Consumer Protection

Gold Missing From Our Bank Locker After a Burglary: Is the Bank Liable, and Will We Get the Value of the Jewellery?

By Advocate Sharan Jain

Gold Missing From Our Bank Locker After a Burglary: Is the Bank Liable, and Will We Get the Value of the Jewellery?

Usually yes, if the burglars got in because the branch's security fell short. The Reserve Bank of India's locker rules make the bank responsible for securing its strong room, and on 25 March 2026 the National Commission held Nashik District Central Co-operative Bank deficient for a strong-room robbery and upheld Rs 3,00,000 compensation and Rs 50,000 costs for a locker holder. What a Consumer Commission is unlikely to give you is the value of the gold. In that order, and in orders of January and February 2026, the National Commission followed the Supreme Court and sent the question of what was in the locker, and what it was worth, to a civil court. The RBI's own figure for a bank's liability in a burglary is one hundred times the locker's annual rent.

Part of the consumer protection practice at S Jain & Attorneys, Bangalore.

This guide is for a family told that the branch strong room was broken into, or who found their locker empty while the branch says it never knew what was inside. The March 2026 order arose under the Consumer Protection Act, 1986 on a 2015 robbery, so every point below is set against the 2019 Act and the RBI's current Directions. For title deeds lost by a bank, read bank liability for lost title documents. For jewellery held by a husband's family, see recovering streedhan.

What the March 2026 order gave, and where the rest goes.

What was claimedWhat the National Commission didWhere the rest goes
Value of 458.710 grams of gold and valuables (the District Commission had awarded the value of 430 grams)Not awarded: set aside by the State Commission in 2022, and that upheldA civil suit, with the benefit of limitation for the time spent
Compensation for agony and harassmentRs 3,00,000 upheld (the District Commission had given Rs 25,000)Nothing further
CostsRs 50,000 upheld (raised from Rs 10,000)Nothing further
The RBI figure of one hundred times the annual rentNot applied to the 2015 robberyNow in the RBI's 2025 Directions, set out below
Key takeaway. A Consumer Commission can find the bank deficient and award compensation and costs where the branch's security failed. The value of the jewellery is a separate question of proof, and the National Commission's 2026 orders send it to a civil court.

Four points from the 2026 orders and the RBI rules.

Deficient and liable

The National Commission upheld Rs 3,00,000 compensation and Rs 50,000 costs in March 2026 against a co-operative bank that had not secured its strong room.

Gold value goes elsewhere

National Commission orders of January, February and March 2026 sent the value of stolen locker contents to a civil court, following the Supreme Court's 2021 ruling.

One hundred times rent

The RBI fixes a bank's liability for locker contents lost in a burglary, theft or robbery at one hundred times the annual rent, a figure both sides in a 2026 case tied to negligence.

Prove contents, not ownership

The March 2026 order says the family must prove what was in the locker at the time of the burglary, not merely that it owned the jewellery.

Is the bank liable at all when burglars break into the strong room?

Yes, where the burglary got through because the bank's security fell short. The RBI's Responsible Business Conduct Directions, 2025 for commercial banks require the area housing the lockers to be secured "to prevent criminal break-ins" (paragraph 229) and kept "adequately guarded at all times" (paragraph 230). Paragraph 258 makes it the bank's responsibility to ensure that theft, burglary and robbery do not occur through its own shortcomings or negligence, and says it "cannot claim that it bears no liability" for loss of locker contents in such an incident. The Directions for urban co-operative banks say the same (paragraph 188).

The Supreme Court, in Civil Appeal 3966 of 2010 against United Bank of India (19 February 2021), held that banks owe "a separate duty of care" in running lockers, including "providing appropriate safeguards against theft and robbery", whatever the law of bailment says about the contents (paragraph 9). In March 2026 the National Commission upheld a finding of gross negligence where the branch lacked adequate guards and CCTV (paragraphs 13 and 14). In February 2026 it held Central Bank of India deficient where no guard was posted during non-working hours and the burglary came at night (paragraph 14).

