Ten percent of 966 is your target only if the project really had 966 allottees on the day you file. Section 7(1) of the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code, 2016 lets allottees start insolvency against a builder only by a joint application of not less than one hundred allottees of the same real estate project, or not less than ten percent of the total number of allottees of that project, whichever is less. In a judgment of 19 January 2021 in Writ Petition (Civil) No. 26 of 2020, the Supreme Court upheld that rule and settled how it is counted: the total is the number of units actually allotted or booked, not the flats promised in a brochure and not the units built, and the requirement must be met on the date the application is filed.
Part of the RERA and homebuyer disputes practice at S Jain & Attorneys, Bangalore.
Those were the exact figures before the National Company Law Tribunal at Kolkata. Fifty-nine buyers had filed through their association, the builder said the project had 966 allottees, and on 9 October 2026 the tribunal refused to rely on the builder's list, accepted the buyers' unrebutted figure of 540 units and admitted the company into insolvency in Evanie Eco Nest Home Buyers Association v Evanie Infrastructure Private Limited.
This page is for allottees in one delayed project who are organising a joint petition and have been told they are short of the number. The builder's side is in our guide on whether a homebuyers' NCLT plea can halt a project. If your project is already in insolvency, the threshold no longer matters and your next step is a claim in Form CA.
What goes into the total, and what does not:
| Item | Counted in the total? | Source |
|---|---|---|
| Flats in the sanctioned plan or the brochure that were never booked | No | SC 2021 |
| Units built but unsold | No | SC 2021 |
| Every allotment or booking made before you file, including buyers who have since taken possession | Yes | SC 2021, section 2(d) of RERA |
| A buyer who acquired an allotment from the first buyer | Yes, as an allottee | Section 2(d) of RERA, SC 2021 |
| One flat booked jointly by two or more people | One allottee | SC 2021 |
| Two flats booked by one person or one family | Each allotment counts | SC 2021 |
| A homebuyers' association or society filing in its own name | Not an allottee, so not counted as one | Elegna, SC 2026 |
| Application forms that name no specific flat | Not proof of an allotment | Evanie |
| Bookings or names added after you file | Ignored | SC 2021, Evanie |
| Buyers in the promoter's other projects | No | SC 2021 |
On the builder's figure, ten percent of 966 is 96.6, so 97 allottees would be needed. On 540 it is 54, and 59 clears it. If you can gather 100 allottees you never need the total at all, because the lower of the two numbers applies.
Four rules decide most of these disputes.
The lower number applies
Section 7(1) asks for one hundred allottees of the same project or ten percent of its allottees, whichever is less, so a group of one hundred never needs the total.
Bookings, not brochures
The 2021 judgment counts units actually allotted or booked, and rejects both the flats promised in a brochure and the number of units constructed as the measure of the total.
Counted on filing day
The requirement must be met on the date the application is filed, so buyers who settle or withdraw afterwards do not take a valid petition below the line.
Same project only
Allottees of the promoter's other real estate projects are left out of both the total and your count, because the proviso speaks only of the same real estate project.
What exactly does section 7 require from a group of buyers like us?
Three things, and only the first is about how many of you there are. The first is the joint filing rule in the second proviso to section 7(1), set out above. (The first proviso sets the same numbers for other creditors in a class, such as deposit holders.) The Explanation to section 5(8)(f) gives "allottee" and "real estate project" the meanings in clauses (d) and (zn) of section 2 of the Real Estate (Regulation and Development) Act, 2016, so the counting starts from RERA's definitions. Second, there must be a default of at least Rs 1 crore, the minimum the Central Government fixed under section 4 by notification S.O. 1205(E) of 24 March 2020. Third, that default must be within limitation, because section 238A applies the Limitation Act, 1963 to proceedings before the tribunal.
Who files matters as much as how many. Section 7(1) lets a financial creditor apply by itself, jointly with others or through a person the Central Government notifies, and S.O. 1091(E) of 27 February 2019 names a guardian, an executor or administrator, a trustee and a person authorised by a company's board, not an association. In Elegna Co-op Housing and Commercial Society v Edelweiss Asset Reconstruction Company (2026 INSC 58), on 15 January 2026, the Supreme Court said that the Explanation to section 5(8)(f) makes individual allottees financial creditors but not their society or association, unless it is a creditor in its own right, and that section 7 requires allottees to file jointly, in the prescribed number, not through an authorised representative or a housing society. It said so while refusing a society's bid to intervene, so file the way it described. An association counts as no one: the count is of allottees named as applicants, one per allotment.
