Yes, a Consumer Commission can order the dealer and the manufacturer to replace the car or to refund its price, under section 39(1)(b) and (c) of the Consumer Protection Act, 2019, but only after a defect is proved, and a fault the service centre has fixed, even over several visits, is more likely to earn compensation than a new car. On 12 January 2026 the National Commission refused to replace a 2014 Maruti Suzuki Celerio whose brake fault had been rectified and which had run more than 70,000 km, and on 2 April 2026 it upheld a refund of Rs 10,42,776 for a Ford EcoSport in which only two of six airbags opened in a crash, without any expert report. The difference was proof: a defect that was real and uncured on the record, against a run of repairs the workshop had closed.
Part of the consumer protection practice at S Jain & Attorneys, Bangalore.
This page is for a buyer some months into a new car that keeps going back to the authorised service centre with the same fault, and for one whose airbags did not open in an accident. Both National Commission orders arose from complaints filed in 2016 under the Consumer Protection Act, 1986, so each point below is mapped to the 2019 Act that governs a complaint filed now. If the dealer sold you a used car as new, read the answer on a used car sold as new, and if the fault surfaced after the warranty ran out, the answer on out-of-warranty defects.
Three 2026 orders on new cars show what a Commission does with the proof.
| The car and what the buyer showed | What was ordered | Act, and where it stands |
|---|---|---|
| Ford EcoSport bought in July 2015 for Rs 10,42,776. It hit a road divider and rolled over, and only two of its six airbags opened. Neither the manufacturer nor the dealer led evidence. | Refund of the price by the manufacturer and the dealer jointly and severally, against transfer of the registration, with Rs 20,000 compensation and Rs 5,000 costs (District Forum, 14 March 2017). | 1986 Act. Upheld by the State Commission and by the National Commission on 2 April 2026. The Punjab and Haryana High Court dismissed Ford's writ on 11 September 2026. |
| Maruti Suzuki Celerio bought in 2014. A brake calliper fault appeared over several visits, later job cards showed no continuing defect, no expert was called, and the car had run more than 70,000 km. | Replacement ordered by the District Commission in 2019, substituted on appeal by Rs 70,000 compensation and Rs 30,000 costs with 9 percent interest. Replacement not restored on 12 January 2026. | 1986 Act, complaint of 2016. The buyer's revision was dismissed. |
| Land Rover Defender bought by a company in October 2022 for Rs 1,65,61,234. It missed the advertised 0 to 100 km/h time, lacked a standard-specification feature, and its chassis was cut during warranty repairs. | Refund of the price by the manufacturer with 7 percent interest from the date the complaint was admitted, and Rs 50,000 costs, the dealer exonerated (Uttarakhand State Commission, 27 April 2026). | 2019 Act. On the manufacturer's appeal the National Commission stayed execution after the fifty percent deposit, as reported in June 2026. |
Key takeaway. The number of visits is not the test. In the orders read for this guide, a new car or the money back followed proof of a defect that had not been cured, or of a car that did not match what was claimed for it, and compensation followed a fault the workshop had fixed.
Four points carry most of the weight.
Defect, not visit count
The Act defines only a defect. The National Commission refused replacement in January 2026 where a brake fault had been rectified over several visits and the car kept running.
Job cards can suffice
A laboratory test is needed only where the defect cannot be found without analysis. Job cards showing the same failure can carry a case, and cards reading no fault found cut against it.
Airbags that stayed shut
Only two of six airbags opening in a severe crash was held a defect on 2 April 2026, with no expert report, because the facts were not disputed.
Two years to file
Section 69 allows two years from the cause of action, and more only for sufficient cause. In an airbag case the Supreme Court counted from the crash, not the purchase.
When does a repeated fault become a "manufacturing defect" in law?
It does not have to. Section 2(10) of the 2019 Act defines a "defect" as any fault, imperfection or shortcoming in the quality, quantity, potency, purity or standard required by law or by contract, express or implied, "or as is claimed by the trader in any manner whatsoever". The words "manufacturing defect" appear in the Act only at section 84(1)(a), in the product liability chapter, undefined. In the Celerio order of 12 January 2026 (Revision Petition 403 of 2022, against Maruti Suzuki India Ltd), the National Commission quoted its own decision of 16 May 2025 in a complaint against Mercedes-Benz India that a car can be replaced or refunded for any "defect" in this sense, but that "even if the defect in a good/car is established, it does not necessarily have to result in directions of replacement of good/car or refund of its cost".