To be fair to banks, paragraph 257 excludes loss from natural calamities and loss caused by the customer's sole fault, and no order read for this guide decided a burglary that defeated a properly built, guarded and monitored strong room.

Is my locker a "service", so that I can go to the Consumer Commission?

Yes. Section 2(42) of the Consumer Protection Act, 2019 names facilities "in connection with banking" as a service, and section 2(7)(ii) makes a person who hires a service for consideration a consumer. In March 2026 the National Commission held that locker holders paying annual rent "are the consumers" (paragraph 12).

Banks often say the locker agreement makes them a lessor, not a banker. The March 2026 order reproduces the National Commission's 2024 reasoning, in cases against Central Bank of India and Union Bank of India, that such a clause "cannot take away the impact of the law made by Parliament" (paragraph 11). Paragraph 222 of the 2025 Directions now bars unfair terms in locker agreements, and paragraph 224 applies the compensation paragraphs even where an older agreement is silent.

What did the National Commission decide in March 2026 about a locker burglary?

It dismissed all 57 revision petitions, 28 by locker holders and 29 by the bank, and left the State Commission's award standing. The lead locker holder had hired a locker at the bank's Ranwad branch in 1996 at Rs 790 a year and kept 458.710 grams of his joint family's gold and valuables in it. On 24 August 2015 the branch manager told him that robbers had entered the strong room and stolen from several lockers. The branch later denied knowing what his locker held.

The District Commission ordered the value of 430 grams of gold at the market price on the day of the theft (30 January 2017). The State Commission set the gold value aside and awarded Rs 3,00,000 for harassment and Rs 50,000 costs (5 December 2022). The National Commission held that locker holders paying rent are consumers (paragraph 12), that the bank was deficient (paragraph 14), that a Commission may award compensation for mental agony apart from the financial loss (paragraph 21), and that the value of the contents must be proved in a civil court. It called Rs 3,00,000 and Rs 50,000 "fully justified" because the families had litigated for more than ten years at three levels (paragraph 23), and closed with liberty to sue for the actual loss and to claim the benefit of limitation for the time spent before the Commissions (paragraph 26).

Why did the family get compensation but not the value of the gold?

Because the Supreme Court held in 2021 that the questions on which liability for the contents depends, whether the bank knew what was inside and whether the locker holder kept "any receipt or inventory" or could otherwise prove the items, "cannot be adjudicated upon in the course of proceedings before the consumer fora" and belong to the civil court (Supreme Court's judgment, paragraph 8.6). It left every question of fact and law, including whether the law of bailment applies, open for that court (paragraph 8.10).

The National Commission applied that in March 2026: the onus of proving the contents at the time of the incident and their value rests on the locker holder, and a Consumer Commission "will not be able to evaluate such evidence", though it may still award compensation for mental agony and costs. On 16 January 2026, on a complaint by 28 locker holders of a Punjab National Bank branch in Modinagar burgled in June 2017, it dismissed the complaint with liberty to sue and awarded Rs 1,00,000 costs to each complainant for the bank's "palpable negligence" (paragraph 30). On 10 February 2026 it modified a West Bengal State Commission order that had awarded Rs 59,49,300 for jewellery stolen in a 2016 burglary of a Central Bank of India branch, substituting Rs 5,00,000 compensation and Rs 1,00,000 costs (paragraphs 17 and 19). On 9 June 2026 the Calcutta High Court dismissed the locker holders' plea for more, their counsel accepting the value belonged in a civil court, and left the bank free to challenge the Rs 5,00,000.

There is one opening. The Supreme Court tied the civil-court route "especially" to the bank disputing the contents (paragraph 8.10) and noted earlier awards where locker holders produced "detailed and precise documentary proof" (paragraph 8.7). On our reading a family with undisputed, well-documented contents may argue for a valuation by the Commission, but none of the three 2026 orders on burglaries accepted that.

What is the RBI's "100 times the annual rent" rule, and is it a cap or the measure?

