Property & Real Estate Law

My Agreement for Sale Has an Arbitration Clause: Can the Builder Force Arbitration Instead of K-RERA?

By Advocate Sharan Jain

My Agreement for Sale Has an Arbitration Clause: Can the Builder Force Arbitration Instead of K-RERA?

No, not on the strength of the clause. Signing an agreement for sale whose dispute clause says arbitration does not remove your right to complain to the Karnataka Real Estate Regulatory Authority (K-RERA), because that right is conferred by the RERA Act. When Bengaluru builders asked K-RERA to send buyers' delay complaints to arbitration, its adjudicating officer refused and the appeals against those refusals failed. The clause still has teeth: it can hold you to arbitration if you pick it yourself or later consent to an arbitrator, it gives the builder a route for its own money claims, and whether such disputes are non-arbitrable as a class now sits before a Division Bench of the Bombay High Court.

Part of the RERA and homebuyer disputes practice at S Jain & Attorneys, Bangalore.

This guide is for a buyer in a registered Karnataka project who has spotted the clause while reading the agreement, before any dispute or complaint exists. The decision that counts comes later, once the promised possession date passes: which forum to approach first, because the Supreme Court has held buyers to the forum they chose. If you have already filed at K-RERA and the builder has answered with an arbitration notice, our guide on replying to the builder's arbitration notice after a K-RERA complaint picks up from there.

Where a claim against the builder can go, and what the clause does to each route:

RouteWhat it can decideImpact of the arbitration clause
K-RERA Authority, complaint under Section 31Refund with interest if you withdraw, or monthly interest for the delay if you stay (Section 18)None by itself. The builder must apply under Section 8, and K-RERA refused such applications in 2019
K-RERA adjudicating officer, Section 71Compensation under Sections 12, 14, 18 and 19The same. K-REAT dismissed a builder's appeal against such a rejection in January 2020
Consumer commissionRelief for deficiency in service, including delayCannot displace a complaint you chose to file there, on Supreme Court rulings of 2018 and 2026 under the 1986 Act
Civil courtOnly what K-RERA cannot decide, because Section 79 bars the restWhere a suit lies, Section 8 obliges the court to send it to arbitration on the builder's timely request
Arbitration you beginDamages for the delay as the arbitrator assesses them, which reached 15 percent a year in a Delhi caseFully effective: the Karnataka High Court appointed an arbitrator on a buyer's own petition in March 2026
Arbitration the builder begins for sums it claimsThe builder's claims for balance price or extra chargesThis is the builder's route, pending the Bombay reference on whether such claims can be arbitrated

Four pointers from day one:

K-RERA stays open

Section 31 lets any aggrieved person complain to K-RERA, and its adjudicating officer refused builders' 2019 applications to send buyers' delay complaints to arbitration.

Arbitrability is unsettled

On 7 October 2026 a Bombay High Court judge referred to a larger bench whether promoter-allottee disputes are non-arbitrable as a class, and it remained unanswered at the time of writing.

Buyers can complain jointly

The Explanation to Section 31(1) includes an association of allottees or a registered voluntary consumer association, so one complaint can carry many buyers.

Consent settles the forum

In 2025 the Karnataka High Court appointed arbitrators on a builder's petitions against two buyers whose counsel agreed, with arbitrability left open for the arbitrator.

Does signing an agreement with an arbitration clause mean I cannot go to K-RERA?

No. The right to complain is statutory. Under the Real Estate (Regulation and Development) Act, 2016, Section 31(1) lets any aggrieved person complain to the Authority or the adjudicating officer against a promoter or an allottee, and its Explanation includes an association of allottees or a registered voluntary consumer association. Section 71 gives the adjudicating officer the compensation claims under Sections 12, 14, 18 and 19. The word arbitration appears nowhere in the Act, and the arguments built on Sections 79, 88 and 89 are explained in our guide on the builder's notice.

When buyers objected, Karnataka's orders favoured them. In 2019, in delay complaints against SJR Prime, K-RERA's adjudicating officer rejected the builder's applications under Section 8 of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, and on 12 July 2019 the High Court disposed of the builder's writ petitions with liberty to appeal under Section 37(1)(a), expressing no opinion on the merits (W.P. 24637/2019). The Karnataka Appellate Tribunal, which dealt with RERA appeals before K-REAT, dismissed a batch of such appeals on 18 November 2019, and on 8 January 2020 K-REAT dismissed Parkway Homes LLP's appeal against a similar rejection following that batch order (Appeal (K-REAT) No. 126/2020). In 2022 the High Court went further, dismissing a builder's Section 11 petitions because the buyers' complaints on the same disputes were already pending before K-RERA, with liberty to return if K-RERA declined jurisdiction (CMP 504/2021). From 2023 to 2026 the High Court directed K-RERA, in a developer's writ petitions, to decide its pending Section 8 applications, without itself ruling on arbitrability.

