Consumer Protection

I Signed Up for a Holiday Membership at a Sales Pitch and Want Out: Can the Company Refuse a Refund Under Its No-Refund Clause?

By Advocate Sharan Jain

I Signed Up for a Holiday Membership at a Sales Pitch and Want Out: Can the Company Refuse a Refund Under Its No-Refund Clause?

Not always. A "non-refundable" clause did not stop a holiday membership refund in the National Commission's order of 30 October 2026, which held the clause "one-sided and unfair" and upheld a refund of Rs 90,000 to a Bengaluru member who signed at the company's office on the day of the pitch and asked to cancel about one and a half months later, having used nothing. The same order said the company could perhaps have kept a pro rata charge, reasonable administrative charges or an earnest amount, and that the answer might have been different had the member used the membership. A month earlier the Punjab State Commission enforced the same company group's no-refund and maintenance clauses against members who proved no refused booking or broken written promise.

Part of the consumer protection practice at S Jain & Attorneys, Bangalore.

This guide is for a family that signed a long-term holiday membership at a "free holiday" presentation, paid Rs 50,000 to Rs 3 lakh, often on a card EMI, and wants out. The Bengaluru and Delhi complaints discussed here were filed in 2015 and 2017 under the Consumer Protection Act, 1986, so neither order applies the 2019 Act's unfair-contract provisions, which are dealt with separately.

Where you areWhat a 2026 order didWhat you can realistically ask for
Cancelled in writing within weeks, used nothingNational Commission, 30 October 2026: refund of Rs 90,000 with 6 percent interest upheld, no-refund clause held one-sided and unfairWhat you paid with interest, possibly less a pro rata charge, administrative charges or an earnest amount
Used holidays, or held the membership for months or yearsPunjab State Commission, 1 October 2026: three refund orders set aside where members proved neither a refused booking nor a broken written promiseLittle on the clause alone. A refund turns on proof of a refused booking or a broken written promise
Years later, disputing maintenance chargesPunjab: a clause making charges payable irrespective of use enforced. Delhi State Commission, 28 September 2026: a company that never issued the card could not rely on unpaid chargesCharges in the signed agreement have been enforced against members who stayed in, unless the company had not performed its side

Three points from the Bengaluru order frame any demand you make.

One and a half months

Signed and paid Rs 90,000 on the day of the pitch, asked to cancel about one and a half months later, and used no benefit.

Deductions it contemplated

A pro rata charge, reasonable administrative charges or an earnest amount might have been kept, though the full refund the State Commission ordered stood.

A 1986 Act complaint

Filed in January 2015, years before the 2019 Act and its unfair-contract definition came into force, so the order does not apply section 2(46).

Holiday membership refund: is a "non-refundable" clause binding if we cancel within weeks?

Not automatically, on the National Commission's reasoning. It read the clause against the whole transaction: the member was invited to the office, "obviously pitched the benefits", signed and paid the same day for services to be used over a long period, asked to leave within about one and a half months without taking any benefit, and the agreement also bound him to pay maintenance charges every year. On those facts it held the company's conduct in taking the fee and then refusing to return it "patently unfair and unjust", held the clause itself one-sided and unfair, and said keeping the money would "unjustly and disproportionately enrich" the company.

The order does not void every such clause. The Commission accepted that the member never tried to use any service and that nothing showed the facilities were unavailable. Its answer rested on speed, non-use and a long commitment signed on the spot.

Key takeaway. What carried the Bengaluru refund was a written request to cancel within weeks, with nothing used. Speed and non-use are facts you create now, not arguments you can make later.

What did the National Commission decide for a Bengaluru buyer in October 2026?

It dismissed the company's revision and left the refund in place. After a promotional call, the member went to the company's office on 7 December 2013 to collect gifts, signed a Membership Purchase Agreement and paid Rs 90,000 the same day. He e-mailed on 28 January 2014 asking to cancel, wrote repeatedly, sent a notice and filed a complaint on 31 January 2015. The Bengaluru District Forum dismissed it in August 2016 for want of proof of an unfair trade practice or deficiency in service. In April 2021 the Karnataka State Commission ordered a refund of Rs 90,000 with interest at 6 percent a year from the complaint date and Rs 5,000 as costs, because the company had not shown the facilities were actually extended to him.