So the real question is what relief the proved defect deserves, and the same order answered it for a brake fault: "A partial failure in the braking system that seems to have been rectified later on may be on a number of visits, does not justify the replacement of the vehicle". On our reading, three patterns move a claim towards replacement or refund: the same component failing again after each repair, a defect the dealer could not cure at all, and a car that does not match what was claimed for it. The Uttarakhand State Commission applied the last when it held that the Defender's failure to reach its advertised 0 to 100 km/h time of 6.1 seconds, and a missing fuel flap lock listed as standard, were manufacturing defects.
Do I sue the dealer, the manufacturer or both?
Both, naming the manufacturer's Indian company as it appears on the invoice or warranty booklet. Section 2(45) defines "trader" to include "the manufacturer" of the goods, so a defect complaint lies against the maker as well as the showroom. In the airbag case the District Forum directed the manufacturer and the dealer to refund the price "jointly and severally", and when the dealer argued that only the manufacturer was answerable, the State Commission held that "in absence of pleading it cannot be inferred that the agreement between the manufacturer and dealer ... was principal to principal basis". The National Commission dismissed both companies' revisions.
In the Defender case the manufacturer relied on a clause in its retailer agreement that neither side answers for the other's acts, and the State Commission held that the complainant "was not a party to the said agreement", treated the free warranty repairs as making the manufacturer a service provider to the buyer, ordered the manufacturer to refund and exonerated the dealer on those facts. A workshop whose repair was deficient answers for deficiency in service under section 2(11), and in a product liability action as a "product service provider" under sections 2(38) and 85.
Do I need an expert report or a laboratory test, or are the job cards enough?
Not always, and the Act says when. Section 38(2)(c) requires the District Commission to send a sample for analysis or test only "if the complaint alleges a defect in the goods which cannot be determined without proper analysis or test of the goods", the test section 13(1)(c) of the 1986 Act also used. Rejecting Ford's argument that the airbag finding needed such a test, the Punjab and Haryana High Court held on 11 September 2026 that "A patent defect or failure, which can reasonably be inferred from the established circumstances, does not require a laboratory analysis merely because the product has a sophisticated mechanism."
Job cards usually do this work, and they cut both ways. In the Celerio order the National Commission accepted, again quoting its Mercedes-Benz decision, that a laboratory test or expert opinion "is not mandatory in each and every case" where there is "other reliable, cogent and sufficient evidence", and one earlier order it quoted treated 25 visits to the workshop in three and a half years as showing that the car supplied was defective. The Celerio buyer still lost the replacement, because his own job cards told the other story: one recorded a calliper problem and a part to be changed later, a later one recorded a test drive with him that found nothing abnormal, and later cards did not show the defect continuing. With no expert to say otherwise, the finding of no manufacturing defect stood.
So ask the dealer in writing for the service history, which in the Celerio case the manufacturer produced and the Commission matched against the job cards, and see that every card records your complaint and the odometer reading. Get a report from an independent automobile engineer who has examined the car, and if the fault needs analysis, ask for the section 38(2)(c) reference and offer the fee under section 38(2)(d). The laboratory route and the product liability chain are explained in our guide on a defective paint complaint.
Common mistake. Signing for the car when the job card says "checked, no fault found" without writing down the fault you reported. In the Celerio case the State Commission relied on a job card recording a test drive with the buyer and no problem, and the National Commission accepted that finding in refusing replacement.
Replacement, refund or compensation: what does a Commission actually order?
Whatever the proved facts support from the list in section 39(1): removal of the defect, replacement "with new goods of similar description which shall be free from any defect", return of the price "along with such interest on such price or charges as may be decided", compensation for "any loss or injury suffered by the consumer due to the negligence of the opposite party", with power to grant punitive damages, and "adequate costs". Sections 49(1) and 59(1) apply the list to the State and National Commissions. Section 14(1)(a) to (d) of the 1986 Act gave the same reliefs, except that its refund clause said nothing about interest.
A refund comes with conditions. The airbag refund was ordered against a letter of subrogation and a power of attorney to transfer the registration, and the Defender refund required the car to be handed to the manufacturer within fifteen days. Interest is the Commission's call: 9 percent a year in the airbag case if the refund was not paid within a month, and 7 percent in the Defender case from the date the complaint was admitted, not the date of purchase, because the vehicle had been used "for sufficient duration".
The Commission is not limited to the relief you name. The Supreme Court held in Hyundai Motor India Ltd's appeal (Civil Appeal 3001 of 2022, 20 April 2022, a 1986 Act case) that a consumer forum may grant relief within the statutory list "irrespective of the fact as to whether specifically certain reliefs have been claimed or not, provided that facts make out foundations for granting such reliefs", and it upheld replacement of the car and punitive damages where the airbags failed. Plead the alternatives anyway, so the facts for each are on record.