Key takeaway. Signing the clause does not shut K-RERA's door. In the Karnataka orders we found, it has taken buyers into arbitration only where they picked arbitration or consented to an arbitrator.

What does each part of a typical arbitration clause in a flat agreement mean?

A typical clause makes five promises.

  • Disputes shall be referred to arbitration. Its reach over RERA disputes is unsettled. The Bombay High Court's 2024 judgment in Rashmi Realty Builders concluded that a dispute between an individual allottee and a promoter covered by RERA is non-arbitral and that the RERA authority's jurisdiction is not ousted by such a clause. A later decision of that court, as Rensar Infra records, read the judgment as confined to the second point, and on 7 October 2026 a judge referred the conflict to a larger bench, endorsing neither view (Rensar Infra, paragraphs 61 to 64). Both camps accept the point that helps you now: the clause does not displace the RERA authority.
  • A sole arbitrator appointed by the developer. Section 10 lets the parties fix any odd number of arbitrators, with one as the default. But under Section 12(5) a person whose relationship with a party falls within the Seventh Schedule, such as the builder's employee, adviser or director, is ineligible, and only an express agreement in writing after a dispute has arisen can waive that. Our guide on a builder picking its own arbitrator deals with clauses of this kind.
  • The seat or venue shall be Bengaluru, in English. Sections 20 and 22 leave the place and the language to the parties, so these words fix the place of arbitration and the language of the papers.
  • Costs shall be borne equally. Section 38 already makes the tribunal's deposits payable in equal shares, on top of each party's own lawyers, as our guide on who pays for an arbitration sets out.
  • The award shall be final and binding. Section 35 says so too, though the award stays open to a challenge under Section 34 within three months of receiving the award.

What have RERA bodies in Maharashtra and Punjab done with the clause?

Every decision we read rejected the builder's objection. On 27 April 2026 the Maharashtra Real Estate Appellate Tribunal dismissed forty appeals by CCI Projects Pvt Ltd in a common judgment that answered against the promoter its plea that the authority lacked jurisdiction because the agreements carried an arbitration clause, with costs of Rs 5,000 to each allottee. It treated Rashmi Realty as binding because the Bombay High Court is its parent court, while noting that the Gauhati High Court had taken a contrary view in 2024.

In Punjab, the adjudicating officer held on 15 March 2024 that a conjoint reading of Sections 79, 88 and 89 leaves no doubt that the remedy under the Act subsists despite an arbitration clause. On 19 February 2026 a Member of the Punjab authority rejected the same objection, advanced by Bathinda Development Authority on a clause in a plot allotment letter, relying on the Supreme Court's Emaar MGF ruling, and ordered a refund of Rs 13,25,756 with interest at 10.80 percent. None of these orders binds K-RERA, but all of them point one way.

When could the clause actually put my claim into arbitration?

In four situations, three of them of your own making. The first is picking arbitration yourself. On 12 March 2026 the Karnataka High Court allowed a buyer's own Section 11 petition over the developer's objection that RERA was the proper remedy, holding, as it read the Supreme Court's rulings, that the choice was the buyer's, and leaving every claim and contention, including jurisdiction, to the arbitrator (CMP 725/2025). The Supreme Court's Emaar MGF judgment of 10 December 2018 had recognised that where a person entitled to a special statutory remedy does not opt for it and is party to an arbitration agreement, the dispute may proceed in arbitration (paragraph 55).

The second is consenting when the builder petitions the High Court for an arbitrator. In October and November 2025 the Karnataka High Court allowed a Bengaluru builder's Section 11 petitions against two buyers after counsel for both parties agreed to an appointment leaving all contentions, including arbitrability, open (CMP 109/2024 of 24 October 2025 and CMP 107/2024 of 14 November 2025). On 22 July 2026, setting aside one of those buyers' 2019 K-RERA orders on a separate ground, it left her, on the builder's submission that the parties had agreed to arbitrate, to pursue relief in that arbitration (W.P. 17842/2022).

The third is a civil suit. Section 79 bars civil courts from anything K-RERA can decide, and where a suit does lie, Section 8 obliges the court to refer the parties to arbitration if the builder applies no later than its first statement on the substance of the dispute, unless it finds prima facie no valid arbitration agreement. That is how a Delhi buyer's delay claims against Omaxe Ltd reached arbitration after the builder's applications in her civil suits were allowed in 2017. The fourth is not in your hands: the builder's own claims for balance price, extra charges or interest on late instalments, which the Rensar judge refused to call sham merely because the buyers disputed them (paragraph 43).

