Not just because the bankruptcy trustee asks. If your mother gave you the jewellery outright before her bankruptcy application was filed, it stopped being hers, and the trustee needs an NCLT order to undo the gift under section 164, 164A or 165 of the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code, 2016. On 12 October 2026 the NCLT's Jaipur bench held that a bankrupt guarantor's handover of 192.49 grams of jewellery to her son was not a preference, because he was not shown to be her creditor, surety or guarantor and the handover was not shown to have triggered the bankruptcy process. It left ownership open, and section 164, which deems a transaction with a child in the two years before the application to be undervalued, was not before it.
Part of the corporate and commercial law practice at S Jain & Attorneys, Bangalore.
This guide is for the adult child, or a child's spouse, of a bankrupt parent who guaranteed a family company's loans. The company's own look-back is in our guide for a director whose company is admitted into CIRP, and the guarantor's first stage in reading a personal guarantor repayment plan.
Three sections can reach a gift made before the bankruptcy application.
| Section | What it reaches | Window for a child | What has to be shown |
|---|---|---|---|
| 165, preference | A transaction that leaves a creditor, surety or guarantor better placed in the bankruptcy | Two years ending on the date of the bankruptcy application | Creditor, surety or guarantor status, causation of the bankruptcy process, and a desire to prefer (presumed for an associate) |
| 164, undervalued transaction | Includes a gift, a transaction in consideration of marriage, or one for significantly less than she gave | Two years ending on the filing of the bankruptcy application | Deemed for any transaction with an associate in the window. The text also requires causation |
| 164A, defrauding creditors, from 26 May 2026 | An undervalued transaction made deliberately to put assets beyond creditors' reach | None stated | Deliberate intent, to the NCLT's satisfaction |
What the Jaipur bench held, in three points.
No debt, no preference
The son was not shown to be his mother's creditor, surety or guarantor, so section 165(8)(a) was not met, although he was an associate and the handover fell within two years.
No link to bankruptcy
The trustee showed no causal connection between the handover and the bankruptcy, which the bank sought after her repayment plan was rejected, so section 165(4) also failed.
Ownership left open
The bench declared neither the son nor other relatives the owner, and left trust property and excluded assets to be decided on proof of title.
Do I have to give the jewellery back because the bankruptcy trustee has asked?
Not on a letter alone, but answer it, because what you write may later be read against you. Sections 164(1) and 165(1) say the trustee "may apply to the Adjudicating Authority for an order", and for a guarantor of a company that authority is the NCLT (section 60(1) and (2)). A gift completed before the bankruptcy application stands until such an order is made.
So the first question is what the handover was. A completed gift made the jewellery yours. If it was only lent to you for a purpose, or left with you for safekeeping, it may still be hers, and her estate takes in "all property belonging to or vested in the bankrupt at the bankruptcy commencement date", the date of the bankruptcy order (sections 155(1)(a) and 79(6)), unless it is an excluded asset or property held "on trust for any other person" (section 155(2)).
Key takeaway. A completed gift needs an NCLT order to undo. Jewellery only lent to you, or kept for someone else, raises a different question, who owns it, and that is decided on proof.
What did the NCLT decide in October 2026 about jewellery a bankrupt mother gave her son?
That the handover was not a preference (IA (IBC) No. 244/JPR/2026, NCLT Jaipur Bench, order of 12 October 2026, with the trustee and the mother both represented and the son not a party). The mother, a guarantor of a company's debts, was declared bankrupt on 26 May 2025 on the bank's application after her repayment plan failed. The trustee later learnt that 192.49 grams of her jewellery had gone to her son in 2023 and had been pledged for a gold loan of about Rs 11.3 lakh by August 2025 (paragraphs 2.1 to 2.5).
Mother and son first called it a gift, the son telling the trustee it was "lawfully gifted to him in 2023" (paragraphs 2.4 and 2.5). Her reply said it was ancestral jewellery held in trust under family custom or relatives' jewellery left with her for safe custody, and that she had handed it over in late 2023 only so that he could raise money for his education, to be returned (paragraphs 3.5 to 3.8).