The numbers rule came in with effect from 28 December 2019. The Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code (Amendment) Act, 2026 left section 7(1), its provisos and section 5(8)(f) as they were. What changed on 26 May 2026 is the admission step in section 7(5), taken up below.
The builder says the project has 966 allottees. Which allottees go into the total?
Only real allotments made before you file. In the 2021 case the petitioners argued that nobody could tell whether ten percent meant the units promised, constructed or allotted. The Supreme Court answered that what counts is allotment in the sense of a documented booking, the figure that section 11(1)(b) of RERA requires the promoter to post every quarter, and not the flats promised in a brochure or the total of constructed units. It added that an allotment and an agreement for sale may signify the same thing.
That is the test the Kolkata bench applied in Evanie. The builder produced a list of 966 bookings about four years after the petition was filed. The tribunal found that many entries were preliminary application forms, some naming only a tower and a floor and no flat, so that one unit could have been provisionally assigned to several people, and some carrying nothing but a name and a booking date. It held that such records were fluid and tentative and could not be treated as valid allotments, and that names added to the list after the petition was filed had to be disregarded. It then treated the number of units as a fact within the builder's own knowledge and, relying on sections 105 and 109 of the Bharatiya Sakshya Adhiniyam, 2023, held that the builder had failed to disprove the buyers' sworn figure of 540.
Three cautions run the other way. The tribunal accepted 540 because the builder did not disprove it, not because a figure of proposed units is the test, and a builder that produces signed allotment letters, agreements and payment records for a larger number can change the arithmetic. The petition was filed in the association's name, not in the way the Supreme Court said in January 2026 that section 7 requires, and the order does not discuss that ruling. And it is one bench's order, made on 9 October 2026, with no appeal reported at the time of writing.
Key takeaway. The total is the number of units actually booked when you file. A list the builder assembles later, a brochure figure or the sanctioned plan does not set your target, and in Evanie the tribunal held the builder, who keeps the booking records, to proving the number it relied on.
Do joint buyers, resale buyers and buyers of two flats count once or twice?
A flat booked jointly counts once, and two flats booked by one person count twice. The 2021 judgment held that joint allottees of a single apartment are treated as one allottee, because the proviso is looking for a critical mass of allotments and not of relatives. It refused to import the RERA Explanations, written only for sections 14 and 15, that treat several flats held in one family as a single allotment, so separate allotments count separately in both the total and your number. A buyer who acquired the allotment from the original allottee is an allottee under section 2(d) of RERA and counts as well.
In the Grand Venezia appeals (2026 INSC 104), the tribunal had counted 141 named petitioners as the allottees of 103 units because joint allottees of one unit count once, and the Supreme Court upheld the finding that the minimum of one hundred was met. In the Revanta case against Raheja Developers Ltd, decided by the National Company Law Tribunal at New Delhi on 8 June 2026, 176 buyers held 99 units, one short of a hundred, and the petition went through on the ten percent route because the project had 932 units.
Common mistake. Counting signatures. Joint buyers of one flat are one allottee, so a group of 110 people may hold fewer than 100 allotments, and then the ten percent test, and with it the builder's figure for the total, decides the case.
On what date is the count taken, and what if some of us settle before admission?
On the day you file, and later settlements do not undo it. The 2021 judgment took up whether the numbers must hold only at presentation or all the way to admission, and said there can be no doubt that the threshold must be fulfilled as on the date of filing. It adopted an early decision under the Companies Act, 1913, in which 13 of 65 consenting members withdrew after a petition was presented, holding that a petition valid when presented does not cease to be maintainable because of later events.
In the Festival City appeals by Mist Avenue Pvt Ltd and two connected companies, the National Company Law Appellate Tribunal held on 17 November 2023 that eight allottees settling their matters was inconsequential because the count is taken on the filing date. In the Grand Venezia case the Supreme Court refused to subtract allottees who had taken possession or been refunded by the time of admission. And in Evanie the tribunal said that subsequent cancellations, withdrawals, additions or post-filing changes cannot defeat the applicants' right to proceed.