Does the distance I have driven weaken my claim?
It can, in two ways. As evidence: refusing to replace the Celerio, the National Commission noted that the defect, if any, "has been rectified and cured and the vehicle has already run more than 70,000 kms. as in 2024", the last service record showing 69,686 km in January 2024. The other side will call a car still covering distance fit for use. As a measure: the Defender refund carried interest only from the date of admission because the company had used the vehicle. Make the readings tell your story instead. The kilometres logged on every job card show how soon the fault came back after each repair, and if the car is off the road, keep the service centre's written acknowledgement that it holds the car and the cost of other transport for the compensation claim. In the Hyundai appeal the Supreme Court said insurance-funded repairs "would not impact the quantum of damages, which is partly punitive in nature in this case".
The airbags did not open in a crash: is that a defect by itself?
It can be, on facts like the EcoSport's. In the revisions filed by the dealer, A.B. Motors Pvt Ltd, and the manufacturer, Ford India Pvt Ltd, the National Commission held on 2 April 2026 that "if only two bags were opened out of six bags then it does amount to manufacturing defect and no expert evidence or expert opinion was required to be produced by the complainant", applying res ipsa loquitur because the accident and the opening of only two airbags were not disputed. It accepted that "wearing of seatbelt does not absolve the manufacturer from the liability pertaining to the defective airbags", and found the owner's manual argument, that the driver-side airbags deploy only in significant frontal collisions, "without any support of convincing material".
Dismissing Ford's writ, the High Court said that with damage on all four sides "all the six airbags should have deployed", and called the dispute "squarely covered" by the Supreme Court's decision in Hyundai Motor India Ltd's appeal. There the front airbags of a Creta did not open in a crash with substantial front damage, the manufacturer's own investigation report said the conditions for deployment were not met, and the Supreme Court still upheld the finding of a defect: "A consumer is not meant to be an expert in physics calculating the impact of a collision on the theories based on velocity and force." It added that a defective safety feature can attract punitive damages.
Read the limits with the result. In the EcoSport case neither company led evidence before the District Forum, the manufacturer having been proceeded against ex parte, and the High Court described the factual position as "admitted". The National Commission, sitting in revision, said it "cannot re-appreciate the evidence led by the parties like an appellate court". On our reading, a manufacturer that produces crash data and a technical explanation in a contested complaint presents a different case, and the buyer should have an engineer's report ready to answer it.
If the occupants were hurt, there is a second claim. The 2019 Act's product liability chapter, which the 1986 Act did not have, lets a complainant claim compensation from the product manufacturer for "harm" caused by a defective product (sections 82 to 84), and section 2(22) defines harm to include "personal injury, illness or death" but not "any harm caused to a product itself". On the text, injuries go into a product liability claim under section 39(1)(e) or a negligence claim under clause (d), and the car into the defect claim.
Both 2026 National Commission orders arose under the 1986 Act: do they still apply to my car?
On the text, yes. The 2019 Act carried the same tests forward, with three changes a car buyer will notice. Section 107(1) repealed the Consumer Protection Act, 1986, and section 107(2) treats anything done under it as done under the corresponding provision of the new Act.
| Point | 1986 Act, under which both complaints were filed | 2019 Act, for a complaint filed now |
|---|---|---|
| What a defect is | Section 2(1)(f) | Section 2(10), in the same words with "or product" added |
| Testing only where the defect cannot be found without it | Section 13(1)(c) | Section 38(2)(c) |
| Replacement, refund, compensation | Section 14(1)(b), (c) and (d) | Section 39(1)(b), (c) and (d), with interest on a refund now written into clause (c) |
| Which Commission | Value of the goods and the compensation claimed (section 11(1)) | Value paid as consideration (section 34(1) and the 2021 Rules) |
| Injury from a defective product | No product liability chapter | Chapter VI, sections 82 to 87 |
| National Commission revision | Section 21(b) | Section 58(1)(b) |
| Limitation | Two years, section 24A | Two years, section 69 |
Which Commission do I file in, and what is the fee?
