It can be medical negligence. Where doctors have decided that a time-critical treatment is needed and then hold it back for a reason the law does not accept, a Consumer Commission can hold the wait negligent. On 25 August 2026 the District Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission-I, Hyderabad ordered a private hospital and its neurologist to pay Rs 1 crore for not performing a clot-removal procedure their own team had advised for a 30-year-old with a massive stroke, while they waited first for consent from his absent family and then for a Covid test report. On 20 July 2026 the Telangana State Commission held Apollo Hospital Enterprises liable for a stroke patient's lost "golden hour" and ordered about Rs 43.4 lakh. Neither order says a hospital may never wait, and both turned on what the case sheet recorded at the time.
Part of the medical negligence practice at S Jain & Attorneys, Bangalore.
This guide is for the son, daughter or wife of a man taken to a private hospital in Bengaluru with stroke symptoms, whose clot treatment waited for a signature or a test result, and who died or was left paralysed. The general law of consent is in our guide on informed consent in medical treatment, where the section "The emergency exception, and how narrow it is" sets out its limits. How an expert proves causation is in our guide on a cancer diagnosis that came too late.
What the two orders say a hospital may wait for, and when the wait became negligence:
| What the hospital waited for or relied on | What a hospital may lawfully do | When the 2026 orders found negligence |
|---|---|---|
| Family consent | Explain the risks and take consent from the patient, or from family reachable in time | Patient unable to decide, family absent and unreachable, thrombectomy already advised, and the doctors waited (Hyderabad, paragraphs 24 to 28) |
| A test report | Send the test and follow infection protocols with protective equipment | The procedure held back for a Covid RT-PCR result, then discharge in an unstable state (Hyderabad, paragraphs 27 and 31) |
| The treatment window | Decline clot-dissolving medicine for a clinical reason recorded at the time, such as an unknown time of onset | The advised procedure's window was still open (Hyderabad, paragraph 29), or hours passed with no treatment (Telangana, paragraph 10) |
| His other illnesses | Decline a treatment that is unsafe for him, if the case sheet says so at the time | A reason first offered after the complaint, held "an afterthought" (Telangana, paragraph 11) |
| A specialist or a transfer | Refer or transfer a patient it cannot treat, safely | No emergency record of the first branch was filed (Telangana, paragraph 9), or a ventilated patient was handed to an ambulance technician (Hyderabad, paragraph 27) |
Key takeaway. Both 2026 orders were decided on the hospital's own paper. The Hyderabad discharge summary recorded that the advised procedure was explained to "attendants who were only friends and could not take decision", and the Apollo case sheet gave none of the medical reasons later offered for withholding treatment. The record written at the time decides a stroke delay case.
Four points from the two orders carry most of what follows.
Absent family, urgent procedure
The Hyderabad Commission said doctors may proceed without consent where the patient cannot decide, the family is absent or unreachable, and waiting risks irreversible brain damage.
Tests run alongside treatment
Official advisories, as the Hyderabad order records them, told hospitals to give emergency care without demanding a Covid test result, using protective equipment instead of postponing treatment.
Record the reason then
Both Commissions disregarded reasons for withholding treatment that surfaced only after the complaint, because the case sheets written at the time did not mention them.
Forum by amount paid
The Hyderabad parents claimed over Rs 5.6 crore before the District Commission, which hears complaints where up to Rs 50 lakh was paid, and it awarded Rs 1 crore.
Is a delay in treating a stroke medical negligence, or a medical judgement?
It is negligence when the doctors decided that a time-critical treatment was needed and then withheld it without a reason the law accepts, and a medical judgement when the treatment was not indicated and the record says why. Under the Consumer Protection Act, 2019, a "deficiency" in a paid service includes, by Section 2(11), "any act of negligence or omission or commission by such person which causes loss or injury to the consumer". The Hyderabad Commission put the doctor's duty as one "to exercise reasonable skill, care, and knowledge" (paragraph 30).
Its order turned on a narrow point. The family did not say the hospital chose the wrong treatment. They said the thrombectomy its own doctors had advised was delayed on the pretext that consent had not been obtained (paragraph 29). That kept the case from becoming a contest between experts. A complaint that a different treatment should have been chosen faces the harder error-of-judgment test explained in our guide on a late cancer diagnosis.
Why do minutes matter in a stroke, as the orders put it?