The son was "undoubtedly an associate" and the handover fell within two years of the bankruptcy application, but the relevant period "does not enlarge the category of transactions which constitute a preference" (paragraphs 8 and 10). No material showed that he was her creditor, surety or guarantor under section 165(8)(a), and the trustee did not show under section 165(4) that the handover caused the bankruptcy process to be triggered, since the bank applied after the repayment plan failed (paragraphs 9 and 11). The presumption for associates "cannot dispense with the substantive requirements" of section 165(8) (paragraph 7). The application was dismissed only "insofar as" it sought a preference declaration and vesting on that basis, and the bench declined to declare who owns the jewellery (paragraphs 21 and 22).
In April 2026, on different facts, the Hyderabad bench went the other way. A father paid his daughter Rs 45 lakh on 31 January 2023, against Rs 50 lakh she had advanced in September 2022 for a bank guarantee to release his passport, inside two years of his bankruptcy application of 18 October 2024. The bench held the payment a preference and ordered a refund within 30 days (IA (IBC) No. 1963 of 2025, 17 April 2026, paragraphs 30 to 35), and Jaipur distinguished it because that daughter stood as a creditor (paragraph 12). In a connected order the same day, Hyderabad treated a Rs 5 lakh payment to the son as a preference, although it found too little evidence that the payment was made without consideration, because "its effect is to benefit an associate over other creditors" (IA (IBC) No. 1972 of 2025, paragraph 42). The two benches read section 165 differently, and we had found no appellate ruling on the point at the time of writing.
How far back can the trustee reach, and from which date is it counted?
For a gift to a child, two years back from the date the bankruptcy application was filed. That is the window in section 164(2)(a) and, for a preference to an associate, in section 165(2). Section 165(3) gives six months for anyone else.
You are almost certainly an associate. Section 79(2) covers any relative of the debtor or of her spouse, as well as her immediate family, and rule 4 of the 2019 rules for personal guarantors' bankruptcy ties "relative" to the list in section 5(24A), which names sons, daughters, grandchildren and the spouse of a son or daughter, dependent or not.
For a guarantor, the bankruptcy application comes only after an order in the insolvency resolution process allows it, usually when the repayment plan is rejected or never submitted (section 121(1)), and that can be years after the company's default. In Jaipur the trustee put the filing at 20 December 2023, so the window reached back to December 2021 and the 2023 handover sat inside it, although the bankruptcy order came on 26 May 2025 (paragraphs 2.2, 2.6 and 3.8).
Anything handed over after the application is filed, and before the bankruptcy order, is void under section 158, and sub-section (2) says such a disposition "shall not give rise to any right against any person, in respect of such property", even where it was received in good faith, for value and without notice of the filing.
Section 164A, inserted with effect from 26 May 2026 by the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code (Amendment) Act, 2026, read with S.O. 2625(E), sets no period. It reaches an undervalued transaction entered into "deliberately" to keep assets "beyond the reach" of claimants or to harm their claims. No order we have read decides whether it reaches a gift made before 26 May 2026.
What must the trustee prove under sections 164, 164A and 165?
Under section 165, that you were her "creditor or surety or guarantor for any debt of the bankrupt" and the transfer left you better placed in her bankruptcy (section 165(8)), that it fell inside the window and caused the bankruptcy process to be triggered (section 165(4)), and that she was influenced by a desire to prefer you (section 165(6)), which section 165(7) presumes for an associate. Jaipur held that these were for the trustee to establish, and that the mother's weak explanation "cannot supply an ingredient" the section requires (paragraph 16). Hyderabad said the burden of proof "shifts significantly" to an associate to justify the transfers (IA (IBC) No. 1972 of 2025, paragraph 30).
