal and no Conflicts of Jurisdiction Tribunal application were found at the time of writing.

Control never decided

The DIFC Courts did not decide which faction owns or manages the company, and the published record does not show the Dubai Courts' outcome. The declaration holds unless those claims end in that faction's favour.

Lien and fees left open

The lien declaration was refused as unnecessary, the fee dispute was left to the English courts or an opt-in, and the Code and jurisdiction texts applied have been replaced since 2023.

Who bears the costs of the declaration, and how much?

The three defendants who demanded the files, not the company. The firm had succeeded in substantial part against their opposition, so costs followed the event (reason 52). Costs against the company were refused, since the other faction would bear them if it proved its ownership (reason 54). The assessment disallowed an unexplained AED 52,834 and cut work on documents from AED 112,388 to AED 49,429 (reason 56). The total without court fees, AED 173,457, was reduced by 20 percent to AED 138,766 for the failure to obtain the lien declaration, and with court fees of AED 22,035 the recoverable sum was AED 160,800 (reasons 53, 57 and 58).

Common mistake. Threatening the individual lawyers. In CFI 080/2022 both legal notices named a partner and a legal director personally. The judge said it was highly questionable whether such threats should ever have been made, that proceedings of that nature brought in the DIFC would likely face a strike-out application under Rule 4.16(2), and that the faction's counsel properly conceded things might have been done differently had he been instructed from the outset (reason 46). The unwithdrawn threats were the first ground for the declaration.

What should a faction member do before demanding the files?

  1. Read the retainer: who signed it, under what authority, which law governs it and which court it names.
  2. Separate the three questions the Court kept apart: who may instruct, who gets the files, who owes the fees.
  3. Expect the firm to verify authority: instruct from the company's own address, in the capacity shown on the licence, licence attached (reason 14).
  4. While the control dispute is pending, say in writing whether you accept that the firm must await its outcome. Silence with a live threat carried the declaration and the costs (reasons 44 and 55).
  5. Do not threaten individual lawyers (reason 46).
  6. If the fees are disputed, decide early where that question is to be litigated (reasons 50 and 51).
  7. Budget for a Part 8 claim by the firm if the threats stay live. Under RDC Part 8 the procedure is for questions unlikely to involve a substantial dispute of fact (Rule 8.1), and the acknowledgment of service, due within 14 days, must carry any objection to the procedure with reasons (Rules 8.13 and 8.17). Here a 14 November 2022 claim form reached judgment on 5 April 2023.

What strikes a practitioner reading the judgment is how little the firm had to decide. It asked who had sent an email, named the dispute, promised to follow the court seized of it, and asked its regulator's court to confirm that course when both sides threatened it. A faction that wants the files should spend its effort in the court that decides control.

Frequently Asked Questions

Our faction is now shown on the trade licence as owner and manager. Does that entitle us to the case files? Not on this judgment while the other faction's claims disputing the licence amendment are pending. In CFI 080/2022 the demanding faction held exactly that licence, amended on or about 24 June 2022, and the Court declared that the firm must decline to supply the files unless and until the UAE civil and criminal claims over ownership and management were finally resolved in that faction's favour (reasons 9, 10 and 48).

Can we terminate the firm and get the file that way? Termination did not change the answer in this case. The new general manager terminated the retainer on 31 October 2022 and demanded the entire case file within seven days, and the declaration still issued (reasons 20 and 48). The current Code's confidentiality rule, Part C(10) of Order No. 2 of 2025, continues after the practitioner has ceased to act for the client.

Can we at least get an itemised invoice? The judge doubted it. He said he was not even sure that providing itemised invoices to the demanding faction would avoid a breach of confidentiality, because the narratives could contain confidential and legally privileged information, and that redacting them was not realistic (reasons 42 and 50). No order for an invoice was made.

Can the firm keep the files because our company owes it fees? The Court declined to say. The lien declaration was refused as unnecessary because payment of every fee would not have changed the confidentiality answer (reason 49). The lien clauses sat in English-law engagement letters, which the judge declined to construe, and the fees themselves were left to the English courts unless the parties opted into the DIFC Courts (reasons 47 and 51).

The engagement letter chose English law and English courts. Why did the DIFC Courts decide anything? Because the question decided was the firm's regulatory duty as a DIFC-registered practitioner, not its contract. The judge declined to express a view on the engagement letters, did not override the jurisdiction clause, and decided only the regulatory responsibilities underpinned by the retainer (reason 47). Jurisdiction today rests on Article 14 of Dubai Law No. 2 of 2025, and Article 14(C)(1) lets the DIFC Courts decline a claim where the parties agreed in writing to another court.

What happens when the Dubai Courts decide the control dispute? The declaration turns on the outcome: the firm must decline to supply the files unless and until the claims are finally resolved in the demanding faction's favour (order 1). The firm had already said it would act in accordance with any final and binding judgment of the UAE Courts (reason 16). The published DIFC Courts record does not show how or when those claims were decided.

Did anyone appeal, and has the case been followed? No appeal was found in the DIFC Court of Appeal lists, and no application concerning the claim was found in the Conflicts of Jurisdiction Tribunal's published decisions, at the time of writing. The only other published items in the claim are two procedural orders of December 2022. It remains a single first-instance decision.

Does the 2025 Code change the result? Its confidentiality rule is unchanged in substance, but no published decision applying it to these facts was found at the time of writing. Order No. 2 of 2025 repeats the confidentiality rule in Part C(10), requires in Part E(6) that a practitioner act only at the direct request of the client party or a clearly authorised agent, and adds a Professional and Disciplinary Ethics Committee established on 30 July 2025 to review breaches. Whether a new case would be decided the same way is not settled.

This article is for general informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Consult a qualified advocate for advice on your specific situation.

References

Matters before the DIFC Courts are conducted by the firm, with counsel from its panel of DIFC-registered advocates engaged for the hearing. The firm acts as counsel in arbitrations seated in the DIFC and the wider UAE, and conducts the Indian proceedings that follow, including enforcement of UAE awards and judgments in India. This section is legal information, not legal advice.

All Dubai and DIFC guides