The company's case in revision had real force on paper: the member signed voluntarily, the fee was expressly non-refundable, the gift vouchers were given, he never tried to book a holiday, a Commission cannot rewrite the contract, and he had not paid his maintenance charges. In Revision Petition No. 259 of 2022, filed by Country Vacations and Country Club (India) Ltd, now Country Club Hospitality and Holidays Ltd, the National Commission agreed with the State Commission's result "though for different reasons" and found "no jurisdictional or other error". At the time of writing we found no report of a further challenge.

Can the company keep anything, such as pro rata or administrative charges?

Possibly, on the National Commission's own words, though in that case it kept nothing. The order says the member "was required to be refunded after perhaps deducting pro-rata charges for 1.5 months, and may be some additional reasonable administrative charges or some earnest amount". The State Commission had ordered the full Rs 90,000, and the revision was dismissed without reducing it, so the deduction remained an observation. The realistic figure is what you paid, with interest, less a reasonable deduction the company can justify. Ask for the full sum if you wish, but expect the company to argue for a deduction.

On our reading, anything you have already used, a free night from the welcome offer or a redeemed gift voucher, is a benefit the company will ask to set off.

What if we were promised things the agreement does not contain?

Then the paper you hold decides most of it. In three appeals by the same company group decided together on 1 October 2026, First Appeals 338, 339 and 299 of 2022, the Punjab State Commission set aside refunds where members could not prove a refused booking or relied on promises missing from the signed agreement: club and fitness facilities under a vacation-only agreement, invitations to events, and a waiver of maintenance charges that the e-mail produced did not contain. It held that "oral assertions cannot supersede the written agreement" and, citing the Supreme Court, that a person who signs a document is presumed to have read and understood it unless force or fraud is proved. The Bengaluru refund did not rest on proof that the member was misled either.

Section 2(47)(i)(b) and (d) of the 2019 Act treat a statement that falsely represents a service's standard, or claims benefits it does not have, as an unfair trade practice, and section 2(47)(iii)(a) covers "creating impression that something is being given or offered free of charge when it is fully or partly covered by the amount charged, in the transaction as a whole". On our reading that is the "free holiday" paid for in the membership price. Each needs proof. In the Delhi case the State Commission read the promised benefits from the membership details the member placed on record, and held the company to them.

Common mistake. Relying on what the sales executive said. A Commission reads the signed agreement first, and a promise that exists only in memory rarely survives it. Photograph the brochure and the presentation, and keep every message from the executive, on the day you sign.

Do we still owe the annual maintenance charges?

If the agreement says so and you stay in the membership, the clause has been enforced, and a promise of no maintenance charges needs to be in writing. In one of the Punjab appeals, clause 9 made the charges payable "irrespective of usage of the vacations", and the State Commission held that the Rs 30,050 the members had paid was maintenance for the five-year vacation period, not an extension of membership as they claimed.

The answer changes where the company has not performed its side. On 28 September 2026 the Delhi State Commission, in C.C. No. 1780 of 2017, a member's complaint about a 2008 life membership against Country Club Hospitality and Holidays Ltd, held that a company which never issued the membership card or allotted the promised plot "cannot rely upon the alleged non-payment of registration expenses or annual maintenance charges". It ordered a refund of the full Rs 1,75,000 with interest at 6 percent a year from April 2008 if paid by 28 November 2026 and 9 percent if not, Rs 1 lakh for mental agony and Rs 50,000 as costs. In the Bengaluru case the company's point that the member had not paid maintenance did not save its revision.

On our reading, charges for the years after a written cancellation stand or fall with the cancellation. Dispute them in writing, and if the company insists, decide whether to pay under protest and claim it back in your complaint.

The October order arose under the 1986 Act: what can a family that signed after 20 July 2020 ask for?

More, on the text, though no order we read applies it to a holiday membership. The 1986 Act had no definition of an unfair contract and did not list one among the things a complaint could allege, and the Bengaluru complaint was framed as deficiency in service and unfair trade practice. The Consumer Protection Act, 2019, whose definitions and Commission provisions came into force on 20 July 2020 under notification S.O. 2351(E), adds three things.

First, section 2(46) defines an unfair contract as one with terms that "cause significant change in the rights of such consumer", including a penalty for breach "wholly disproportionate to the loss occurred due to such breach to the other party to the contract" (clause (ii)) and "any unreasonable charge, obligation or condition which puts such consumer to disadvantage" (clause (vi)). Second, section 2(6)(i) lets a complaint allege that an unfair contract has been adopted. Third, section 49(2) lets the State Commission "declare any terms of contract, which is unfair to any consumer, to be null and void", and section 59(2) gives the National Commission the same power. Through section 49(1) it can also make the section 39(1) orders, including a refund "along with such interest" under clause (c), compensation and costs.