It is the RBI's figure for what a bank owes when locker contents are lost in a fire, theft, burglary, dacoity, robbery or building collapse, or through fraud by its employees, read by both sides in a February 2026 case as payable once the bank's negligence is shown. The RBI circular of 18 August 2021 put it at paragraph 7.2, in force from 1 January 2022 for new and existing lockers. It now sits in paragraph 258 of the commercial banks' Directions of 28 November 2025: "the bank's liability shall be for an amount equivalent to one hundred times the prevailing annual rent of the safe deposit locker." Paragraph 188 of the urban co-operative banks' Directions is to the same effect.

On our reading of its words, it is a measure, not a ceiling. It says what the liability "shall be", and it does not say "up to", "not exceeding" or "limited to". For a locker rented at Rs 2,500 a year, the figure is Rs 2,50,000. Paragraph 466 says the Directions are "in addition to, and not in derogation of" other laws, as section 100 of the 2019 Act says of that Act. A bank will answer that the Supreme Court left banks' responsibility for the contents to the RBI (paragraph 15.1) and that this figure is the RBI's answer. On our reading nothing in the figure bars a family that proves a larger loss in a civil court from recovering it, but no order read for this guide has decided that.

Commissions have used it unevenly. In May 2024 a single member of the National Commission applied it to a 2015 theft from a Central Bank of India locker rented at Rs 1,000, awarding Rs 1,00,000 with 9 percent interest in place of the value of the ornaments the District Forum had allowed (paragraphs 11 and 12). There the figure reduced the award. In February 2026 the National Commission did not apply it.

These two sets of Directions cover commercial banks, such as the State Bank of India and the nationalised and private banks, and urban co-operative banks. Small finance banks, payments banks, regional rural banks and district central co-operative banks fall outside both, so ask your bank which Directions it follows.

Has any Commission ever ordered a bank to pay for what was inside?

Yes, but since 2021 the one standing value award found was not a burglary. On 27 October 2026 the Delhi State Commission ordered Union Bank of India to pay Rs 47,00,000, the value of jewellery claimed by a joint locker holder, with interest, plus Rs 3,00,000 for agony and Rs 50,000 costs (Complaint Case 249 of 2019, paragraphs 17 and 18). The bank said the locker had been surrendered but produced no surrender receipt and no receipt for the items, and had kept debiting the rent, so the Commission held the belongings misappropriated. The order does not discuss how the value was proved, and the thirty days to appeal had not run out on the date of this guide.

Earlier, the National Commission had awarded the value of missing contents where locker holders produced detailed documents, as the Supreme Court recorded (paragraph 8.7), and a West Bengal State Commission did so in 2020 before the February 2026 order replaced it.

Each turned on its own facts. The Delhi bank could not account for a locker in its own hands. Yet in the 2021 Supreme Court case, where the bank had broken the locker open itself, the disputed contents still went to a civil court, and where outsiders break in, the 2026 National Commission orders send the value there.

What do we have to prove about what was inside, and with what papers?

You must prove what was in the locker at the time of the burglary, and its value. The March 2026 order says the locker holder must prove "the contents of locker at the time of incident and not necessarily the ownership", though ownership papers help (pages 58 to 59 of the order). It accepted that much family gold is inherited or self-acquired without bills, and that a locker often holds a spouse's and children's jewellery, which can be claimed if the contents are proved with "reliable and cogent evidence". Proof of ownership without proof that the pieces were in the locker on the day lets the bank deny liability.

What families put forward, and how it fared:

  • Jewellers' bills, affidavits of the locker holder and relatives, the police panchnama and locker register entries: no positive evidence of value, and the value sent to a civil court (March 2026, paragraphs 6 and 13).
  • A list given soon after the burglary and a valuer's report of Rs 59,32,200: "unilateral", and "it cannot be concluded that these articles have in fact been kept" in the locker (February 2026, paragraph 15).
  • An affidavit alone: sent to a civil suit in one earlier case and dismissed in another (Supreme Court, paragraphs 8.8 and 8.9).
  • Purchase documents with the sons' bank passbooks showing their income: accepted by the National Commission in 2015, before the 2021 ruling (quoted in its January 2026 order, paragraph 23).