Section 164 asks less of the trustee where the recipient is a child. An undervalued transaction includes a gift and a transaction "in consideration of marriage" (section 164(6)), section 164(3) deems any transaction with an associate in the window to be undervalued, and the ordinary-course defence in section 164(5) is not available for an associate. What remains in the text is section 164(2)(b), that the transaction "caused bankruptcy process to be triggered", the requirement on which the Jaipur trustee failed under section 165(4). No order we read applied section 164 to a gift to a child, so none says how that requirement works for a deemed undervalued transaction.
Under section 164A the NCLT must be "satisfied" that the debtor acted deliberately, for one of the two purposes the section names, and the transaction must be undervalued in one of the ways section 164(6) lists.
Does acting in good faith, or paying for the jewellery, protect me?
Not as the child. Section 166 shields a person from an order under section 164 or 165 only where the interest was acquired or the benefit received "in good faith", "for value", without notice of the undervalue or preference, without notice of the bankruptcy application or order, and by someone who "was not an associate of the bankrupt" (section 166(1) and (2)). All five conditions must be met, and the last shuts out a child or a child's spouse.
The section may protect people who dealt with you, such as a jeweller who bought it or a lender who took it in pledge, if every condition is met. Unlike section 166, section 164A's proviso protects no interest acquired from the debtor or her associate, such as you, or anyone who "was a party to the transaction".
Payment cuts both ways. On our reading a purchase at a real price is outside section 164A, but inside the window section 164(3) still deems a transaction with an associate undervalued, and if the jewellery came to you in repayment of money you had lent her, you were her creditor. That is the Hyderabad pattern, where a family loan repaid inside the window was twice held a preference.
What if the jewellery was never really hers, or it is my stridhan?
Then the question is ownership, decided on proof. Property your mother held on trust for another person is outside her estate (section 155(2)(b)), but in Jaipur "a bare assertion of third-party ownership or entrustment cannot, by itself, conclusively determine beneficial title" (paragraph 14). Hyderabad, by contrast, accepted that bond money the bankrupt received only as a nominee and paid on to the beneficiary was outside his estate, because the bank entries tied the two together (IA (IBC) No. 1972 of 2025, paragraphs 33 to 36).
Section 79(14)(c) excludes only "unencumbered personal ornaments" of the debtor or her immediate family "which cannot be parted with, in accordance with religious usage", capped at one lakh rupees by rule 5(a). So the whole 192.49 grams could not be excluded merely on an assertion of religious or family usage, and the pledge made the "unencumbered" point significant (paragraph 17). Her disclosure of family assets in Form E, her statement of financial position, was "relevant for investigation but is not conclusive of title" (paragraph 18).
Stridhan changes less than families expect. It describes a woman's ownership, as our guide to stridhan and dowry explains. Your mother's own stridhan was hers to give, and none of the exclusions in sections 155(2) and 79(14) mentions stridhan. Jewellery you received as stridhan at your wedding is yours, but section 164 asks when it came, and section 164(6)(c) lists a transaction "in consideration of marriage" as undervalued. On our reading a wedding gift inside the window is not saved by being stridhan, while an older one can be reached, if at all, only under section 164A. We found no order on the point.
Common mistake. Changing the story. In Jaipur the jewellery was a gift in the emails and a limited entrustment in the reply. The bench said that "An absolute gift and an entrustment for a limited purpose are legally distinct", and the inconsistency stopped it accepting, on her assertion alone, that all of the jewellery was held in trust for others (paragraph 15).
What should I keep as evidence, and what should I do now?
Keep everything that fixes when the jewellery changed hands, where it came from and what the family said about it at the time. What we see go wrong in family-company insolvencies is rarely the law and usually the record. Jewellery moves between relatives without paperwork, often in the anxious months after a bank recalls a loan, and when the trustee writes years later each relative remembers the handover differently. One true account, given once and backed by documents made at the time, serves a child better than fresh declarations.
- Ask the trustee in writing which section he relies on and when the bankruptcy application was filed.
- Write down when the jewellery came to you, on what occasion, and where it has been since, including any locker, pledge or sale.