Because, as both orders record, the treatments that dissolve or remove a clot have to be given within hours. The Hyderabad hospital itself filed the Union Health Ministry's 2022 stroke management guidelines, which, as the order quotes clause 5.4, make a patient eligible for clot-dissolving treatment "within 4.5 hours after onset of symptoms" (paragraph 23). Its own case was that mechanical thrombectomy, an image-guided procedure to remove the clot, had to be done within 6 to 24 hours of onset (paragraphs 8 and 24). Its written arguments said a patient loses on average 1.9 million neurons for every minute a large-vessel stroke goes untreated, a figure the Commission adopted (paragraphs 24 and 29). The Telangana Commission wrote that in an acute ischaemic stroke "the crucial period is first 60 minutes and maximum time 4.5 hours" (paragraph 10).
These are medical statements as two Commissions recorded them, not rules of law. Which window applied to your father turns on when he was last seen well, what his scans showed and his other illnesses, and only a neurologist reading the file can say.
Can a hospital wait for family consent when the patient cannot consent?
Not for an urgent procedure when the family is absent or unreachable and the wait risks irreversible harm, the Hyderabad Commission held. The doctors advised thrombectomy in the emergency department on the day of admission. The hospital's records show the need was explained to friends who could not decide and wanted time to speak to his family (paragraphs 22, 24 and 29). The hospital argued that an immediate family member's consent was mandatory because he might die on the operating table (paragraphs 6 and 8).
The Commission asked why the doctors waited "for consent of the patient's family who are physically absent and unreachable" (paragraph 24). Where a sudden illness such as a severe stroke leaves a patient unable to decide, immediate intervention is needed to save life or prevent severe, irreversible disability, and the family is absent or unreachable, or waiting for them risks irreversible brain damage, doctors may give standard emergency treatment without prior consent (paragraph 25). The doctors "ought to have documented in the medical record that the thrombectomy procedure is an immediate necessity and that delaying it to obtain consent would harm the patient", and should have proceeded on presumed emergency consent (paragraph 26). Their duty was to act "without letting procedural, administrative, or consent-related hurdles delay life-saving treatment" (paragraph 30).
The exception is narrow, and the same order calls informed consent "an imperative rule" (paragraph 26). If your father could understand and decide, or you could be reached in time, the hospital had to explain the risks and take consent first, and a short wait for that is not negligence by itself. The Supreme Court decision the Commission relied on is explained in our consent guide.
Can a hospital hold back treatment until a test report comes?
It may run the test, but the Hyderabad Commission held that it should not have held back the procedure for the result. The day after admission a sample went for RT-PCR, and the family said his friends were told the procedure would follow the result, which takes 24 hours (paragraph 3). A positive report arrived at 7.30 am on 19 August 2020 and he was discharged for a Covid-designated hospital (paragraph 4). The Commission recorded that Union Health Ministry and ICMR advisories told hospitals to give emergency care "without demanding a prior positive or negative test report", with protective equipment, instead of postponing treatment (paragraph 27). Even if it was not designated for Covid, the hospital "ought to have conducted Thrombectomy to the patient while awaiting RT-PCR report" and stabilised him before discharge (paragraph 31).
The Commission accepted that the pandemic rules on Covid and non-Covid hospitals were real (paragraph 31). The point is that the test runs alongside the treatment. On our reading the reasoning may reach other tests that can proceed in parallel, but the order concerned a Covid test during the pandemic. It did not blame the laboratory: a later test elsewhere was negative, but nothing showed that the positive report was false (paragraphs 4 and 33).
What may a hospital lawfully decline, and why does the case sheet decide it?
A treatment that is not indicated, provided the reason is in the record written at the time. The Hyderabad discharge summary said clot-dissolving treatment was not given because the time of onset was unknown and the MRI suggested a stroke more than six hours old (paragraph 18), and the Commission made no finding against that, the family's case being about the advised procedure. What failed was a later reason. The hospital's expert said the patient was not clinically suitable for thrombectomy, but that view was in neither the doctors' notes and case sheets nor the hospital's written version (paragraph 29). Even with the onset time unknown, the Commission reasoned, the 6 to 24 hour window was open because he arrived at about 4 pm (paragraph 29).
The Telangana Commission went further. Apollo said clot-dissolving treatment was withheld because of kidney failure and earlier strokes, but "Nothing is mentioned anywhere in the case sheet" to that effect, and the explanation was "an afterthought to wriggle out from the allegation made in the complaint" (paragraph 11). The case sheet recorded only, at 6 pm, "Patient not thrombolysed as patient beyond window period" (paragraph 10).
On our reading, if the record written at the time gives a clinical reason, the family needs an expert to meet it. If it shows a treatment advised and then delayed, or gives no reason at all, the hospital's own papers carry much of the case.
What did the Hyderabad Commission decide in August 2026?