On our reading, the papers that matter most place particular pieces in the locker on or near the day: your last visit, what you put in or took out then, photographs, and matching purchase or gift records. Never list a piece you cannot place in the locker.

Common mistake. Handing the police a hurried list from memory on the day of the burglary and filing a different, longer list months later. A bank can point to every gap between the two. Make one careful list from your records and use it everywhere.

Does the bank escape if it says it never knew the contents?

Not from liability for its own failure. The Supreme Court said banks "cannot leave the customers in the lurch merely by claiming ignorance of the contents of the lockers" (paragraph 9), and in March 2026 the National Commission accepted the bank's account of the two-key system yet held it liable to compensate. But the ignorance is real: the bank's officer may not remain while the locker is opened (paragraph 236), and the agreement must say the bank keeps no record of the contents (paragraph 260). That is why the burden of proving the contents falls on the family.

We had a joint locker: who can claim?

Every joint hirer can, supported by the family members whose jewellery was inside. Section 2(7)(ii) of the 2019 Act treats a beneficiary of a service availed with the hirer's approval as a consumer, and section 2(5)(vi) lets a legal heir complain where the consumer has died. The March 2026 order lets a locker holder who proves the contents claim for pieces owned by relatives. Where many locker holders are hit, section 35(1)(c) allows one complaint for all with the District Commission's permission. On our reading every living joint hirer should join as a complainant, and each family member should give an affidavit listing her pieces in the same words as the main list.

Should we file a police complaint, and does the criminal case decide anything?

Yes, put your own statement on record, but the criminal case does not decide what the bank owes. In each 2026 burglary order the bank went to the police itself. In Modinagar the complaint quoted the investigating officer's findings of a brick strong-room wall five inches thick, no guard, an alarm that did not work and mostly non-working CCTV, which the bank disputed.

A pending investigation did not defeat the claim in February 2026: the bank called the complaint premature for that reason, and the National Commission still held it deficient (paragraphs 4, 8 and 14). Ask the branch in writing to preserve the CCTV recording, which paragraph 230 requires it to keep until the police investigation is completed and the dispute settled.

The March 2026 order applied the 1986 Act to a 2015 robbery: what applies to a burglary now?

The substance carries over, but the forum test and the RBI rules have changed. The complaints were filed in 2016 under the 1986 Act, and the order applied its section 14 while noting that section 39 of the 2019 Act is similar. The bank argued that in 2015 there were no clear RBI guidelines on branch security.

Point1986 Act and the 2015 factsA burglary now
Locker holder as consumerSection 2(1)(d)(ii), with "service" in section 2(1)(o) naming bankingSections 2(7)(ii) and 2(42), which also name banking
DeficiencySection 2(1)(g)Section 2(11), which adds any act of negligence, omission or commission causing loss
What can be orderedSection 14(1)(d), compensation for loss or injury due to negligenceSection 39(1)(d) in the same words, and costs under section 39(1)(m)
ForumSection 11: value of the service plus compensation claimed, District Forum up to Rs 20 lakhSection 34 and rule 3 of the 2021 Rules: value paid as consideration, District Commission up to Rs 50 lakh
Time limitSection 24A: two years from the cause of actionSection 69: two years, later only for sufficient cause with reasons recorded
RBI rulesNo 100-times figure. The Supreme Court found the earlier circulars left procedures to each bank (paragraphs 10 and 10.1)Paragraph 258 (commercial banks) or 188 (urban co-operative banks) of the 2025 Directions

Which Commission, and within what time?