On our reading, a no-refund clause that keeps the whole fee of a member who leaves within weeks, having used nothing, fits clause (ii) or (vi). Whether the 2019 definitions reach an agreement signed before 20 July 2020 is a separate question we have not seen decided.

Which Commission hears an unfair-contract complaint, and how do we file?

The State Commission, on the Act's own words, however small the price. Section 47(1)(a)(ii) gives it "complaints against unfair contracts, where the value of goods or services paid as consideration does not exceed ten crore rupees", and section 58(1)(a)(ii) sends anything above that to the National Commission. The 2021 Jurisdiction Rules, G.S.R. 912(E) of 30 December 2021, cut the ordinary District Commission band to Rs 50 lakh and the State Commission band to Rs 2 crore, but rule 4 is made under the proviso to sub-clause (i) only, so on our reading the unfair-contract limb still runs to Rs 10 crore. The District Commission's list of orders in section 39(1) contains no power to declare a term void.

So a family that wants the clause struck down goes to the Karnataka State Commission, while a complaint asking only for a refund for deficiency in service or an unfair trade practice goes to the District Commission where the family lives or works, under section 34(2)(d). Both can be filed on e-Jagriti, launched by the Department of Consumer Affairs on 1 January 2025, which integrates e-Daakhil, and under the fee table substituted in August 2023 a complaint where the value paid is up to Rs 5 lakh carries no fee.

Deadline warning. Under section 69 a Commission cannot admit a complaint filed later than two years from the day the cause of action arose, unless it finds sufficient cause and records why it condones the delay. On our reading, count from the company's first refusal, and do not let months of calls saying your request is under process run the clock.

In the Delhi case the cause of action was treated as recurring because the card was never issued and the plot never allotted. Do not rely on that for a membership you have been able to use.

What do we send this week, and what evidence do we keep?

A written cancellation, the documents behind it, and nothing that looks like using the membership.

  1. E-mail the company and post the same letter to the branch that signed you up: membership number, date, amount paid, that you cancel and want a refund, and each point on which the agreement differs from the pitch.
  2. Book no stay and redeem no voucher, because the October order said the position "could perhaps have been different" had the member availed any benefit.
  3. Keep the agreement, receipts, card or bank entries, the brochure, vouchers and every message from the sales executive, with dates.
  4. Answer the first maintenance invoice in writing, disputing it as falling after your cancellation.
  5. If you paid on a card EMI, keep paying unless the issuer agrees otherwise in writing. The EMI is owed to the issuer under your card agreement, to which the holiday company is not a party, so read what that agreement says about missed payments first.
  6. If the refusal stands, send a legal notice and then file on e-Jagriti within two years: the District Commission for a refund, or the State Commission where you want the clause declared void.

The law is rarely what sinks these claims. Families cancel by phone, are told the request is being processed, and lose months with nothing in writing. Others accept a free night at a partner resort while the dispute runs, handing the company the argument that they used the membership. Complaints plead what the executive said without the brochure or a single message, and some ask a District Commission to strike down the clause, a power the Act gives the State Commission.

Four rules decide where and how a family files.

State Commission for terms

Complaints against unfair contracts go to the State Commission up to Rs 10 crore paid, and only it or the National Commission can declare a term void.

District Commission for refunds

A refund complaint for deficiency in service or unfair trade practice goes to the District Commission where the value paid is up to Rs 50 lakh.

No fee to five lakh

Under the fee table substituted in August 2023, a complaint where the value paid is up to Rs 5 lakh carries no fee.

Two years to file

Two years runs from the day the cause of action arose. A complaint after that is admitted only if the Commission finds sufficient cause and records why it condones the delay.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can the company keep everything because the agreement says non-refundable?

Not where a member left within weeks having used nothing, on the National Commission's order of 30 October 2026, which held such a clause one-sided and unfair. The same order said a pro rata charge, reasonable administrative charges or an earnest amount might be kept, and the Punjab State Commission enforced the clause against members who had held their memberships for months or years.

We used one free night from the welcome offer. Have we lost the refund?

Not necessarily, but you have given the company an argument. The October order said the position could perhaps have been different had the member availed any benefit, so expect the company to set off what you used, and stop using anything further once you cancel.

The company offers to switch us to a shorter plan instead of a refund. Should we accept?

Only if the new plan suits you. The October order said the answer might have been different had the member acted "in furtherance of the contract", and on our reading signing a revised plan is such an act. If you want your money back, reply in writing that you decline and repeat the cancellation.