It held the hospital and its consultant neurologist negligent and ordered them, jointly and severally, to pay Rs 1 crore and Rs 50,000 as legal expenses. The order, in C.C. No. 567/2022 against Citizens Speciality Hospital, Gachibowli and others, was pronounced on 25 August 2026. The patient, a 30-year-old research scholar, was brought in at about 4 pm on 17 August 2020 (paragraph 29), and his MRI showed complete blockage of the right middle cerebral artery (paragraph 18). On 19 August he was discharged on a ventilator and handed by the nursing staff to the ambulance technician, which the Commission read as meaning that no medical staff went with him (paragraph 27). He died at the second hospital on 21 August 2020.
The Commission found that the advised thrombectomy was not done "on the pretext of waiting for the consent of the patient's family" (paragraph 28), and that blaming consent for the delay, and the lack of Covid designation for the transfer, "is not only unjustified but considered as deficiency of service and negligence" (paragraph 31). Where prompt treatment within the window could have saved the patient, it said, the hospital is liable for "the loss of that chance of life or survival/recovery" (paragraph 32). Payment was due within 45 days of receiving the order, failing which the Rs 1 crore carries 9 per cent interest a year from that receipt (paragraph 36).
Read it for what it is: a District Commission order from Telangana, binding on no Commission in Karnataka. The family's own expert opinion was not pressed when the expert could not be produced for cross-examination (paragraph 16), and the Commission decided on the hospital's records, written arguments and literature (paragraphs 23, 24 and 29). The hospital could appeal within 45 days under Section 41 of the 2019 Act, and we found no report of an appeal at the time of writing.
What did the Telangana State Commission decide against Apollo in July 2026?
It held Apollo Hospital Enterprises Ltd liable for a stroke patient's lost golden hour and ordered it to pay about Rs 43.4 lakh in all, including costs. The complaint, C.C. No. 116 of 2015, was filed under the 1986 Act by the wife and children of a 53-year-old government employee, and the Commission's Additional Bench decided it on 20 July 2026. He had stroke symptoms at home at about 1.30 pm on 22 March 2013, went first to the group's Secunderabad branch, where the family said no neurologist came, and then to its Jubilee Hills hospital (paragraphs 2, 7 and 9). He died there in October 2013.
The Commission held that "no proper treatment was given to the patient during the Golden hour period" and that the golden hour "was wasted by the Opposite Parties due to their negligence", the first medication coming only at 7.13 pm (paragraph 10). The time at the Secunderabad branch counted, because it was under the same management, and the missing emergency record from that branch amounted to "suppression of a material aspect of the case" (paragraphs 9 and 10). It awarded Rs 40,11,876, worked out on his lost earnings, and Rs 1 lakh each for loss of estate, consortium and records kept "in the shabbiest manner", with Rs 25,000 costs, against the hospital company as vicariously liable for its doctors and staff (paragraphs 20 and 21).
The order is not one-sided. The Commission rejected the son's allegation of a second stroke, criticised his conduct, would not act on his video recordings, noted that no expert spoke to the day-to-day treatment, and said "both sides are not speaking truth" about the patient's earlier medicines (paragraphs 12, 15 and 16). It still held the first hours lost, on the hospital's own record.
Who is liable: the hospital, the neurologist, the laboratory or the next hospital?
On these orders, the hospital and the treating doctor who held the treatment back, and not those against whom nothing specific is proved. In Hyderabad the hospital and its neurologist were liable jointly and severally (paragraph 36). The complaint failed against the laboratory that reported the positive test, for want of evidence that the report was false (paragraph 33), and against the hospital that received him and its neurologist, as there was "neither any specific allegation nor evidence" against them (paragraph 34). In the Telangana case the award ran against the hospital company alone, liable "under the principle of vicarious liability of the other Opposite Parties" (paragraph 20).
On our reading, join the hospital and the doctor who made or deferred the decision, plead what each did and when, and join a laboratory or a second hospital only where the file shows a lapse of its own.
Which records decide a stroke delay case, and how do we get them in Karnataka?
The ones that fix the minutes, from arrival to the first dose. Ask for:
- the emergency triage and initial assessment forms, with times
- every scan report with its time (in Hyderabad an unclear MRI at 5.13 pm was repeated at 7.10 pm, paragraph 24)
- the plan of care and progress notes, where advice of a procedure is usually written
- every consent form and who signed it (there, a friend signed the admission consent, paragraph 7)
- test requisitions, sample times and report times
- the drug chart and pharmacy record, the latter putting the first medication at 7.13 pm in the Telangana case (paragraph 10)
- the discharge or death summary, any second version of it, and the transfer note
In Karnataka the Karnataka Private Medical Establishments Act, 2007 gives a statutory route. Section 12(3) entitles a person or his family member to a copy of the clinical record, and under Section 13(2), where the patient has died or is incapacitated, a family member may ask for it and the establishment must supply it within seven days of the charges being paid. Records are often the fight: the Hyderabad hospital declined a request for the case sheet made through the university's medical officer in October 2020 (exhibits A17 and A18). If the hospital stalls, the next steps are in our guide on your legal right to medical records.