The builder's genuine point is the mirror image. A booking cancelled and refunded, or a claim settled, before you filed is the builder's best ground for striking a name, and it needs documents. In the Grand Venezia case the Supreme Court noted that no document proved any settlement made before the petition was filed, and the objection failed for that reason as well.
Can more buyers join after we file to make up the number?
Do not plan on it. Because the threshold is tested on the filing date, a petition that was short when filed is not cured by buyers who come forward once it is pending. In Evanie the tribunal dismissed an application to add 49 more homebuyers who had approached the association after the petition was filed, and four interventions by other buyers. One window exists: in the Grand Venezia appeals the Supreme Court allowed names to be removed and added while a returned petition was being corrected, before registration, but after registration only with the tribunal's leave.
So put every allottee who will join on the petition before you file, and keep a margin. The builder will test individual names, and a petition that clears ten percent by one allottee falls below it if one joint booking was counted twice.
Some of us booked years ago. Do time-barred buyers still count?
They count as applicants, but the default you build the petition on must be within time. The 2021 judgment held that a joint application still lies where the debt is barred against some of the applicants, so long as others, or even one, establish a default of the required sum that is not barred, because under the Explanation to section 7(1) the default need not even be owed to an applicant. The Appellate Tribunal applied that in the Festival City appeals to reject the developer's attempt to strike 18 allegedly time-barred allottees, and others with premature claims, out of the count.
On the facts it added that the buyer agreement promised delay charges for every month of delay, so the breach continued under section 22 of the Limitation Act, 1963 and the right to sue had not run out. The builder's answer is real: the developer relied on an earlier Appellate Tribunal decision refusing that argument on a different agreement, and whether a delay in possession is a continuing breach turns on the wording of yours.
Deadline warning. The 2021 judgment restates that Article 137 of the Limitation Act, 1963 governs a section 7 application, which means three years from the default unless delay is condoned. Time-barred applicants still count, but the Rs 1 crore default you plead must fall inside that period, with dates you can prove.
What counts as the same real estate project: a tower, a phase or the whole township?
The project as RERA defines it, which is a question of fact in each case. Section 2(zn) of RERA defines a real estate project as the development of a building or apartments, or of land into plots or apartments, for sale, with its common areas and development works. The Explanation to section 3 makes every phase of a phased project a standalone real estate project for the purpose of registration. The 2021 judgment left out the promoter's other projects and said that what constitutes the project depends on the terms, conditions and scope of the particular project.
In practice the RERA registration is the best evidence of the boundary, and it can cut either way. A builder may argue that your project is bigger than you say, because a larger total raises ten percent, or that some of your applicants belong to another phase. In the Revanta case the tribunal took the total of 932 units from the builder's own registration form filed with the RERA authority. Before you file, match each applicant's agreement to the registration number of the phase or project it names.
The project was developed by more than one company. Can we file against all of them together?
Yes, if the companies are bound up in the same project, and you will have to prove the link. In the Festival City appeals the landowner company and two successive developers objected that they were separate legal entities. The Appellate Tribunal held one joint application against all three maintainable because they were intrinsically interwoven with a single project, under collaboration agreements, one developer allotting the units and taking the money and the other taking over the sold inventory. The Supreme Court declined to interfere at that stage, leaving itself free to revisit maintainability, and the three were admitted into insolvency together on 19 July 2024.
The Supreme Court reached the same result in the Grand Venezia case, upholding a joint petition by the allottees of 103 units against the developer and the company that marketed the units, relying on common directors, the developer's demand and possession letters to the marketer's buyers, receipts and the marketing agreement, and holding the two jointly answerable to the allottees. The builder's side of this is the separate existence of each company, and it is strongest where the documents show that only one company ever dealt with you. Collect the allotment letters, receipts and correspondence that name each company before you join it.
How do we find out how many allottees the project really has?
From the builder's own filings first. Section 11(1)(b) of RERA requires a registered promoter to post on its web page on the regulator's website a quarterly up-to-date list of the number and types of apartments or plots booked, and rule 15 of the Karnataka Real Estate (Regulation and Development) Rules, 2017 requires those updates within fifteen days from the end of each quarter. The 2021 judgment described that booking list as the reservoir of data the legislature intended allottees to use.
On the K-RERA portal, the Know About Your Project search opens each project's details, and our guide to checking a project's RERA registration walks through it. A project page we opened in October 2026 had a Quarterly Updates tab and fields for total, sold and unsold units and a list of allottees, but what a page holds depends on what the promoter uploaded, so download it with the date.