The one that matches the price you paid, where you live or work. Section 34(1) fixes jurisdiction by "the value of the goods or services paid as consideration", not by what you claim, and rules 3 to 5 of the Consumer Protection (Jurisdiction of the District Commission, the State Commission and the National Commission) Rules, 2021, notified as G.S.R. 912(E) on 30 December 2021, set the bands: up to Rs 50 lakh for the District Commission, above Rs 50 lakh up to Rs 2 crore for the State Commission, and above Rs 2 crore for the National Commission. The Rs 1.65 crore Defender went to a State Commission, which under section 42(2) ordinarily sits at the State capital. On territory, section 34(2)(d) allows the complaint to be instituted where the complainant "resides or personally works for gain", so a buyer living or working in Bengaluru can file there.
The fee follows the same price under rule 7 of the Consumer Protection (Consumer Disputes Redressal Commissions) Rules, 2020, as its table was substituted on 17 August 2023: nil up to Rs 5 lakh, Rs 200 above Rs 5 lakh up to Rs 10 lakh, Rs 400 above Rs 10 lakh up to Rs 20 lakh, Rs 1,000 above Rs 20 lakh up to Rs 50 lakh, Rs 2,000 above Rs 50 lakh up to Rs 1 crore, and Rs 2,500 above Rs 1 crore up to Rs 2 crore. The wider rules are in our guide to consumer court types and jurisdiction.
Within what time must I file?
Within two years from the date on which the cause of action arose, under section 69(1), and later only if the Commission accepts that you had sufficient cause and records its reasons for condoning the delay under section 69(2). For airbags, the Supreme Court in the Hyundai appeal held that limitation ran "from the day the defect surfaces", the date of the accident, and rejected the manufacturer's plea to count from the purchase. The Act does not say which date starts the clock for a fault that keeps coming back. On our reading, count from the earliest date the other side can point to, usually the first job card that records the fault, and treat every later visit as evidence rather than a fresh start.
Deadline warning. Two years under section 69(1) is the limit, and a dealer's offer of one more repair, a goodwill extension or a promise to escalate does not stop it on the text of the Act. File before two years from the first recorded failure, and plead every later date as evidence of the same defect.
The company has appealed: does it have to deposit, and can it stop the refund?
It must deposit half of what it was ordered to pay before its appeal is heard. Section 41 gives forty-five days to appeal a District Commission order to the State Commission and bars an appeal by "a person, who is required to pay any amount" unless the appellant "has deposited fifty per cent. of that amount". Section 51(1) applies the same condition, within thirty days, to an appeal to the National Commission against a State Commission's original order, and section 67 to an appeal from the National Commission's original order to the Supreme Court.
The Act does not say that the deposit stops the refund, but the appellate Commission can stay it. In the Defender case the National Commission stayed execution after noting the deposit, as reported in June 2026, and listed the appeal for 7 October 2026, with no later order found at the time of writing. Both 2026 National Commission orders came on revisions against State Commission orders passed in appeal, a route now under section 58(1)(b), and in the airbag case the Commission repeated, quoting the Supreme Court, that its revisional jurisdiction is "extremely limited". An order not appealed is final under section 68 and enforceable "as if it were a decree" under section 71, and section 72(1) punishes non-compliance with imprisonment of one month to three years, a fine of Rs 25,000 to Rs 1 lakh, or both. The company's side of the same appeal is in our guide for a business defending a consumer complaint.
What goes in the legal notice and the e-Jagriti filing, step by step?
A short notice to both companies, then a complaint built on the job cards and filed online.
- Ask the dealer in writing for the complete service history, and keep every job card and invoice with its date and odometer reading.
- When the fault returns, write to the dealer and the manufacturer's Indian company together: date and price of purchase, each visit with its job card number, date and reading, what the fault does, and the replacement or refund you want, with a request for a joint inspection. Sections 35 to 38 make no notice a condition of filing, but a written refusal puts the dispute on record.
- Have an independent automobile engineer inspect the car and report on the fault and whether it has been cured.
- Draft the complaint as a dated chronology with a document for each fact, asking for replacement or, failing that, a refund with interest, plus compensation and costs, and a section 38(2)(c) reference if the fault needs testing. Where an airbag failure caused injury, add the product liability claim.
- File electronically, as the proviso to section 35(1) allows, on the e-Jagriti platform of the Department of Consumer Affairs, and pay the rule 7 fee.
- Admissibility is ordinarily decided within twenty-one days under section 36(2), and the opposite parties then have thirty days, extendable by fifteen, to give their version under section 38(2)(a). Evidence is by affidavit and documents under section 38(6).
- Keep the car available, because the refund and replacement directions in the EcoSport, Celerio and Defender cases were each made against the return of the car or its registration.
What does it cost and how long does it take?