Common mistake. Attacking the decision not to give the clot-dissolving injection when the case sheet records a reason for it, such as an unknown time of onset. The Hyderabad family won on the procedure the doctors themselves advised and then delayed, not on the choice of treatment (paragraph 29). Read the file before deciding what the complaint is about.
Does Karnataka law make a private hospital treat an emergency first?
For some emergencies it does in terms, but not, by its words, for most strokes. Section 11(i) of the 2007 Act requires every private medical establishment to give first aid and "other life saving or stabilising emergency measures in all medico-legal or potentially medico-legal cases such as victims of road accidents, accidental or induced burns or poisoning or criminal assaults and the like", and, by an amendment in force from 4 April 2019, to do so "without insisting on advance payment". A stroke at home is not that kind of case, so on our reading the section does not settle a stroke family's complaint.
The Patient's Charter in the Act's Schedule promises "a documented procedure for his informed consent". Under Section 11A(2) a patient or authorised family member may complain of a breach of the Charter to the district Registration and Grievance Redressal Authority, which the Deputy Commissioner chairs (Section 4). That Authority refers complaints of negligence to the Karnataka Medical Council for enquiry and a report within sixty days (Section 8(1), proviso), and for a first breach of the Charter it imposes a penalty of Rs 10,000, half of it paid to the patient (Section 15(3)). That is a regulatory remedy. Compensation comes from the Consumer Commission.
Which Commission, and within what time?
The forum depends on what was paid, not on the size of the claim, and the clock is two years. Sections 34(1), 47(1)(a)(i) and 58(1)(a)(i) of the 2019 Act measure each Commission's reach by "the value of the goods or services paid as consideration", and G.S.R. 912(E) of 30 December 2021 sets the bands: up to Rs 50 lakh for the District Commission, above that up to Rs 2 crore for the State Commission, and above Rs 2 crore for the National Commission. In the Hyderabad case the parents claimed over Rs 5.6 crore, the two hospitals' bills they sought back came to Rs 2,97,594, and the District Commission heard the case and awarded Rs 1 crore. The filing fee follows the same figure, and under G.S.R. 606(E) of 17 August 2023 there is none where up to Rs 5 lakh was paid.
After a death, Section 2(5)(vi) gives the complaint to "his legal heir or legal representative". The Hyderabad parents, who live in Uttar Pradesh, ran their case through their son's friends as holders of a power of attorney (paragraphs 1 and 15). Under Section 69 the two years run "from the date on which the cause of action has arisen", and a late complaint is admitted only if the Commission accepts the cause shown and records its reasons. Section 35(1) permits electronic filing, and complaints now go through e-Jagriti, which the Department of Consumer Affairs launched on 1 January 2025, bringing e-Daakhil and the older systems onto one platform with OTP registration and online or offline fees.
Deadline warning. In the Hyderabad case the parents filed three days short of two years from their son's death, and the laboratory still argued that time ran from its test report two days before the death (paragraph 11). Count the two years from the earliest date a hospital could argue, usually the day the treatment was held back, and file well inside it.
What compensation is awarded when the patient dies?
Compensation follows proof of negligence, and the two orders fixed it in different ways. Section 39(1)(d) of the 2019 Act lets a Commission award compensation "for any loss or injury suffered by the consumer due to the negligence of the opposite party". The Hyderabad Commission set out no multiplier: considering the young man's age, education and likely career, it awarded a lump sum of Rs 1 crore "towards compensation for loss of dependency, future prospects, filial consortium, and mental agony" (paragraph 35).
The Telangana Commission took a monthly salary of about Rs 45,585, deducted a third for personal expenses, and applied a multiplier of 11 for the age group 50 to 55 from a 2009 Supreme Court judgment, reaching Rs 40,11,876 (paragraph 19). Where your father survived with paralysis, the claim is for treatment, care, lost earnings and the disability itself, and the arithmetic is in our guide on medical negligence compensation. Past results do not guarantee a similar outcome.
Four practical points from the second half of this guide, in brief.
Ask for the case sheet
In Karnataka a family member of a patient who has died or is incapacitated may ask for the clinical records, which must be supplied within seven days of payment.