Then use the builder's own words. In Evanie the buyers pointed to the builder's earlier arguments on 540 units. Demand letters, earlier RERA and court pleadings and replies to legal notices often state the number. Where the portal is silent, a request under section 6 of the Right to Information Act, 2005 to K-RERA's public information officer, listed on its RTI page, must be decided within thirty days under section 7(1). Ask for counts, such as the number of units shown as booked in each quarterly update, not for other buyers' names.
Does the Rs 1 crore floor apply to us, and must each of us be owed that much?
It applies, but not buyer by buyer. The 2021 judgment held that the Rs 1 crore default need not be owed to any applicant, because the Explanation to section 7(1) says that a default includes a default in respect of a financial debt owed to any other financial creditor of the company. In the Festival City appeals the Appellate Tribunal read that to mean the applicants need not each be owed Rs 1 crore if a default of that size, within limitation, is made out on the petition. Our guide to the Rs 1 crore insolvency threshold covers the floor itself.
For allottees the default is usually the failure to hand over possession by the agreed date. In the Revanta case the tribunal found the default established from the admitted non-delivery of possession after the promised timelines, and in Evanie the association said its members had advanced about Rs 3.43 crore. The harder work is proving which debts fell due, and when.
What else will the builder argue, and does a pending RERA case stop us?
A pending RERA or consumer case does not stop you, and in the Revanta case neither did the builder's account of why it was late. There the builder blamed the authorities for missing roads, sewerage and power, said execution proceedings and a RERA order freezing its accounts had hurt its finances, and claimed to be solvent. The tribunal held that the duty to deliver on time came from the builder's own contract, rejected the force majeure plea, and held that proceedings before the Haryana regulator or the National Consumer Commission create no bar because the remedies are independent and concurrent, relying on the Supreme Court's Pioneer Urban judgment.
Admission itself changed on 26 May 2026. The substituted section 7(5), in force under S.O. 2625(E), now says the tribunal shall admit within fourteen days if a default has occurred, the application is complete and no disciplinary proceeding is pending against the proposed resolution professional, and its Explanation I says that where those requirements are met no other ground shall be considered to reject the application. The threshold sits in section 7(1), which decides who may file at all, and both orders made after that date, Revanta and Evanie, examined it first.
Expect pressure as well as argument. In the Festival City litigation the developer sought a section 65 penalty and a criminal inquiry over six affidavits, and on 29 January 2024 the Appellate Tribunal upheld the refusal of both, holding that allottees who filed to protect their rights had not acted fraudulently or maliciously. Since 26 May 2026 section 64A also allows a penalty of Rs 1 lakh to Rs 2 crore on anyone who initiates a frivolous or vexatious proceeding, one more reason to file only on a documented count.
Four answers to the builder's usual objections, drawn from the orders above.
Settlements after filing
Allottees who settle, take refunds or take possession after the petition is filed do not reduce the count, because the threshold is measured on the date of filing.
Stale claims still count
Applicants whose own claims are time-barred stay in the count, so long as the Rs 1 crore default the petition relies on is within limitation.
Linked companies, one petition
A joint petition against companies that developed or sold one project together is maintainable, as the Supreme Court held in the Grand Venezia case in 2026.
RERA case no bar
A pending RERA or consumer case does not bar a section 7 petition, because the Revanta order treats the remedies under the Code and RERA as concurrent.
Will the insolvency swallow the builder's other projects?
Usually not, and the builder will press for that limit. In September 2025 the Supreme Court directed that resolution of real estate insolvency should, as a rule, proceed on a project-specific basis rather than against the entire company, unless circumstances justify otherwise (2025 INSC 1110). Applying that direction, the Appellate Tribunal on 27 March 2026 confined the insolvency of Vatika Ltd to the single project its debentures had financed, leaving creditors of its other projects free to bring their own petitions. In the Revanta case the tribunal admitted the petition for that one project and directed a separate project account. What follows admission, from claims to possession, is covered in our guides on homebuyer rights once the builder is in insolvency and on possession during the process.
Step by step: counting and filing before the builder's figure is tested
- Pull the RERA registration of your project or phase, and download its project page and quarterly updates with the date.
- List the group by unit, not by person, one line per allotment with joint holders together, and keep for each unit the agreement, the receipts, the bank debits and the agreed possession date.