We paid on a card EMI. Can we stop the instalments?

The instalments are owed to your card issuer under your card agreement, not to the holiday company, so on our reading a dispute with the company does not by itself end them. Read what your card agreement says about missed payments, keep paying unless the issuer agrees otherwise in writing, and claim what you paid from the company.

Can we file in Bengaluru if the company's registered office is elsewhere?

Yes. Section 34(2)(d) lets a complaint be filed in the District Commission where the complainant resides or personally works for gain, and section 47(4)(d) says the same for the State Commission. A branch office in your city is a further ground under section 34(2)(a).

Can we claim compensation as well as the refund?

Yes. Section 39(1) lets the Commission order the price returned with interest, compensation for any loss or injury due to the opposite party's negligence, and costs. The Bengaluru member received interest at 6 percent and Rs 5,000 as costs, while the Delhi member, who never received a card, was awarded Rs 1 lakh for mental agony and Rs 50,000 as costs.

Our membership was signed in 2018. Does the 2019 Act's unfair-contract power help us?

Uncertain. The 2019 Act's definitions and Commission provisions came into force on 20 July 2020, and we have not seen an order deciding whether section 2(46) reaches an earlier agreement. On our reading, the route the Bengaluru member used, deficiency in service and unfair conduct in refusing a prompt refund, remains open.

How long does a complaint like this take, and what does it cost?

The Bengaluru complaint, filed in January 2015, ended in the National Commission in October 2026 after a dismissal, an appeal and a revision. As an indicative range, plan for one to two years at the first level if the company contests. There is no filing fee where the value paid is up to Rs 5 lakh.

This article is for general informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Consult a qualified advocate for advice on your specific situation.

References

  1. National Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission, Revision Petition No. 259 of 2022, Country Vacations and Country Club (India) Ltd (now Country Club Hospitality and Holidays Ltd) v a Bengaluru member, reserved 14 July 2026, pronounced 30 October 2026, against the Karnataka State Commission's order of 16 April 2021 in First Appeal 3097 of 2016: no-refund clause held one-sided and unfair where the member asked to leave within 1.5 months without availing any benefit, refund of Rs 90,000 with 6 percent interest and Rs 5,000 costs left in place, revision dismissed.
  2. State Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission, Punjab, First Appeals 338, 339 and 299 of 2022 by Country Vacations, a division of Country Club (India) Ltd, decided 1 October 2026: three District Commission refund orders set aside for want of proof of a refused booking or a written promise, a maintenance clause payable irrespective of usage enforced, and the non-refundable clause applied.
  3. Delhi State Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission, C.C. No. 1780 of 2017 against Country Club Hospitality and Holidays Ltd, judgment of 28 September 2026 under the Consumer Protection Act, 1986: failure to issue the membership card and allot the promised plot held a deficiency, the company could not rely on unpaid maintenance charges, refund of Rs 1,75,000 with interest, Rs 1 lakh for mental agony and Rs 50,000 costs.
  4. Consumer Protection Act, 2019 (No. 35 of 2019), Gazette of India copy published by the Department of Consumer Affairs: sections 2(6), 2(46), 2(47), 34, 39(1), 47(1) and (4), 49, 58(1), 59(2) and 69.
  5. Ministry of Consumer Affairs, Food and Public Distribution, notification S.O. 2351(E) of 15 July 2020: section 2 (save five clauses) and sections 28 to 73 of the Consumer Protection Act, 2019, among others, in force from 20 July 2020.
  6. Consumer Protection (Jurisdiction of the District Commission, the State Commission and the National Commission) Rules, 2021, G.S.R. 912(E) of 30 December 2021: rules 3 to 5, value paid as consideration up to Rs 50 lakh for the District Commission, above Rs 50 lakh up to Rs 2 crore for the State Commission, made under the provisos to sections 34(1), 47(1)(a)(i) and 58(1)(a)(i).

Related Legal Services

Dealing with a matter like this? Our Bangalore advocates can help. Explore the relevant practice areas:

SJ

About the Author

Advocate Sharan Jain

Advocate based in Bangalore, practising before the Karnataka High Court and District, Sessions, Consumer and Family courts. Writes on civil, criminal, corporate, family and constitutional law to make Indian law more accessible.

Related Articles

S Jain & Attorneys · Legal Consultation

Have a Legal Question? We're Here to Help.

Our experienced lawyers in Bangalore offer confidential consultations tailored to your specific legal needs.

All matters handled with complete confidentiality and legal discretion.