Usually the District Commission, within two years. Section 34(1) and rules 3 to 5 of the 2021 Jurisdiction Rules send complaints where "the value of the goods or services paid as consideration" does not exceed Rs 50 lakh to the District Commission, those of Rs 2 crore or less to the State Commission, and larger ones to the National Commission. The jewellery's value is not the test. On our reading the consideration for a locker is the rent, which keeps the complaint in the District Commission, though no order read for this guide has applied the test to a locker. You may file where the bank has its branch, where you live or work, or where the cause of action arose (section 34(2)). The fee is nil if the consideration is Rs 5 lakh or less (G.S.R. 606(E) of 2023), and filing may be electronic (section 35(1), proviso). For the portal and the forums, see consumer court types and jurisdiction.

Section 69 gives two years from the cause of action, with longer only for sufficient cause and recorded reasons. On our reading, count from the date of the burglary, not the day you learnt of it, as that is the earliest date a bank could argue.

Deadline warning. Do not wait for the police investigation to end. Section 69 counts two years from the cause of action. In February 2026 the National Commission held the bank deficient although the bank had argued that the pending investigation made the complaint premature.

The numbers that decide where and when to file.

Two years to file

Section 69 of the 2019 Act gives two years from the cause of action, with more only for sufficient cause and the Commission's recorded reasons.

Forum by consideration paid

The 2021 Rules fix the forum by the value paid as consideration, up to Rs 50 lakh in the District Commission, not by the value of the jewellery.

No filing fee

The 2023 fee table charges nothing where the consideration paid is up to Rs 5 lakh, which on our reading covers the rent for a locker.

Civil court for value

The 2026 orders gave liberty to sue in a civil court for the actual loss, and two of them allowed the benefit of limitation for the time already spent.

When must we go to a civil court instead, and do we lose the years spent in the Commission?

Go to a civil court for the value, directly or after the consumer case. The Supreme Court sent the contents question there because it needs the evidence of both sides, leaving open whether bailment under section 148 of the Indian Contract Act, 1872 applies (paragraphs 6, 8.6 and 8.10).

You need not lose the years before the Commissions, but get it in writing. The March 2026 order gives liberty to "claim benefit of limitation" for the time the cases were pending (paragraph 26), and the February 2026 order said the locker holders "may invoke the provisions of Section 14 of the Limitation Act, 1963" (paragraph 17). Section 14(1) of the Limitation Act excludes time spent prosecuting, with due diligence and in good faith, another civil proceeding on the same matter in a court unable to entertain it for defect of jurisdiction or a like cause. In the West Bengal case the Calcutta High Court directed the civil court to deduct the time spent before the consumer fora and the High Court (paragraphs 26 and 27). The January 2026 order said nothing about limitation. On our reading, do not rely on the exclusion unless your order grants it, and file promptly. The articles that could govern the suit, such as Article 55 for breach of contract and the residuary Article 113, each allow three years from different starting points, and no order read for this guide decided which applies.

Step by step: the first seven days after the branch calls

Paragraph numbers are from the commercial banks' Directions. The urban co-operative banks' Directions carry matching rules under other numbers.

  1. Get the branch's account in writing: the date of the burglary, the lockers affected, the FIR number and the police station.
  2. Give the police your own written statement and list, and see that the panchnama records the state of your locker.
  3. Write to the branch asking it to preserve the strong-room CCTV recording (paragraph 230) and to give you your locker agreement (paragraph 223), your locker register entries and the record of who accessed your locker and when (paragraph 235).
  4. Collect proof of contents: the date of your last visit and the alert the bank sent for it (paragraph 237), purchase and gift records, hallmark details, photographs and bank entries for purchases.
  5. Ask each family member whose jewellery was inside to list her pieces in the same descriptions you will use everywhere.
  6. Claim from the bank in writing under its locker compensation policy (paragraph 256), keep its reply, and take advice before signing anything described as full and final.
  7. Diary two years from the date of the burglary, and decide whether to file a consumer complaint, a civil suit for the value, or both in sequence.

What will it cost, and how long will it take?