Whichever route you enter first is likely to hold you. On 11 August 2026 the Supreme Court held in Neo Developers' case that buyers who, despite the clause, had elected the Haryana authority and were enforcing its order could not pursue arbitration on substantially the same claims (paragraphs 8 and 9).

How does an arbitral award compare with a K-RERA order once you have won?

They differ in almost every respect. A K-RERA order has the State's revenue machinery behind it: interest or compensation the builder does not pay is recoverable as an arrears of land revenue under Section 40(1), through the recovery certificate process laid out in our guide on executing a K-RERA order. A builder appealing to K-REAT has sixty days under Section 44(2), and under the proviso to Section 43(5) its appeal cannot be entertained until it deposits at least thirty percent of the penalty, or the total amount payable to you including interest and compensation, as our guide on the builder's appeal and pre-deposit walks through.

An award, once the time for a challenge under Section 34 has expired, is enforced under the Code of Civil Procedure as if it were a decree (Section 36(1)). The builder may apply to set it aside within three months of receiving it, with an appeal from the court's decision under Section 37(1)(c), and the challenge does not by itself stop enforcement unless the court grants a stay, which it may do on conditions (Section 36(2) and (3)). The money can be better in arbitration: on 14 August 2026 a Division Bench of the Delhi High Court sustained awards in Omaxe Ltd's appeals giving a buyer delay damages at 15 percent a year on the amount invested, in place of the agreement's Rs 5 per square foot, and observed that a buyer who elected arbitration could not be deprived of compensation for that reason (paragraphs 9.2, 9.3, 18 and 23). K-RERA's rate is SBI's highest marginal cost of lending rate plus two percent under rule 16 of the Karnataka rules, as our guide on how K-RERA works out delay interest sets it out. While the Bombay reference is pending, an arbitration you begin carries the same arbitrability risk as one the builder begins.

Common mistake. Telling the builder in a demand letter that you are "invoking the arbitration clause" to sound serious, then filing at K-RERA on the same delay. Under Section 21 a request to refer a dispute to arbitration starts an arbitration of that dispute once the builder gets it, and your own letter can later be presented as a choice of forum.

What should I do now, before any dispute?

Read the clause once, keep your papers, and settle the forum deliberately later.

  1. Highlight the five parts above on the agreement itself: the reference to arbitration, who appoints, the seat and language, the costs and the finality wording.
  2. Keep the signed agreement, the allotment letter, every receipt, bank statement and demand together, and enter the promised possession date in your calendar.
  3. If the clause lets the builder nominate the arbitrator, you can ask before signing for appointment by an arbitration centre or by agreement instead, and a builder may accept or decline.
  4. Do not sign a later letter, addendum or possession document that nominates an arbitrator or records your consent to arbitration.
  5. When the possession date passes, choose the forum before writing to the builder, using the table above, and leave arbitration out of any demand letter unless you mean it.
  6. If you choose K-RERA, file under Section 31 using our guide on running a RERA complaint step by step, and keep every claim about the delay in that one complaint.
  7. If the builder later answers your complaint with an arbitration notice, reply in writing and follow our guide on the builder's arbitration notice after a K-RERA complaint.

Four checks to run on your own clause:

Who appoints

A builder's employee, adviser or director falls within the Seventh Schedule and is ineligible under Section 12(5), unless you waive it in writing after a dispute arises.

Who pays

Section 38 lets the arbitrator fix deposits for the costs, payable by the parties in equal shares, before any award is made.

How it is enforced

An unpaid K-RERA order is recoverable as an arrears of land revenue, while an award is enforced under the Code of Civil Procedure like a decree.

What stays open

Section 31 keeps a complaint to K-RERA open to any aggrieved person, whatever the agreement for sale says about arbitration.

Where buyers slip when the clause is read too late

The trouble we see usually starts with correspondence rather than a courtroom. A buyer who never read the dispute clause first sees it in the builder's reply to a demand for delay interest, and answers by threatening arbitration and K-RERA in the same breath, a letter that later sits on file as the buyer's own election. Others sign a possession-stage addendum that quietly installs the builder's nominee as arbitrator, or treat the clause as a bar and lose a year before filing anywhere. A few begin an arbitration hoping for speed and only then discover the deposits and the arbitrator's charges. Reading the clause before there is a dispute, and settling on the forum before writing anything, prevents all of these.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is an arbitration clause in a flat agreement for sale allowed under RERA?

Nothing in the RERA Act forbids it, and the Act never uses the word. Whether such disputes are non-arbitrable as a class is the question the Bombay High Court referred to a larger bench in October 2026, and it was still open at the time of writing.

If I sign the agreement, can I still complain to K-RERA when the builder delays?

Yes. Section 31 lets any aggrieved person complain, and K-RERA's adjudicating officer refused builders' 2019 applications to send such complaints to arbitration, with the appeals against those refusals dismissed in November 2019 and January 2020.