The filing fee is the rule 7 figure, nil to Rs 1,000 for a car costing up to Rs 50 lakh, and the larger cost is time. Section 38(7) asks the District Commission to try to decide within three months of notice to the opposite party, or five months where testing is needed. The two National Commission orders show what happens when a company contests every level: the airbag complaint was filed in 2016, decided by the District Forum on 14 March 2017 and the State Commission on 13 July 2017, then sat in revision until 2 April 2026, and Ford's writ was dismissed on 11 September 2026. The Celerio complaint of 2016 went through orders in 2019, 2021 and January 2026. Professional fees turn on the number of opposite parties, whether an engineer's evidence is needed and how far the companies take the case, and any figure is indicative only.
The figures that decide the filing, on one card each.
Forum by price paid
Where the price paid is up to Rs 50 lakh the District Commission hears the complaint, and above that up to Rs 2 crore the State Commission, under the 2021 Rules.
Fee by price paid
The filing fee is Rs 200 for a car above Rs 5 lakh up to Rs 10 lakh, Rs 400 up to Rs 20 lakh and Rs 1,000 up to Rs 50 lakh.
Half down to appeal
A dealer or manufacturer ordered to pay must deposit fifty percent of that amount before its appeal is heard, under sections 41, 51(1) and 67 of the 2019 Act.
Refund means returning the car
The airbag and Defender refunds were ordered against transfer of the registration or return of the car, with interest at a rate the Commission fixed.
What we see go wrong
In our practice, repeat-defect complaints are rarely short of visits to the workshop. They are short of paper that ties the visits together. Job cards record "checked, found OK" and the buyer signs for the car without adding a word. The odometer readings that would show the fault returning within a few hundred kilometres are never pulled out and set side by side. The complaint names the dealer alone, and the dealer answers that only the manufacturer can replace a car. Months go in goodwill promises while the first job card ages towards two years. The first task on these files is a single dated table of every visit, fault and reading, built from the service history, because it is the document the Commission and every appeal will turn to.
Frequently Asked Questions
My car has gone back to the service centre four times for the same fault. Can I get a new car?
Possibly, if the fault is proved and has not been cured. On 12 January 2026 the National Commission refused to replace a Celerio whose brake fault had been rectified and which had run more than 70,000 km, and left the buyer with compensation. Job cards showing the same failure returning, and an engineer's report, are what move a claim towards replacement or refund under section 39(1).
Do I need an expert report to prove a manufacturing defect in my car?
Not in every case. Section 38(2)(c) calls for a laboratory test only where the defect cannot be determined without analysis, and the Punjab and Haryana High Court and the National Commission both said in 2026 that expert evidence is not mandatory every time. Without it, though, a Commission may hold the defect unproved, as the Celerio buyer found.
Should I file against the dealer or the manufacturer?
Both. The 2019 Act's definition of trader includes the manufacturer, and in the airbag case the refund was ordered against the manufacturer and the dealer jointly and severally. In the Defender case the State Commission held the buyer was not bound by the agreement between the dealer and the manufacturer, but ordered only the manufacturer to refund and exonerated the dealer on the facts.
Only some of the airbags opened in my accident. Is that a defect?
It can be. On 2 April 2026 the National Commission upheld a refund of Rs 10,42,776 where only two of six airbags opened in a rollover, without an expert report, because the facts were not disputed. Where the manufacturer produces crash data, be ready to answer it with an engineer's report.
Which Commission hears a complaint about a Rs 15 lakh car, and what is the fee?
The District Commission, because the price paid is under Rs 50 lakh, and you may file where you live or work. The fee for a price above Rs 10 lakh and up to Rs 20 lakh is Rs 400 under rule 7 of the 2020 Commission Rules as amended in 2023.
How long do I have to file a complaint about a defective car?
Two years from the date the cause of action arose, under section 69, with later filing only on sufficient cause and recorded reasons. For a failed airbag the Supreme Court counted from the accident. For a repeated fault, count from the first job card that records it.
If the Commission orders a refund, do I have to return the car?
In the orders read for this guide, yes. The airbag refund was against transfer of the registration, and the Defender refund required the car to be handed back within fifteen days. Interest is fixed by the Commission: 9 percent in the airbag case only if the refund was paid late, and 7 percent from admission in the Defender case.
Can the manufacturer delay paying by filing an appeal?
It can appeal, but only after depositing fifty percent of the amount it was ordered to pay, under section 41 or 51(1). Whether the rest is stayed meanwhile is for the appellate Commission, as the reported stay in the Defender case shows. An order not appealed is final and enforceable as a decree, and non-compliance is punishable under section 72.
This article is for general informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Consult a qualified advocate for advice on your specific situation.