The fee is usually nil and the real cost is time. Section 38(6) has the complaint heard on affidavits and documents, and section 38(7) sets an aim of a decision within three months of notice where no testing is needed. The Nashik robbery of 2015 reached the National Commission's order in March 2026, the West Bengal burglary of 2016 in February 2026 and the Modinagar burglary of 2017 in January 2026, each with the value still to be fought in a civil court. Professional fees turn on the number of complainants and on whether a valuer, witnesses and a civil suit are needed, so any figure is indicative only.

What we see go wrong

These claims are rarely lost on the bank's negligence in our practice, and often lost on proof of what was inside. The list given to the police in the first hours is written from memory and later does not match the complaint. No one asks the branch to keep the CCTV recording until it has been overwritten. The last locker visit is not pinned down, so nothing places a particular necklace in the locker that month. Gifted and inherited pieces are described as family gold without a photograph or a date. The first task on these files is one careful list, one set of photographs and one dated chronology, used unchanged in every forum.

Frequently Asked Questions

Will the bank's insurance pay us for the jewellery?

Not directly, on the RBI's rules. A bank must keep a branch insurance policy to minimise loss from incidents such as robbery and fire affecting locker contents (paragraph 259 of the commercial banks' Directions), but it is under no duty to insure your contents and must not offer you any product to insure them (paragraph 260). Jewellery insurance you bought yourself is a separate claim on your own policy.

The bank has offered us one hundred times our annual rent. Should we accept it?

It is the RBI's figure for the bank's liability in a burglary, so it is a starting point rather than a favour. Whether accepting it ends your right to claim more has not been decided in any order read for this guide, so read the receipt before you sign and take advice before signing anything described as full and final.

Is the gold valued at the price on the day of the theft or at today's price?

No order read for this guide settled it. The District Commission in the Nashik case awarded the value of 430 grams at the market price on the day of the theft, but that award was set aside and the question now goes to a civil court.

My mother held the locker and has died. Can we still complain?

Yes. Section 2(5)(vi) of the 2019 Act makes a deceased consumer's legal heir or legal representative a complainant, and section 2(7)(ii) covers a beneficiary of the service. The two-year limit under section 69 still runs from the cause of action.

The bank says the burglary was beyond its control. Is that a defence?

It is an argument the Commission tests on the evidence. The Directions exclude liability for natural calamities and for the customer's sole fault (paragraph 257), and paragraph 258 makes the bank responsible for preventing burglary and robbery through its own shortcomings or negligence. In February 2026 the bank's evidence of CCTV, alarms and an armed guard did not help it where no guard was posted during non-working hours.

Can all the locker holders of the branch file one complaint?

Yes, with the Commission's permission under section 35(1)(c), where numerous consumers have the same interest. Twenty-eight locker holders of 15 lockers filed one complaint against Punjab National Bank in 2018, and the March 2026 order decided 57 revision petitions arising from one robbery together.

We never signed a fresh locker agreement. Does the RBI rule still protect us?

Yes. Paragraph 224 of the commercial banks' Directions says the compensation and liability paragraphs apply even where an existing agreement differs from the model agreement and does not mention them, and banks were advised to have fresh or supplementary agreements executed by 31 December 2023 (paragraph 225).

Should we go to the Consumer Commission at all if it will not award the gold's value?

Often yes, for a different purpose. It can find the bank deficient and award compensation and costs, as the three 2026 orders did in different forms, and those orders gave liberty to sue for the value afterwards. Whether to go there first or straight to a civil court turns on your proof, your papers and the time left.

This article is for general informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Consult a qualified advocate for advice on your specific situation.

Related Legal Services

Dealing with a matter like this? Our Bangalore advocates can help. Explore the relevant practice areas:

SJ

About the Author

Advocate Sharan Jain

Advocate based in Bangalore, practising before the Karnataka High Court and District, Sessions, Consumer and Family courts. Writes on civil, criminal, corporate, family and constitutional law to make Indian law more accessible.

Related Articles

S Jain & Attorneys · Legal Consultation

Have a Legal Question? We're Here to Help.

Our experienced lawyers in Bangalore offer confidential consultations tailored to your specific legal needs.

All matters handled with complete confidentiality and legal discretion.