Can the builder's own employee or director be the arbitrator?

Not unless you waive the bar. Section 12(5) read with the Seventh Schedule makes an employee, adviser or director of a party ineligible, and the waiver must be an express agreement in writing made after the dispute has arisen.

Is the number of arbitrators, the place or the language in the clause important?

Only for how an arbitration would run. Section 10 permits any odd number of arbitrators and defaults to one, Section 20 lets the tribunal fix the place where the parties have not and allows it to sit at any convenient place to hear witnesses or inspect property, and Section 22 lets it order translations of documentary evidence.

If the High Court appoints an arbitrator, who would hear the case?

In each Karnataka appointment described above, a retired judge was named as sole arbitrator, to sit under the aegis of the arbitration centre attached to the High Court in Bengaluru, including the appointment of March 2026 on a buyer's own petition.

Should I choose arbitration instead of K-RERA if the builder delays?

Only after weighing both. A Delhi buyer recovered 15 percent a year in arbitration, but you split the tribunal's deposits, the arbitrability question is open, and the first forum you choose tends to stick. K-RERA applies the rate in rule 16 of the Karnataka rules, an unpaid order is recovered as land revenue, and a builder's appeal comes with a pre-deposit.

Does the clause stop me from approaching the consumer commission?

Not on the Supreme Court's rulings in Emaar MGF (2018) and Abhiyan Cooperative Group Housing Society (June 2026), both under the Consumer Protection Act, 1986, which refused to send buyers' consumer complaints to arbitration. A buyer who has already gone to RERA may be held to that choice, as the Supreme Court held in Kabra and Associates' case in February 2026. Our reader question on consumer cases and arbitration clauses deals with that route.

Can several buyers in my project complain to K-RERA together?

Yes. The Explanation to Section 31(1) counts an association of allottees, or a registered voluntary consumer association, as a person who may complain, whereas an arbitration clause works agreement by agreement.

This article is for general informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Consult a qualified advocate for advice on your specific situation.

References

  1. Real Estate (Regulation and Development) Act, 2016, as published by K-RERA: Section 18(1) refund with interest or interest for every month of delay, Section 31(1) and its Explanation, Section 40(1) recovery as arrears of land revenue, Section 43(5) proviso on the promoter's pre-deposit, Section 44(2), Section 71 and Section 79.
  2. Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996, as amended: Section 8 reference by a judicial authority, Section 10 number of arbitrators, Section 12(5) with the Seventh Schedule and the proviso on waiver after disputes arise, Sections 20 and 22 place and language, Section 21 commencement, Sections 34 to 37 on setting aside, finality, enforcement as a decree and appeals, and Section 38 deposits in equal shares.
  3. Bombay High Court, Arbitration Application No. 205 of 2026, Rensar Infra Private Limited, judgment of 7 October 2026: the builder's claims not sham (paragraph 43), the conflict on Rashmi Realty recorded (paragraph 61), and whether promoter-allottee disputes are non-arbitrable as a class referred to a larger bench, with the Section 11 application deferred (paragraphs 63 to 67).
  4. Maharashtra Real Estate Appellate Tribunal, common judgment of 27 April 2026 in the appeals of CCI Projects Pvt Ltd, Appeal No. AT006000000053079 of 2021 and connected appeals: the authority's jurisdiction is not ousted by an arbitration clause in the agreements for sale, following the Bombay High Court, and forty appeals dismissed with costs.
  5. Supreme Court of India, Neo Developers Private Limited's case, Civil Appeal Nos. 10899-10904 of 2026, order of 11 August 2026, 2026 INSC 875 (non-reportable): buyers who had elected the Haryana RERA authority could not pursue a parallel arbitration on substantially the same prayers, and the parties were relegated to that authority.
  6. Delhi High Court (Division Bench), Omaxe Ltd, FAO (COMM) 53/2022 and 91/2022, judgment of 14 August 2026: arbitral awards of delay damages at 15 percent a year upheld against a Rs 5 per square foot clause, a buyer who elected arbitration not to be deprived of compensation, and the appeals dismissed with costs.

Related Legal Services

Dealing with a matter like this? Our Bangalore advocates can help. Explore the relevant practice areas:

SJ

About the Author

Advocate Sharan Jain

Advocate based in Bangalore, practising before the Karnataka High Court and District, Sessions, Consumer and Family courts. Writes on civil, criminal, corporate, family and constitutional law to make Indian law more accessible.

S Jain & Attorneys · Legal Consultation

Have a Legal Question? We're Here to Help.

Our experienced lawyers in Bangalore offer confidential consultations tailored to your specific legal needs.

All matters handled with complete confidentiality and legal discretion.