Name each party's lapse
The Hyderabad complaint failed against the laboratory and the hospital that received him, because nothing specific was proved against either of them.
Two years from the lapse
Section 69 counts two years from the date the cause of action arose. Count from the day the treatment was held back, the earliest date a hospital could argue.
Appeals need a deposit
A hospital appealing a District Commission order to the State Commission must first deposit half the amount ordered, under Section 41 of the 2019 Act.
Should we also go to the police or the medical council?
You can, but neither pays compensation, and both families in these orders used them alongside the consumer case. The Hyderabad parents complained to the police of criminal negligence on the day their son died and also filed a writ petition (paragraph 5). In the Telangana case a complaint to a magistrate led to an FIR in 2014 with, the family said, no charge sheet (paragraph 2), and the hospital relied on a medical council's finding of no negligence (paragraph 3), yet the State Commission found the golden hour lost. When the council and the police are worth approaching is covered in our guide on a late cancer diagnosis, and what a doctor faces in our guide on a police case against a doctor after a patient's death.
Step by step: the first sixty days
- Note, while memory is fresh, when he was last seen well, when he reached the emergency department, which doctor advised what and when, and who was asked to sign.
- Write to the hospital for the full case sheet under Sections 12(3) and 13(2) of the Karnataka Private Medical Establishments Act, and keep proof of delivery.
- Keep every bill, the discharge or death summary, the scan and test reports, and any messages the hospital sent.
- Against each entry in the case sheet, mark the time of the scan, the test sample, the report, each consent form and the first dose.
- Take a neurologist's written opinion on which treatment was open, within which window, and what giving it in time would probably have changed.
- Diary the two-year limit from the day the treatment was held back, with a margin.
- Total what both hospitals were paid to pick the Commission, and file on e-Jagriti with the papers in date order.
- Plead a specific lapse against each party, and keep your expert available for cross-examination.
What we see go wrong
Families come to us with a true sense that the hospital made them wait, but these cases are decided on minutes written in the hospital's own forms: arrival, scan, the decision to treat, the consent form, the test sample and report, the first dose. Where the timeline is not built from those forms, the complaint argues a feeling. We also see families attack the clot-dissolving drug that the record says was ruled out, instead of the delay in the procedure the doctors themselves advised. And expert evidence lapses, as it did in the Hyderabad case. Plan for years, not months: the Hyderabad complaint took four years and the Telangana complaint eleven.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can the hospital refuse to operate until a family member signs?
Not when the patient cannot decide, the family is absent or unreachable, and waiting risks irreversible harm, according to the Hyderabad Commission's order of August 2026. Where the patient can decide, or the family can be reached in time, consent should be taken first.
The hospital says the treatment window had passed. Does that end the claim?
Not necessarily. A clinical reason recorded at the time is a strong defence, but in Hyderabad the Commission found the window for the advised procedure still open, and in the Apollo case reasons missing from the case sheet were treated as an afterthought.
Was the hospital wrong to test for Covid before the procedure?
The test itself was not faulted. The Hyderabad Commission held that the hospital should have performed the procedure while the RT-PCR report was awaited, as official advisories instructed, rather than holding it back for the result.
My father survived but is paralysed. Can we still claim?
Yes, if the delay was negligent and probably caused or worsened the disability. The claim covers treatment, care and lost earnings, and it needs a neurologist's opinion on what timely treatment would have changed.
Do we need an expert opinion?
In practice, yes. The Hyderabad family won on the hospital's own records after their expert's opinion was not pressed, but no family should plan on that, and an expert must be available for cross-examination.
When does the two-year limit start after a stroke death?
Section 69 runs it from the date the cause of action arose, and a hospital may argue that was the day the treatment was held back rather than the day of death. Count from the earlier date.
Which Commission do we approach?
The one set by the amount paid for the treatment: the District Commission up to Rs 50 lakh, the State Commission above that up to Rs 2 crore, and the National Commission above Rs 2 crore.
Is the Hyderabad order binding in Karnataka?
No. It is a District Commission order from Telangana and may be challenged in appeal. It shows how one Commission reasoned on these facts, and every case is decided on its own record.
This article is for general informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Consult a qualified advocate for advice on your specific situation.
Related Guides
- Informed Consent in Medical Treatment: What Indian Law Requires From Every Doctor
- The Doctor Missed My Father's Cancer and It Was Found Too Late: Is a Missed or Delayed Diagnosis Medical Negligence, and What Can We Claim?
- Your Legal Right to Your Medical Records in India (and How to Get Them When a Hospital Stalls)