- Work out the total from units actually booked, and keep every statement in which the builder has given a figure.
- If you have 100 allottees, the total no longer matters. If not, file only with a clear margin above ten percent.
- Pick the default you will plead and check it is within three years, with the dates.
- Decide which companies to name, with the documents linking each one to the project.
- Name every allottee as an applicant, not the association, and take a signed authority and a properly sworn affidavit from each before filing.
- File before the bench with jurisdiction over the builder's registered office under section 60(1), with the record of default and the proposed interim resolution professional that section 7(3) requires, and his written consent.
- After admission, file each claim in Form CA, and if a claim is admitted for less than was paid, use the route in our guide on challenging the admitted figure.
How long does this take, and what does it cost?
Longer than the statute suggests. Section 7(5) now asks for an order within fourteen days, with reasons recorded for any delay, but the four petitions read for this article took from just over two years to five years to reach admission.
On cost, the 2021 judgment noted that the fee for the application stayed the same however many allottees joined. The group also funds the interim resolution professional at the start: the Evanie order directed the buyers to pay an advance of Rs 3 lakh towards his fee, to be adjusted later. Professional fees turn on how hard the count is fought.
Where do groups like ours go wrong?
The count is usually lost before anyone reaches the tribunal. A list of names is treated as a list of allottees, and once co-buyers are paired it holds fewer allotments than the group believed. The total is taken from the sanctioned plan or the brochure, which overstates the target, or from a messaging group, which proves nothing. The petition is filed a few names over the line, with nothing in reserve when the builder challenges one booking. Every default pleaded is more than three years old. The petition goes in the association's name, or signatures are collected without proper authorities, so the builder's first application is about standing and affidavits rather than the debt. The document we ask for first is a one-line-per-unit table with the agreement, the payments and the possession date, because the threshold, the default and limitation all come out of it.
Frequently Asked Questions
Do we need 100 buyers, or is ten percent enough?
Whichever is less. Section 7(1) asks for one hundred allottees of the same project or ten percent of its allottees, whichever is less, so in a project with fewer than 1,000 allottees ten percent is the smaller number and the total decides your target.
The builder has sold more flats since we started organising. Does that raise our target?
Bookings made before you file count in the total, so file once you have your number rather than waiting. Bookings or names added after filing are ignored, because the threshold is measured on the filing date, as the Kolkata bench held in Evanie.
If some of us settle with the builder after we file, will the petition fail?
No. The Supreme Court's 2021 judgment fixed the filing date as the point at which the threshold is tested, and the Appellate Tribunal in the Festival City appeals and the Supreme Court in the Grand Venezia case refused to subtract allottees who settled, took refunds or took possession after the petition was filed.
Can our homebuyers' association file in its own name?
No. An association is not itself an allottee, so it adds no one to the count. In January 2026 the Supreme Court said that section 7 requires allottees to file jointly, in the prescribed number, not through an authorised representative or a housing society. The Evanie petition went in an association's name and was admitted, but that order does not discuss the ruling. Name each allottee as an applicant, take a written authority from each for whoever signs and conducts the case, and use the association as the 2021 judgment described it, as the way allottees gather the names and the status of allotments.
Do buyers whose claims are time-barred still count?
Yes, as applicants. The 2021 judgment held that the application lies if a default of Rs 1 crore that is within limitation is made out, even if the debt is barred against some applicants, and the Festival City appeals refused to strike 18 allegedly time-barred allottees from the count.
Does a pending K-RERA complaint stop us filing at the NCLT?
No. In the Revanta case the tribunal held that proceedings before the RERA authority or the consumer commission create no bar, the remedies being concurrent. Once a petition is admitted, though, section 14 bars proceedings against the company, including a pending K-RERA complaint.
What if the builder will not tell us how many flats it has booked?
Section 11(1)(b) of RERA requires the promoter to post the number booked every quarter on its project page, and an RTI request to K-RERA can ask for those figures. In Evanie the tribunal treated the number of units as a fact within the builder's knowledge and held it to its burden of proving the total it relied on.
Can we include the landowner company in the petition?
Only if it is bound up in the project. In the Festival City appeals the landowner and two developers were joined because they were intrinsically interwoven with one project under collaboration agreements, and the Supreme Court upheld a similar joint petition in the Grand Venezia case.
This article is for general informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Consult a qualified advocate for advice on your specific situation.