- Collect invoices, family records of inherited pieces, wedding photographs and gift lists, and the bank record of anything you paid her or lent her.
- Settle, with advice, whether it was a gift, a loan of the jewellery for a purpose or safekeeping for others, and give that one account in writing.
- Do not sell, pledge or pass on the jewellery while the question is open.
- If the trustee applies to the NCLT, answer each element: the window, whether you were ever her creditor, the link to the bankruptcy and who owns the jewellery.
The records that mattered most in these orders.
The filing date
Both windows count back from the filing of the bankruptcy application, given as 20 December 2023 in the Jaipur case and 18 October 2024 in the Hyderabad case.
Bank entries
In Hyderabad, bank statements traced each payment, so family loans repaid were held preferences and nominee bond money was kept outside the bankrupt's estate.
Earlier correspondence
In Jaipur, emails calling the jewellery a gift sat against a later reply saying it had only been entrusted to the son for a limited purpose.
Frequently Asked Questions
My mother gave me the jewellery at my wedding years ago. Can her trustee still claim it?
Under sections 164 and 165, only if the wedding fell inside the two years before the bankruptcy application was filed. For an earlier gift the only avoidance route is section 164A, which needs the NCLT to be satisfied that the gift was made deliberately to keep assets from her creditors, and no order we have read decides whether it reaches gifts made before 26 May 2026. Keep the records that fix the date.
I paid my mother for the jewellery. Is it safe?
A real purchase is not a gift, which matters for section 164A. Inside the two-year window, though, section 164(3) deems any transaction with an associate to be undervalued, and if the jewellery was really repayment of money she owed you, section 165 may apply, as it did to two family loans repaid in Hyderabad. Keep the bank record of the payment.
The jewellery was given to my wife, not to me. Is she treated differently?
No, on the definitions. A son's or daughter's spouse is a relative under the list in section 5(24A), which rule 4 of the 2019 rules adopts for section 79(2), so she is an associate too. That the jewellery is her stridhan describes her ownership, and on the words of section 164 it does not by itself take a gift made inside the window out of the section.
Is a mangalsutra or other religious jewellery protected?
Partly. Section 79(14)(c) excludes unencumbered personal ornaments of the debtor or her immediate family that cannot be parted with under religious usage, up to one lakh rupees in value under rule 5(a). In the Jaipur case the mother's reply said her earlier statement of affairs had disclosed a mangalsutra worth Rs 1.5 lakh, and the bench held that the whole 192.49 grams could not be excluded on an assertion of religious usage.
The jewellery came from my grandmother. Does that help?
Only if it can be proved. In the Jaipur case the mother said that ancestral pieces, and items bought for the future spouses of the family's grandchildren, had come to her from her late mother-in-law to be held in trust under family custom. The bench did not accept that on assertion and left it to proof of title (paragraphs 3.5, 14 and 21). On our reading, records of the grandmother's ownership made at the time count for more than a family declaration made now.
The NCLT rejected the trustee's preference claim. Is the matter over?
Not necessarily. The Jaipur order dismissed the application only so far as it sought a declaration of preference and vesting on that basis, and said it was not deciding ownership, trust property or excluded assets (paragraphs 21 and 22). It did not consider section 164 or 164A. We had found no report of an appeal against it at the time of writing.
Where will the dispute be decided?
For a personal guarantor of a company, before the NCLT, which under section 60(1) and (2) hears the guarantor's insolvency and bankruptcy, usually at the bench dealing with the company. For other individuals the Adjudicating Authority is the Debt Recovery Tribunal under section 179(1).
The trustee first reported that my mother had no assets. Can he still come after the jewellery?
Yes. In the Jaipur case the trustee had told creditors, on the information then available, that there were no assets, and the bench held that this could not stop him investigating property that came to his knowledge later (paragraph 19). Investigating the bankrupt's affairs is the first of the trustee's functions under section 149.
This article is for general informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Consult a qualified advocate for advice on your specific situation.






